4 ms·
> how were funds stolen by hacking into a database? Sometimes "decentralized" really means "running on a theoretically distributed network, but practically we
by lxgr 3y ago
> how were funds stolen by hacking into a database?
Sometimes "decentralized" really means "running on a theoretically distributed network, but practically we host all the nodes/have emergency root keys/exclusively provide the software running on them and the clients used to access them – only for now, we promise!"
This particular project also seems to heavily lean on Intel SGX, according to its most recent public whitepaper from 2018 [1] and also seems to offer wallet recovery using only a user's mobile phone number and a 6-digit PIN [2] – combine that with not too many actually administratively distributed nodes, and it's not too hard to imagine what could have gone wrong...
Edit: Actually the entire proposal sounds ridiculous, unless I'm missing something: The protocol claims to offer secure, yet recoverable device-local keys, but it all seems to boil down to a trusted and independent set of signer nodes (see above for problems), as well as users being able to store a "per-device ephemeral secret" securely and locally, with backup considerations basically left as an exercise to the reader, and the reference implementation seems to just upload that backup to a central API... [3]?!
[1] https://mixin.one/assets/Mixin-Draft-2018-07-01.pdf https://mixin.one/assets/Mixin-Draft-2018-07-01.pdf
[2] https://tip.id/ https://tip.id/
[3] https://github.com/MixinNetwork/ios-app/blob/9e11dd02953297facd20ac7b4d54317382584481/MixinServices/MixinServices/Services/API/TIPAPI.swift#L20 https://github.com/MixinNetwork/ios-app/blob/9e11dd02953297f...
- dboreham 3y agoThat white paper reads like the blockchain equivalent of a The Onion article.