3 ms·
I have a friend that builds his own drones (and RC vehicles, like a really big, fast tank). He sneers at DJI, but keeps one to entertain the mensch (that's me).
by ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago
I have a friend that builds his own drones (and RC vehicles, like a really big, fast tank). He sneers at DJI, but keeps one to entertain the mensch (that's me).
He also sneers at licensing, jailbreaking, geofencing, etc.
I notice that there aren't any pictures that actually show people in close proximity to the drone. The "drone in hand" picture looks photoshopped, so I assume the drone is actually not-so-mini. I have a teeny-tiny drone, about half the size of a sparrow. It doesn't have cameras, though.
- SparkyMcUnicorn 3y ago> The "drone in hand" picture looks photoshopped, so I assume the drone is actually not-so-mini. Folded (without propellers): 148×94×64 mm (L×W×H) Unfolded (with propellers): 298×373×101 mm (L×W×H)
- coder543 3y agoThe size of the drone is not some secret... you can search for the Mini 4 Pro on YouTube and find a bunch of hands-on reviews. The DJI Mini drones are very compact. The DJI Air 3 is arguably the next level up in the lineup, and it weighs 3x as much and is noticeably larger. The "teeny-tiny drone" you're describing just doesn't sound comparable or particularly useful.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoIt isn’t useful at all. Quite boring, frankly. I just realized the DJI that my friend has, is a mini. It’s small, but some of his hand-built ones are smaller.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- palata 3y ago> It’s small, but some of his hand-built ones are smaller. Aside from the size, how do his hand-built ones compare in terms of camera, gimbal, remote controller, radio, battery life, and potentially SDK?
- serf 3y agofrom experience I know that the SDK and battery life are better on the mid-range DIY options/ Aftermarket remotes/radios are arguably better; just not as compact and conveniently set-up. I can't comment on camera/gimbal. There are DIY-ish units out there that are entirely controllable via your choice of language; i'm not sure if there is any SDK that rivals that flexibility. all that said : I understand the DJI value proposition, but the company has practices that I try to avoid entirely in my life, regardless of how nice their drones are.
- palata 3y ago> from experience I know that the SDK and battery life are better on the mid-range DIY options SDK in DIY options? Do you have examples? > I can't comment on camera/gimbal. Cameras and gimbals become very difficult in DIY, because they required tight integration with the drone.
- cultofmetatron 3y agowould love to get an alternative but it doesn't seem like anyone else is getting anywhere near the flight times that dji has. all the non dji drones I've seen list 8 min while dji is saying 15-20 min.
- oceanplexian 3y agoThere are lots of them like the Explorer LR that are under the 250g limit, and get 30-40 minute runtime. That said in the hobbyist community power is more interesting than range. I have a DJI mini 2 and the technology is impressive but honestly, it puts me to sleep compared to my 100MPH mini quad. Every time I use it (once every few months) I have to update the app, use a trash remote, and install all this spyware on my phone.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThat’s almost exactly what my friend says. He has this tiny little quad, about half the size of the DJI, that does about 90. He has pretty fancy video gear. He uses a VR-style headset. It’s pretty cool.
- FpUser 3y agoAsk him how long it can fly at 90. Few minutes at most.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoWhy does that matter? Top Fuel dragsters are designed for a quarter mile, you wouldn't use them for a 400 mile round-round. Different things have different purposes.
- FpUser 3y ago>"install all this spyware on my phone" You do not need to install spyware on your phone. It is a spyware on it's own. So are Alexa, "smart" TVs and many other things.
- 3y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoHmm… it’s interesting, the reaction I got to this personal anecdote. It is what it is. This chap exists, and I talk to him, almost every day. He has a great deal of enthusiasm, and does interesting work. I am sure his approach is quite common, in the HN crowd. My friend is not your typical DJI customer, and his approach is no threat to them. People like him have always been around. It’s like people that mod cars. They don’t threaten the mainstream. But the reaction seems to have been quite defensive.