3 ms·
> three of the five words in the The Cat in The Hat title are noncontent words Wat? They're all easily sounded out, and only one word (the) is "non-content".
by WalterBright 3y ago
> three of the five words in the The Cat in The Hat title are noncontent words
Wat? They're all easily sounded out, and only one word (the) is "non-content".
- hotnfresh 3y agoYeah, I’d certainly say “in” isn’t somehow difficult to sound out, though “the” is a bit weird and not necessarily intuitive (plus we don’t always pronounce it the same way)
- WalterBright 3y agoIf you sound out "t" and "h" quickly, it slushes into to the "th" sound. Besides, there's nothing wrong with teaching that "th" has its own sound, just like "ng" has its own sound.
- hotnfresh 3y agoThat’s exactly what they do—I think they call that a “blend” (I’m not a teacher, I just know lots of them) when they’re teaching phonics, and they don’t try to do some insane thing like treating the two letters as meaningfully separate, but teach them as a unit that makes one sound. It’s what to do with the “e” that’s a bit tough to guess, I should think—and that’s not consistent, at least in American English, because we’ll say it like “thuh” or “thee” depending on context. “Thus” without the S, or “these” without the SE.
- WalterBright 3y agoPeople hear "the" so often I can't believe the kids have a problem with pronouncing the "e".
- hotnfresh 3y agoIt’s more that it’s not a word you can rely on them to sound out, if they don’t know what it’s supposed to be. And, anyway, not all “sight words” are difficult to sound out—it’s a kind of loose category of short words that occur so often that you must not need to sound them out to recognize them if you’re going to read fluently. Of course any successfully reader will accumulate even more words that they recognize at a glance (that’s why the “jumble all but the first and last letter” trick works—fluent readers rarely need to sound out words, and don’t really look at every letter, so they can still read texts so-jumbled with little difficulty) but sight words are taught that way explicitly, from early on, almost like learning the alphabet. They do know what “the” sounds like, spoken, they just might not be able to figure out that “the” represents that sound (or may struggle with it longer than you’d expect). Other sight words are very straightforward, but lots are subtly tricky for early readers (“of”—that’s gotta be the word “off”, right? The sound the same letters make in “often”, surely? But no.)
- WalterBright 3y agoI'm sorry, I just cannot fathom anyone having trouble sounding out "the" and recognizing the result.
- hotnfresh 3y agoEarly readers will often attempt several sounding-outs of a word, out loud, one of them correct, and fail to recognize that they have just spoken aloud a word that they know. Sometimes they’ll do it when it’s the only attempt they make. They just won’t process the sound the same when they’re sounding the word out, as they do when they say or hear the word naturally. “Hooking up” those two parts of the brain, if you will, is part of how you get them to be good at sounding out words (aside from memorizing the various sounds letters and letter-combos might make) and usually just comes to them as they practice more.
- codersfocus 3y agoThe problem as I understand it is that schools have stopped teaching students to sound out words and instead are teaching words as pictograms. https://nypost.com/2023/09/17/columbia-quietly-closes-down-teachers-college-project-that-ruined-countless-lives/amp/ https://nypost.com/2023/09/17/columbia-quietly-closes-down-t...
- hotnfresh 3y agoWhat’s weird about this just getting traction in the media now is that the Golden Age of whole-language was decades ago, AFAIK. Academics had data to show it sucked and a list of reading pathologies that could be traced to it by 2000 or so, and had had those long enough for consensus at that level to have already swung to “um, yeah, this is very bad.” It’s still hanging on in many schools, at least in part, so I’m glad everyone’s talking about it now (my kids have seen a bit of it, and the main effect each time has been to make them worse at reading, temporarily, for reasons that are obvious if you look at the work they have them doing) but it’s weird to see stuff I was hearing about from education students as fairly settled science in the ‘00s brought up like it’s a brand new finding. This has been known to be bad for a long time, what’s news is a bunch of folks running schools and school districts won’t let go of it. Like the guy at your tech job who hung his hat on some bad database tech and just will not stop pushing the damn thing.