3 ms·
Science and technology are fundamentally about overcoming limitations and enabling previously impossible things. The process is ethically neutral, or oblivious
by nine_k 3y ago
Science and technology are fundamentally about overcoming limitations and enabling previously impossible things. The process is ethically neutral, or oblivious if you will. Once you discover nitration, it will be used to produce both hunger-reducing fertilizers and devastating explosives. One cannot be discovered without the other, because they often involve the same chemical compounds.
If you used said limitations to protect something you value, you have to start looking for a better protection. It's a constant process of adaptation. It cannot and should not be stopped. Instead we should be looking for ways to adapt, preferably ahead of time. Restrictions work to a rather small extent.
Be fully aware that a new scientific or engineering breakthrough will have all the potential to result in more deadly weapons, invasion of your privacy, undermining democracy, exacerbating inequality, putting you personally out of job, and disrupting whatever else you hold dear. It's always high time to think about factors which would eliminate or at least limit such consequences, and these must be positive factors, things people do willingly and profitably, not bans.
It's time to think not how to ban the privacy-invading AI (it will never work), but how to have a smaller footprint that may be used to invade your privacy, and, most importantly, how to run things in such.a way that invading your privacy is not profitable, even though still possible. And, inevitably, learn to live with even less privacy by default.
- pjmorris 3y ago> The process is ethically neutral, or oblivious if you will. I like 'oblivious' here, as it seems to me a matter of chance about who will achieve a breakthrough. It does seem to me that once a breakthrough is achieved by someone it will be used to enhance their power over others (counterexamples welcome!) To my mind, this power calls into doubt its ethical neutrality. Yes, it is the people in possession who are making the ethical choices... but they are ethical choices enabled by the technology.
- bamboozled 3y agoYou've left out the "unintended consequences" bit? Soil degradation at scale from fertilizer use? Ocean run off? It's time to think not how to ban the privacy-invading AI (it will never work), but how to have a smaller footprint that may be used to invade your privacy, and, most importantly, how to run things in such.a way that invading your privacy is not profitable, even though still possible. And, inevitably, learn to live with even less privacy by default. When 50%+ of the cars driving around your city are Google / Waymo cars which are essentially intelligence gathering tanks with unparalleled surveillance capability, I don't see how anyone is going to be reducing any footprints ? Cashless society? Home assistant robots that "phone home"? Face it, this is not going to be getting better anytime soon. We can try adapt all we like but maybe we should just be walking around with EMP emitting back packs on if we care about our privacy?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hooverd 3y agoTechnology is only neutral if it's not being applied, which is the whole point of technology.