2 ms·
> While I'm not aware of any technology that claims to classify faces as liars the rest of the statement is broadly true. And if you wanted to cross-check a fac
by robertlagrant 3y ago
> While I'm not aware of any technology that claims to classify faces as liars the rest of the statement is broadly true. And if you wanted to cross-check a face against a database of known liars, the entire statement is true.
Well, I don't think the "bad character" thing is there either. The problem is with these statements is they are lies that contain some truth. Cameras exist. AI to try and detect basic facial expressions exists. Mapping from basic facial expressions to underlying emotions exists. But I doubt many people are trying this, except as a way to justify a marketing budget (we want to push our smile numbers from 8% to 8.2% - give me $5m for my marketing department). And I have never heard of anything connecting "liar" or "bad character" to AI detection.
> And if you wanted to cross-check a face against a database of known liars, the entire statement is true.
Filling in the gaps with technically true statements should not justify the emotional change in you this sort of article seems to be trying to engender. It's pretty much not true, and the bits that might be true and honest - e.g. emotion detection - doesn't work well, and is probably not deployed anywhere.
As for using facial recognition to replace time cards, and replace photos of banned customers - sure? Might work?
- ethanbond 3y agoI see the reverse “lie that contains some truth” in your argument. Obviously this stuff will be used for all of these purposes as soon as it’s able, and probably a little bit before then.
- robertlagrant 3y agoAs soon as AI is able to tell a liar from a video of them? What does that mean?
- ethanbond 3y agoAs soon as it’s able to detect lying, it’ll be used for that purpose. Probably a little bit before it’s actually capable of doing it reliably.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> As soon as it’s able to detect lying, it’ll be used for that purpose. That's not the thing I was talking about. > Probably a little bit before it’s actually capable of doing it reliably. I think you said that already?
- ethanbond 3y agoOkay sure let’s take your “bad character” version: of course this is being done. Someone already linked to a commercially available version of it for shoplifters. Of course this type of technology was used to identify protestors in Hong Kong. It was probably also used to identify Jan 6’ers. And in fact you yourself already hedged that this probably is happening, “ But I doubt many people are trying this, except as a way to justify a marketing budget.” Aka you believe that at least some people are already attempting this.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Aka you believe that at least some people are already attempting this. This is getting painfully repetitious, but that was about facial recognition, not deciding if someone's a liar or is of bad character via AI. > Identifying protesters isn't the same as an AI filming you and deciding if you are of bad character. Same comment.
- ethanbond 3y agoGot it so we agree facial recognition will be dramatically amped up; we agree AI-based polygraphing will exist; you don’t think AI-identify-bad-intentions-button exists currently and therefore we are supposed to doubt that AI is a major surveillance hazard. Am I reading this right now?
- robertlagrant 3y ago> so we agree facial recognition will be dramatically amped up It may be. Not that it will be. > we agree AI-based polygraphing will exist We didn't mention lie detecting, but no - I was saying liar detection, which was the thing from the article, also sounds like fear-mongering. > you don’t think AI-identify-bad-intentions-button exists currently Yes. > therefore we are supposed to doubt that AI is a major surveillance hazard No, that's a category error. "Major" and "hazard" are far too vague to decide upon. Will AI be used in surveillance in some capacity? Of course - it likely has been for decades, depending on how you define AI. But implying that you'll walk into a shop and be classified as a liar based on a video feed is not right. I understand websites need emotion for clicks, but I don't think it's right to do it this way.