2 ms·
So you want to make financial transactions more expensive and make the market less liquid? What good can come of this? Fewer stock market bubbles, less asset i
by anigbrowl 3y ago
So you want to make financial transactions more expensive and make the market less liquid? What good can come of this?
Fewer stock market bubbles, less asset inflation.
- gruez 3y agoMarket bubbles aren't caused by stocks trading back and forth. They're caused by irrational exuberance and macroeconomic factors.
- anigbrowl 3y agoPeople are less likely to be irrationally exuberant if there's an up-front cost to trading, no? Having to write a check (to to speak) to the government feels like real money, as opposed to the fantasy of sure-thing future profits that naive margin traders and property flippers may kid themselves into.
- gruez 3y ago>People are less likely to be irrationally exuberant if there's an up-front cost to trading, no? Stock bubbles promise to return your investment several-fold. See: stocks like Tesla or even Zoom (during the pandemic). A 10% tax isn't going to dissuade anyone from the prospect of making 500%. It will dissuade someone from buying broad-market ETFs or mutual funds that return on the order of 5-8% a year.
- anigbrowl 3y agoI don't see why. Nobody buys an ETF to make a fast buck, they buy ETFs to just sit there and compound at low risk.
- gruez 3y agoPeople already have trouble stashing away money in favor of immediate consumption. Forcing them to take a loss of 10% immediately upon investment basically makes saving much less attractive, especially if their future is uncertain. If for whatever they had to liquidate their investment they'd suffer a loss of 20% before any gains.