7 ms·
Sealand, HavenCo, and the Rule of Law
- rdl 15y agoI realize this is 10-12 years ago, but the analysis here is quite interesting in applicability to other cases -- Megaupload, jurisdictional issues in general, etc. The summary of this over at Ars Technica is great too. (http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2012/03/sealand-and-havenco.ars http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2012/03/sealand-and-...)
- allenbrunson 15y agoI just now submitted that link, as a matter of fact, before I saw this one. I wondered if you'd have any comment on it.
- rdl 15y agoIt's amazingly accurate (I did help him with fact checking about a year ago, and some URLs for photos and things, but I think it was 99% accurate to begin with -- the only thing I pointed out was a purely technical point). He had better insight into the legal issues than we (or any of the lawyers we talked to) did. I still think it failed primarily because the economics changed under our feet (prices went from $2-3k to $20-30 within 2 years), and because we didn't raise enough money. The team could have been a bit better (and would be, today; I was like 20 years old back when we did this, and none of us had done a traditional startup before), but the brick wall we were up against on pricing and financing was pretty much a deal killer. I don't think any of this is strong evidence against a similar effort working today (not an offshore platform for hosting, but cryptographic systems, or offshore for HR/visa compliance, or just for cost advantages). The basic strategy of trying to push only a single challenge (technical or legal or whatever) vs. trying to innovate on everything at once, is valid.
- tobiasu 15y agoI remember looking at HavenCo's prices frequently, but couldn't afford to host there. For the price you had to make money and we were sailing on voluntary member payments. And what we were doing required serious bandwidth...
- nikcub 15y agoDo you agree with the conclusions about it being better to change the law (since it is supposed to work for all of us) rather than attempting to subvert it? I think eventually some smaller nations will catch on and become secure offshore data and processing hubs, just as today there is an entire economy around offshore finance. We will probably look back at DataCo as being a few decades ahead of time.
- InnocentB 15y agoNauru is (or was) trying to do this. http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/253/the-middle-of-nowhere http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/253/t... is where I heard about it, but this story aired almost a decade ago so I don't know what's happened since. I assume it didn't pan out. Nauru is kind of hard to get information on, because of its obscurity and isolation.
- rdl 15y agoI believe in using purely software or technical means where possible (PGP to defeat unlawful wiretaps, Start-TLS to protect against echelon), followed by social pressure (i.e. "it's rude to rip off someone's work", vs. enforcing it with laws). Do a good job of articulating socially good uses. PGP to protect you from spies is unrealistic, PGP to protect you from the law if you are a criminal is both unrealistic and bad PR, but filevault to protect my SSN when your laptop is stolen, that's a much easier win -- it's just hard technically and inertia, but those are easier than active political or legal opposition to overcome. In parallel with that, try for political change, ideally using tech as much as possible to support that -- I wasn't an Obama voter, but what the 2008 campaign did with social media was transformative. If all those fail, sure, consider doing something crazy like Sealand or offshore corporations or whatever, but ultimately I'd rather live in a first-world country WITH good laws, than something with technical or jurisdictional hacks.
- harshreality 15y agoHow would a similar extra-legal data haven work today? Let's say cost is not an issue - some people with deep pockets have things they think are worth it to host outside the law, and will pay you with bitcoin (run through a bitcoin pool operating on the extra-legal territory itself). How do you get around the fact that all your internet links will be run by companies in real countries subject to legal orders? How do you get around the fact that any ragtag band of pirates can board and take over your "island" nation? Do you hire a team from G4S to guard your ship? G4S or any other security entity would be subject to laws and court orders, too. If it's not a ship, but an actual island, you still have most of the same problems. Even if it's populated to provide some measure of physical security (you can't bomb an island with innocent civilians on it without a lot of bad press, not that other governments would need to bomb to shut you down), won't the existing government care more about protecting tourism and/or the interests of the natives before they care about protecting a data haven? http://imageshack.us/f/546/havenco.jpg/ http://imageshack.us/f/546/havenco.jpg/
- rdl 15y agoFor hosting static data, it's trivial to build a distributed cryptographic system which is arbitrarily censorship resistant. The trivial way is to distribute a large file encrypted, then once it's widely seeded, publish the key. It's really hard to censor a short string, basically as hard as censoring an idea. For transaction processing systems which need to be durable, I'd go with something with multiple levels of indirection on the network, using links which are locally secure for short periods of time. Sort of like tor/onion routing with hidden services. You might still put your processing nodes in a concrete fortress of some kind, but they're basically anonymous data processing equipment. Use tamper-resistant technology and the worst that happens to them is denial of service. The point of having a published high profile physical location (like Sealand) is to claim jurisdiction there, and thus get some legal benefits in interacting with other jurisdictions. To the extent that everything can be done on the Internet, you don't particularly need that.
- polyfractal 15y agoFurther, if you're hosting content that makes governments unhappy (say, WikiLeaks-esque data that casts other sovereign nations in a bad light, or actively hurts their country like a list of undercover operatives), what is to stop them from using their military to take over your sovereign country? Wars happen all the time, and you have no military of your own.
- ayuvar 15y agoI was really surprised at their server farm; I always figured (from the original Wired article) that it was fairly busy with servers. I guess losing the fiber optic link kind of ruined that. Or, you know, having to put your customers' data into a Zodiac to hang out on a plank of metal in the sea.
- rdl 15y agoThat photo was early in the buildout, but yeah, it was a single 300 square foot circular room in one of the towers with 5-10 racks, loosely populated. We planned to raise $3-5mm plus followon financing, and ended up raising only $1.5mm or so, most of which was spent on mechanical/life safety upgrades to the facility -- we didn't have a whole lot left for datacenter. Losing the 155Mbps link was a big problem -- the best we had was 4xE1 (8Mbps), some caching/CDN, and 128-512k of satellite. Thus, our costs never dropped the way we wanted, so we couldn't really be price competitive. Wired has a 3-6 month lead time, so the Wired article actually got written while we were first looking at the buildout. This happened to overlap with the collapse of the dotcom bubble.
- ayuvar 15y agoI can see a definite advantage in cooling being that close to the North Sea. How far down did the towers go? Was the entire hollow space within them basically inhabitable (if uncomfortable)?
- rdl 15y agoEach side was 7 (I think) hollow 300sq ft concrete rooms, circular. We had forced air circulation, and AC in the "datacenter" tower (which was 2 rooms of datacenter, some power conditioning, and a NOC); just forced air in the residential one (and some heating using electrical heaters). During the war, those towers were where people lived, and the lowest levels were shell magazines for the big AA guns (3.9"?). They had a bigger superstructure, too. I absolutely would not have wanted to have been there with 300 people; even with 6-10 it was pretty bad.
- shabble 15y ago
- shimon_e 15y agoI just saw your profile states you founded havenco. Seems this submission is getting a lot more traction than my one 12 hours ago. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3764331 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3764331
- ChuckMcM 15y agoThis should be mandatory reading for "Internet generation" entrepreneurs. It is a clear exposition on why people need to engage their local institutions to change the law to meet their needs, rather than to try to create from whole cloth new institutions. When folks argue that changing the law of the land is 'hard' I do not disagree, but when they say creating something new from scratch is 'easier' I do. Like a manager who just sees the effects of the software and not how it achieves those effects, creation tends to look easier to the ignorant than to the experienced. Anyway, there are great lessons to be learned in the story of Sealand.
- wisty 15y agoI think the review plays down one thing - time. Sealand may (I'm not a lawyer, and certainly not an expert in the laws of statehood) become a state if: * It stays independent. * It obtains a sustainable population. * Commercial independence. Not just as a "data haven", but hydroponic food production, and stuff being built there (possibly just IP, but more than just what you get from legal arbitrage). * A functional community, with a rule of law. Not too likely. The platform is simply to small to support any of this.
- rdl 15y agoIt would be way easier to find a "real" country and convince them of the merits of doing a favorable free trade zone, than to try to rehabilitate Sealand. (our plan was actually to use Sealand to get press, and then develop both technical means like anonymous ecash, and political means (going to various neutralish countries to try to sell them on the idea), which is why we did such a big PR campaign)
- excuse-me 15y agoThe trouble is that you need to get enough customers quickly enough that they have more power than the governments opposing you! eg. Switzerland, Lichtenstein, Monaco, the Channel Islands, most of the caribbean etc. The US could probably manage to shut any of them down if their 'customers' didn't have so much political clout in Washington The difficulty is going to be getting enough customers who donate more to US politics than the MPAA/RIAA
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- stcredzero 15y agoMy version of a datahaven: A series of small cases with a 12 volt auto plug, a small fanless computer, some batteries, and a 3G wireless connection. Hire some vehicle operators to keep it plugged in while they are moving. Once started, they will need a daily activation code to keep operating, otherwise they erase their hard drive encryption key and deactivate, requiring their encryption key to reactivate. The small cases will constitute a low-powered cloud with no permanent address. If a case is seized in a raid, it becomes inactivated.
- vegardx 15y agoYour version of a datahaven seems flawed. What if no-one want to sell you connectivity? How will you manage what adresses they are accassible on? Heck, you even made your data trackable down to a few meters by using GSM.
- stcredzero 15y agoYour version of a datahaven seems flawed. Granted. I was just thinking of what could be done with off the shelf parts. I think the scheme can stymie anyone without a wiretapping or a search warrant. Eventually, the law will change to adapt. How will you manage what addresses they are accessible on? Steganographic messages posted on darknets over TOR. Heck, you even made your data trackable down to a few meters by using GSM. My design goal is to let the authorities eventually shut down the operation, but still deny them any information when they do. I think that's as far as one can practically go with off the shelf hardware.
- rdl 15y agoPeople talked about things like that after Tunisia and Egypt, for local organizing (maybe combined with SMS, BTS, etc. capability). A lot of the most interesting data is both highly time sensitive (where are police suppressing riots right now) and local (within a few blocks). I suspect there's a fair bit of USAID, DOD, etc. funding available to make reliable systems like that. It would also be great post natural disaster, some kind of automated repeater and bulletin board system which works with an existing base of smartphones.
- samstave 15y agoI sent the article over to Ryan Lackey via Quora to see if he had any comments. Maybe he'll come post here as well. (Ryan Lackey was founder of HavenCO.) HAHA edit: RDL is already in this thread! I sent before looking at the comments :(
- moonchrome 15y agoIf I was a billionaire I would probably buy Nauru[1], it's a 21km2 independent island state with <10k people and GDP ~30M$, which comes at 3000$ per capita. I would offer 50.000k$ to every citizen (more than they will earn in 15 years), which comes down to 500M$, to abdicate authority trough democratic process and move off the island (or possibly stay and work for me). Then build your own benevolent dictatorship that's already recognized internationally as a state. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nauru http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nauru
- newman314 15y agoThe problem with this is that that is just the first step. Having a nation with no alliances means that you will pretty much be invaded with impunity. But given the way certain nations have been behaving of late, having your own nation may not make much of a difference.
- moonchrome 15y agoIn my fantasy billionaire scenario hiring PMC would be a viable option. Also, with lot's of cash to throw around - how hard would it be to build an alliance with neighboring states, bribing politicians, "friendly relations", etc. You would probably trade with them anyway, build a few facilities there to please the people/sell the story.
- techiferous 15y agoYou'd have to be creative with the economy. Nauru is literally made of shit. The phosphate-rich soil has been basically completely mined, so it has very little natural resources. It's very expensive to have humans living on an island with little natural resources. You'd have to be very creative in your business model to make this work. But I imagine that's your point entirely: the business model would be founded on the "benevolent" dictatorship which would have the latitude to create a completely unique economic system that could attract particular types of business ventures.
- moonchrome 15y ago
- shawnbaden 15y agoI'm ignoring the core issue here but I just want to say: SEALAND IS AWESOME The location and structure itself I mean. What a sweet pad that'd be. Sure, it makes no sense from an economical standpoint. Or if you value safety. Or any logical reason really. But it's awesome. That is all.
- algoshift 15y agoCan a privately launched satellite in orbit be considered free from control from any one nation? Would my satellite be sovereign territory? Might this be an idea for the future of DNS and highly-independent web hosting in some form? No cooling problems for shure! Of course, there's the minor issue of a connection to the wired internet... I want a .orbital TLD! Forget the "cloud" how about "space"? Hmmmm, isn't there a prominent web entrepreneur who's building a rocket company?
- smhinsey 15y agoI think you got the cooling problems backwards. In vacuum it's a lot harder to get rid of excess heat than it is inside an atmosphere. Latency might be a bit of a bummer.
- algoshift 15y agoHere you go: http://www.tak2000.com/data/Satellite_TC.pdf http://www.tak2000.com/data/Satellite_TC.pdf
- Zaak 15y agoA government doesn't have to take down your satellite if they can persuade you to do it for them. Jail time can be a powerful persuasion. And if your orbiting data haven is objectionable enough there's always http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-satellite_weapon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-satellite_weapon
- dotBen 15y agoRight now none of the major satellite-owning countries will ratify an agreement on the sanctity of space - and specifically satellites. In real terms that means any country could shoot your satellite out of orbit regardless of whether you're obeying any given country's law or not.
- smallblacksun 15y agoThe Outer Space Treaty specifically says that no country can claim sovereignty over outer space or celestial objects, that countries retain ownership of anything they launch into space, and that they are liable for damage they cause to any other countries space objects (or people on them). The treaty has been signed and ratified by all major space faring nations, including the US, Russia, China, and all major European countries.