3 ms·
Bailing out individuals (in the cases you mention) makes no sense either. People keep saying that we need to hold banks and investors accountable for the risks
by potatolicious 18y ago
Bailing out individuals (in the cases you mention) makes no sense either. People keep saying that we need to hold banks and investors accountable for the risks they knowingly took.
In the same logic, we must also hold individual consumers accountable for their own actions. Why should I, a responsible, fiscally conservative individual who has very little debt, bail out someone who's swimming in their own material extravagance, living beyond their means from credit card to credit card? Why do I, a person who has never owned a big-screen TV in my life, bail out someone who couldn't keep their wallet in their pocket despite not having the money?
Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of people who are in debt despite their best efforts - we should be helping these people, who I believe are a minority of all people in debt.
Likewise, many of the same homeowners who are getting wiped out mortgaged for a house that was well beyond their income to support. My folks had a number of opportunities during the last bubble to "trade up" - sell our house (which had appreciated massively) and trade up to something larger, so we can flip it for an even higher price later. They didn't, because they didn't believe in a free lunch, and they were perfectly happy with the house they lived in.
I despise how we are blaming banks and investors for their greed (they were greedy) but we look at all consumers as victims. Everyone is screaming for the banks' blood - let them burn for their own irresponsibility... so why can' we let consumers do the same?
- time_management 18y agoDon't get me wrong, there are plenty of people who are in debt despite their best efforts - we should be helping these people, who I believe are a minority of all people in debt. You are wrong on the Internet. Most people in debt are in that situation because of uncovered medical bills.
- potatolicious 18y agoHmm... Point taken. My perspective is distinctively Canadian, and massive unpaid medical bills are quite rare around here :S The majority of "poor" people I know personally are there because of their own indiscretions.
- krschultz 18y agoYes but in the US, the vast majority of bankruptcies are due to our crappy healthcare. A better fix would be to work out a health care system that didn't have such a terrible side effect and then those in bankruptcy would have done something wrong rather than being screwed by a crappy deal in life.
- time_management 18y agoThe motto of for-profit medicine: "Save the body, ruin the life".
- ig1 18y agocitation ?
- time_management 18y agohttp://newstandardnews.net/content/?action=show_item&itemid=1439 http://newstandardnews.net/content/?action=show_item&ite... I'm slightly wrong. It's "half", as "most" requires that the proportion be strictly greater than 50.0%. I'm off by epsilon. Also, I meant to say "in bankruptcy"-- or, more appropriately, "in unmanageable debt"-- rather than "in debt".
- Brushfire 18y agoLet me be clear -- Id rather we bail out no one. But if we must, I still dont see any reason why it is better to go through financing companies than directly to consumers. Why is one better than the other?