3 ms·
> Is it unethical for a student to use ChatGPT in this case? I think this is the wrong question to ask. The real question is: "is it smart for a student to use
by palata 3y ago
> Is it unethical for a student to use ChatGPT in this case?
I think this is the wrong question to ask. The real question is: "is it smart for a student to use ChatGPT instead of doing their homework?". And probably it is completely stupid. School is not an adversary, school is here to teach. If students manage to trick the system to get good grades while staying stupid, it doesn't really hurt anyone other than themselves.
- mdorazio 3y ago> School is not an adversary, school is here to teach. This is debatable, at least in the US. In many cases, higher ed is here to offer a credential and network regardless of true aptitude since many students will simply not use the majority of what they are supposed to be learning in their career. Put another way, students were already using things like ratemyprofessor to deliberately tailor their courses for easier grades back when I was in school, plus memorizing older exams rather than studying the core material in detail, or just straight up paying someone else to write papers for you. AI is an extension of this, not something new.
- palata 3y ago> This is debatable, at least in the US. Then instead of fixing the AI problem in your broken system, maybe fix the system? Maybe I'm being naive here, and we're doomed anyway.
- CptFribble 3y agoSome students will always try to cheat, that is inevitable. But saying that whether schools are for teaching is "debatable," while a popular meme, is a false and harmful assertion. Regardless of what you or any of us consider to be "proper education" or "good teaching," even if higher ed really is just about getting certified for jobs, the simple fact is that the purpose of school at any level is to learn various skills and facts, and any form of direct-to-the-answer interferes with that. I saw this a lot when GPT3 first came out, many people on HN and elsewhere decried the existence of book reports and essays, rejoicing that such "worthless" tasks would go the way of the dinosaur. However, all who say such things miss the crucial insight: the point of the book report is to learn and display reading comprehension. Similarly, essay writing is only about learning to communicate with essays specifically in the first one or two classes you encounter such tasks. After that, essays are used to communicate your command of the material for subjects that cannot be easily broken down into multiple-choice or short-form exams. Allowing students to use AI tools to do their homework for them is a massive step backwards, and an unimaginable risk to the future of our society. If we allow our children to use AI to do all their work for them, especially during crucial reading comprehension years, they will arrive at adulthood unable to process anything more complex than a menu. And relying on AI to summarize and communicate information that would otherwise be written into a document of some kind is an even bigger risk - then the controllers of the AI would essentially control how we process information in general, because no one would be able to do it themselves. 21% of adult Americans are already illiterate, pre-AI. 54% read below a 6th-grade level. What kind of world are we building if we push those numbers even higher?
- palata 3y agoI totally agree. The hard part is to get students to understand why the exercise is useful. It is easy to lose one's time writing an essay. But if you lose your time, it means you are doing it wrong; better not to do it at all.
- whimsicalism 3y agoTracking is prevalent everywhere in the American education system and means that this argument is wrong. If you are getting downtracked because everyone else is cheating with ChatGPT, that's bad.
- palata 3y agoSure but as I said above, instead of fixing the ChatGPT problem that happens because of the broken education system, maybe there is an opportunity to improve the education system.
- whimsicalism 3y agoIn my view, tracking has a necessary place - and does not mean the education system is broken.
- palata 3y agoWell, tracking is good if it helps the student learn. But if it is commonly admitted that the students need to trick the system to get higher ed and will then get better jobs because of that, maybe there is something to rethink about how higher ed is valued.
- whimsicalism 3y agoI'm going to learn worse if my track is diluted by a bunch of cheaters. You are adding in a whole bunch of things I never said.
- gnicholas 3y agoThis assumes the schooling is not functioning largely as a signaling device, which at Harvard it may be. I’m not saying students should use ChatGPT on their homework, but I would understand why a student would do so if it allows them to spend more time on side projects, networking, learning about other topics, etc.
- musicale 3y agoIt could possibly be slightly more effective than having someone else lift weights or practice piano for you. You could potentially learn something by reading and copying the answers, or by trying to understand worked examples.