3 ms·
"The government guarantees in relation to this series of bailouts are more akin to investments - some of the money will be lost, but not nearly 4 trillion dolla
by chaostheory 18y ago
"The government guarantees in relation to this series of bailouts are more akin to investments - some of the money will be lost, but not nearly 4 trillion dollars."
How do you know? There is virtually no transparency aside from what it costs and where the money is being drawn from? Theoretically they can just use the money for parties and private jets, bonuses, or even purchase stock at double the market price... very sound investment indeed =)
- marvin 18y agoThis is the fifth time you've made this point in this story's comments.
- chaostheory 18y agowell people like you seem to ignore it =) and I still haven't gotten a good counter argument (it's actually just the 3rd time I think) and o yeah the investment argument has also been repeated to no end
- krschultz 18y agoBecause history does not side with you. We made money off the airline bailout in 2001. We made money off the Chrysler bailout in the 60s. While the government may have lost $200 billion in the S&L crisis, much more saved by preventing a longer depression and the associated loss of tax revenue. Expand the length of time and the breadth of the factors you are looking at and all of a sudden even 4 trillion dollars doesn't seem like a bad investment if the return is more than that - even if it is an indirect return.
- chaostheory 18y agoIt depends on historical perspective... it's all in the details. since this is a financial institution bailout (and not say an auto manufacturer bailout) - you've already proven my point. not to mention if you add up all of the gains and losses of previous bailouts (my math may be off so feel free to correct me http://www.propublica.org/special/bailout-aftermaths http://www.propublica.org/special/bailout-aftermaths), it adds up to a net loss of 173 billion dollars (it's probably more because I don't see Amtrak on the list - and that thing continues to lose money even today) (even if history was against me, there is still no good valid excuse for not having public transparency) krschultz your post, a logical and valid response, was all I was asking for. I just think it's lame when someone can't come up with a good counterargument, that they just post a petty complaint as a response