4 ms·
It is for the six and seven figure heart surgery/NICU baby/cancer treatment. Edit: My question is, is Sesame paying the doctors less, or are you actually payi
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
It is for the six and seven figure heart surgery/NICU baby/cancer treatment.
Edit: My question is, is Sesame paying the doctors less, or are you actually paying $29 for a Nurse Practicioner/Physician's Assistant?
- ethbr1 3y agoAnd technically, that's what health insurance always should have been for. Allowing insurers to step in the middle of smaller, everyday health transactions by empowering them to negotiate price fundamentally screwed up the system. There's no reason insurance should be involved in non-catastrophic or routine pharmaceutical purchasing.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThe US government does offer a massive carrot for people to choose high deductible health plans, in the form of the most tax advantaged account you can have, a Health Savings Account. The root problem is most Americans are too poor to afford healthcare at the current prices of doctors/medicines/medical equipment/liability protection/etc, period.
- creato 3y agoUsing an HSA can be a pain in the ass. On multiple occasions I’ve had to go back and forth with the provider and HSA to get an acceptable receipt. I ended up just giving up in one case because it was a small amount and not worth fighting phone reps and automated systems.
- mcny 3y agoI thought the whole point of an HSA was to be used as a tax shelter. I didn't get one because it seemed way too complicated and also I don't make nearly enough money to set aside money in an HSA but that's what I remember when looking up on it a little. I think you're not supposed to use it actually for healthcare, at least not in your young age.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI do not know why that would be difficult, I have never had an issue getting a receipt with patient name, charges, and the amount on it. Also, the ideal way to use an HSA is to not use it. Every year, transfer the HSA funds to Fidelity, invest in VOO or whatever, and let it ride as long as you can. PDF all the receipts, and then pay yourself with tax free income when you finally need to.
- mighmi 3y ago> pay yourself with tax free income when you finally need to My understanding's that direct withdraws are possible after 65, taxed as income. Does your "when you finally need to" mean only withdrawing for healthcare reasons or is there a way to transfer or withdraw without a tax hit, besides for health costs?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoYes, worst case scenario, it performs as an IRA/401k. But pretty much everyone will incur healthcare costs as they get older, so you should be able to withdraw tax free for those. And all healthcare costs incurred by your family during your lifetime while you had an HSA are eligible for reimbursement. Quite frankly, I do not know how auditable a 40 year old medical receipt is. Is the IRS' plan to just take everyone's word for it?
- smsm42 3y agoProbably yes, until they audit you. I don't think many people who want to defraud IRS do it by faking 40 year old medical receipts.
- ethbr1 3y agoMedical expenses is a deduction category that can be itemized? https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc502 https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc502 Never needed it, so don't know all the rules are, but I'd imagine the IRS gets a lot of fraud through it (since hospitals wouldn't report from their side).
- astrange 3y agoMine has stopped even asking for a receipt. But more importantly it's a super-IRA that's the best tax reduction around.
- dpifke 3y agoWho's administering your HSA that you have to provide specially-formatted receipts?! Every HSA I've had[0], I just reimbursed myself for eligible expenses[1] by transferring from the HSA to my regular bank account. That amount then gets reported on line 15 of form 8889[2] the following April. If it's not an eligible expense, that's between me and the IRS—not the bank at which my HSA is held. [0]: I highly recommend Fidelity, for anyone reading this and thinking they need a better option. [1]: https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i8889#en_US_2022_publink37971yd0e238 https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i8889#en_US_2022_publink379... [2]: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f8889.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f8889.pdf (PDF)
- Breza 3y agoDepending on the specifics of your financial situation, age, and healthcare utilization, it can actually be in your best interest to pay more out of pocket and save your HSA money for retirement.
- MiddleEndian 3y agoFor these kinds of relatively low-cost interactions, the HSA is even more of the same problem as health insurance: It's for people who find paperwork to be a fun hobby. Just tell me how much money I owe you and let me pay. When I find myself at a clinic, I tell them I don't want to use health insurance to pay. They just give me a bill and I give them money.
- wokkel 3y agoThe ultimate root of the problem is thinking healthcare works like a bakery: if the bread is too expensive i'll go shopping elsewhere or even choose something else besides bread. This last option is basically off the table in healthcare: you either get healthcare or die. Which in the usa seems to be the options indeed.
- monero-xmr 3y agoThe solution is to have universal catastrophic insurance for all citizens automatically, say $100k or some number. Combine that with tax-deductible health savings accounts and a competitive retail healthcare market, you find a sweet spot between universal and for-profit. Anyone who thinks the universal model standard in Canada and the UK is actually working has a hole in their head. The solution is a combo.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIt is not as easy as that because supply is heavily constrained. You need a lot more people able and willing to become doctors, nurses, people who change bedpans and clean hospital rooms, so on and so forth. Add in aging populations with fewer proportionate working age people, and the equation does not balance. That is not something any policy change can fix until far in the future. In the short term, all that is possible is deciding who gets allocated the available healthcare.
- monero-xmr 3y agoNurse practitioners have been allowed by states to handle more and more services. Telehealth primary care has enabled more scaling - I know because I use such a service for my whole family. I’m much, much more confident in the US to handle an influx of immigrants and aging retirees than Canada or the UK with their rigid services.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoYes, one of the ways that the limited resource of doctor time will be allocated is to simply have increasing portions of the population see people less qualified than doctors (perhaps not bad from a systems point of view if it is diagnosing conjunctivitis, but from an individual point of view, you can see where this is going.). You pay more, you get people who have met a higher standard of education/experience, e.g. concierge care and direct primary care practices.
- 3y ago
- jimt1234 3y agoWould those procedures cost "six and seven figures" if it wasn't for health insurance? To put another way, would the costs be so high if it wasn't for the current health insurance system, where the "consumers" are actually the health insurance companies themselves and patients like you and I have basically no power to choose, well, anything.
- huytersd 3y agoThe prices have got to be up there. It’s taking up dozens of hours from multiple highly skilled workers at the very least. That with the use of very expensive medication and some very complicated machines adds up.
- Projectiboga 3y agoI don't know if it is insurance or the administration on both the provider and insurer sides. I have a horrible respiratory infection in western Europe, here I'd have likely died or been so overcharged I'd wish I had died. There 17 days in ICU on a ventilator and a few weeks or normal hospital recovery the total bill in 2001 was under $20K, the Euro and Dollar were almost even then so the conversion isn't important. Now if a local had needed that bed more I might have not been as lucky. This is what a well organized society can do, keep everyone under some level of free care so there is less chaos in their ER departments and that they'd have time to treat a foreigner well. If we switched to single payer the estimates are that we'd save money as a nation the first year, even with all the backlog of needed care and any transition costs. The savings would compound as preventive care started preventing more serious outcomes and things like car insurance and liability insurance would come down in cost too.
- huytersd 3y ago[dead]
- gdcbe 3y agoHuyterds, they don’t cost that much in Belgium though, US medical prices are out of the roof.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TylerE 3y agoI imagine your appts/per hour go WAY up when it's a 5 minute voice chat versus occuyping a room in a physical building for an hour, having a nurse take vitals, all that ancillary stuff.
- smsm42 3y agoProbably the latter, buf this would frequently be the case now in other providers too. Unless you want to wait for 2 months.
- Ekaros 3y agoNICU baby feels so weird. Why isn't that covered by Medicare or something else? Like why isn't basic health-care for children under whatever age 18 or 16 fully covered by government? At least to certain level.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoBecause babies and kids do not vote. Why is Medicaid a separate thing than Medicare? Because poorer people are less likely to vote than older people. The US is composed of very fractured tribes, that people move in and out of throughout their lives. And US politicians are tasked with keeping taxes extremely low, and services very high, and the various tribes do all they can to give disproportionately little relative to how much they benefit.