2 ms·
>I can run models locally on my laptop, so no, it isn't. Which is irrelevant if tens of thousands of other AIs, from entities with 4-5 orders of magnitude more
by coldtea 3y ago
>I can run models locally on my laptop, so no, it isn't.
Which is irrelevant if tens of thousands of other AIs, from entities with 4-5 orders of magnitude more times the resources and power over the economy/society/country than you use them for surveillance and to optimize to your detriment.
The claim was never was about the logical or practical impossibility of AI to also be used otherwise.
And facial recognition is just the tip of the iceberg of AI uses in surveillance.
Nor is "blurring out faces" much consolation. What's blurred in, say, a public "Street View" service doesn't mean is also blurred on the same company's raw captured data. And the example wasn't about such cases, but about surveillance cameras anyway - which don't blur anything, just use the AI to identify targets.
We should instead of arguing the point (and especially, the point at large), instead of nitpicking on the speaker's expression, while onstage, during a conference panel talk - as if those would be the best formulated and exhaustive.
- insanitybit 3y ago> The claim was never was about the logical or practical impossibility of AI to also be used otherwise. Well, yeah, it actually was the claim. It's literally the headline and I even quoted directly from the article where they say that there is literally 100% overlap between AI and surveillance. If you want to say "that was hyperbole", congrats, you've arrived at the premise of my comment.
- coldtea 3y agoEver heard of nuance and context? >If you want to say "that was hyperbole", congrats, you've arrived at the premise of my comment. The premise of the comment was more like saying a headline like "WWII is deadly for Europe" is BS because Switzerland was just fine.
- insanitybit 3y agoI think I was pretty clear and reasonable about where I think hyperbole would have been appropriate and where I think it wasn't appropriate. Disagree if you'd like.
- bigfudge 3y agoTo within an order of magnitude that’s probably true. Local llm use is a rounding error at present and likely to remain so outside of specialised application s like scanning. For child porn on your mobile, which you still have no control over.