4 ms·
One of the most important lessons I got from high school came from my history teacher: instead of testing that we had learned the book by heart and were able to
by palata 3y ago
One of the most important lessons I got from high school came from my history teacher: instead of testing that we had learned the book by heart and were able to "copy-paste" the right parts into our test, she was looking for critical thinking.
In a typical test, she would give us all kind of articles (with the source: date, author, journal, country, etc) and ask us to analyze it. Not only it required us to understand the historical context ("the author is talking about this event that happened at this place for this reason"), but we had to show critical thinking: "he comes from this country and has this religion, so I would assume that he has a bias towards this", etc. To the point where we could even choose which questions we wanted to answer in the test. "It's okay to have completely forgotten about this event, just pick a question about some historical context you know". She was not testing our capacity at learning everything by heart (of course we had to learn something, otherwise we could not answer any question at all).
It took her time to establish that. Many students hated her, because they would usually easily make good grades by "learning the book by heart", and they were failing here. But at least for me, when I started understanding how it worked I also started loving this class. Somehow I did not feel like another pointless class where I would optimize my grades: I was actually improving my critical thinking. I was getting something out of this class other than good grades. Reading my history book now was not about learning facts, but trying to understand the context through the lens of the author.
I think that every teacher should strive to give that kind of feeling to their students. Then ChatGPT would not be a problem anymore: it becomes clear that it is not trustworthy. If some like to use it as a tool (e.g. because they need ChatGPT to give them keywords that they can use in further research), that's fine. Those who take the output of ChatGPT for granted have just missed the point, they may as well do nothing.
- dopidopHN 3y agoJust for context, what you describe is standard end of high school history test in France.