6 ms·
J. G. Ballard’s brilliant, “not good” writing
- optimalsolver 3y agoAnybody who hasn't should read his short story: "Report On An Unidentified Space Station". http://geosci.uchicago.edu/~kite/doc/roauss.htm http://geosci.uchicago.edu/~kite/doc/roauss.htm
- TylerE 3y agoAudible has an anthology the collects basically all the short stories - it’s like 60 hrs long.
- john-tells-all 3y agothanks! title is "Complete Short Stories", and yes it's 63 hours long! I love Ballard, so this is a fine investment.
- TylerE 3y agoI need to break it back out myself. I made it through the first ten hours or so. It’s not that I didn’t like it… it’s just so dense and disturbing. Not exactly binging material.
- TylerE 3y agohttps://www.audible.com/pd/The-Complete-Short-Stories-Audiobook/B00MU2VLLI https://www.audible.com/pd/The-Complete-Short-Stories-Audiob...
- breezeTrowel 3y agoGetting real strong "backrooms" vibes from this.
- robocat 3y agoStory discussed on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34203778 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34203778 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26405515 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26405515
- lmm 3y agoRead this link against my better judgement and found it very dull (I find this usually happens with things recommended as "anyone should read x", without any detail). What do you like about it?
- LispSporks22 3y agoI’ve read many of his short stories, but not that one. Loved it. Thanks for mentioning it
- jamesgreenleaf 3y agoIf you like this, read House of Leaves.
- BruceEel 3y agoInteresting take. I do have to wonder to what extent these elements are fully attributable to Ballard himself rather than being a product of experimentation that kind of belonged with the genre back then? Personally, I get a similar impression from Brunner's works from roughly the same period, e.g. Stand on Zanzibar, but perhaps I'm comparing apples with.. non-apples :)
- flenserboy 3y agoGood article. Ballard's tenor and tone are purposeful; it is as if he is trying to present the world of his books through the same sort of lens the world was presented through the media of the day — flat, always something outside what is seen, muted colors, the like [edit: clinical is a word that fits his writing well]. If you have not read Running Wild, I strongly suggest it — this is a prescient book, way ahead of most when it comes to considering what the culture has been busy doing to the kids.
- nickdothutton 3y agoI’d encourage anyone to seek out a couple of his interviews which are available on the usual video web site. An interesting fellow.
- twiddling 3y agoespecially his experiences as a child under Japanese occupation.
- alcover 3y agoThis one struck me : Future Now - Interview with J.G. Ballard. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RELjQkAI1RA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RELjQkAI1RA
- mikhailfranco 3y agoInteresting interview (1986). Narration in Swedish with English subtitles. "I wanted to write about the next 5 minutes, not the last 30 years. The only form of fiction that had the vocabulary of ideas to deal with the next 5 minutes was science fiction. I wanted a science fiction for the present day. It seemed to me that the future was a better key to the present than the past." "What is so strange about the world we inhabit today is the way in which fiction and reality have become reversed. 20, 30, 40 years ago everybody had a clear idea that reality was the external world around you, the world of work, industry and commerce. Fantasy and the imagination was the world inside our head, the private dreams and hopes for the future. Now that's been reversed. Now the external landscapes of our world are almost entirely fictional, made up of advertising and publicity - an artificial man-made landscape. The only point of reality we each of us have is inside our heads. Our own obsessions are all we have."
- karaterobot 3y ago> Putting Ballard on a master’s course list, as I’ve done a couple of times, provokes a reaction that’s both funny and illuminating. Asked to read Crash or The Atrocity Exhibition, the more vociferous students invariably express their revulsion, while the more reflective ones voice their frustration that, although the ideas might be compelling, the prose “isn’t good.” I've been in these kinds of courses. I always found the least helpful part to be hearing people's opinions about books, especially what didn't work for them. The opinions of a group of grad students is pretty worthless to me. Even the hotter takes, which can be entertaining, do not forward my understanding of reading or writing. What's much more valuable is acknowledging that it is a book, it was published, people did get something out of it—sometimes many people—and then asking why that might be. I always wanted to break apart the mechanics of the style, the architecture of the story's structure, ask why the author did certain things instead of certain other things, etc. What I got instead was an airing of personal grievances, set vaguely against the backdrop of the story, with thin (or nonexistent) textual evidence as support. I always wanted the professor to say "I don't care, what made you think I would care about what you just said?" but they never did. In fairness, neither did I. But, those classes were my vaccine against academia and literary criticism, so they were not useless and probably saved me from a career of sitting through that.
- broscillator 3y ago> ask why the author did certain things instead of certain other things, I think that the answer to that is unknowable to any mind other than the author's, and the best speculation can come from someone who's digested many of their work for a long period of time. It's certainly an interesting discussion to have if you can find enough people like that but it's tough!
- hotnfresh 3y agoYou can definitely make a good guess at it in some cases. It’s often easier when the writer’s not very good at e.g. plot. Getting too good at it usually means you start automatically spoiling a lot of books for yourself, though. “Why’d this character show up in chapter 3? What do they do for the story? Ohhhh they’re secretly the villain” or “why are we spending so much time with this character right now, in this way? Oh, the author’s gonna kill them.”
- tatrajim 3y agoAn early story of Ballard, "The Voices of Time" blew my young mind as a teenager and single-handedly projected me toward a future career in distant places, a journey I could scarcely have imagined from my life on a remote midwest farm. It was immensely gratifying decades later to have an opportunity to thank the author personally after a lecture in London. Just in case there are any "future me's" out there, here's a link to an unpredictable future adventure. https://readerslibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/The-Voices-of-Time.pdf https://readerslibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/The-Voices-of-...
- damnitpeter 3y agoIncredible, thanks for sharing this.
- ecliptik 3y agoSince I read "Why we are living in JG Ballard’s world" [1] in 2020 I've slowly been making my way through Ballards short stories, and each and every one of them is treat. Some fall flat, but ones like "Studio 5, the Stars" [2] about automated poetry hit hard in the modern context of ChatGPT and AI generated art. 1. https://www.newstatesman.com/long-reads/2020/04/why-we-are-living-jg-ballard-s-world https://www.newstatesman.com/long-reads/2020/04/why-we-are-l... 2. https://readerslibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/Studio-5-The-Stars.pdf https://readerslibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/Studio-5-The-S...
- Insanity 3y agoInteresting, thanks for sharing those links. Have not yet read anything by Ballard but will start with the short "Studio 5, the Stars" which you shared!
- PaulHoule 3y agoI just love Ballard and pity that I took so long as a science-fiction fan to discover him, but of course he is one of those "science-fiction" writers who isn't solidly part of the genre.
- andybak 3y agoAs a 15 year old and avid science fiction reader, I used to badger my English Lit teacher constantly. He always maintained that Ballard was one of very few SF writers he liked and one of the few that he felt were good writers on a technical level. (I haven't read the article yet, but I sense some irony in the air) I still disagree with his definitions but Ballard is definitely special.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoI always felt like those who were good at "writing, on a technical level" never had any interesting stories, or even interesting ideas. Still waiting for someone to suggest a counter-example.
- andybak 3y agoWell. Ballard?
- hotnfresh 3y agoBradbury. [edit] also, if you like short stories and novellas, I found the New Hugo Winners series (in which Asimov had taken a back seat as editor, writing in his introduction, to paraphrase, “I do not understand these kids”) has a way higher average quality of writing than the older Hugo Winners series. The ideas didn’t seem a lot worse to me, either. But I’ve also read a lot more of the regular Hugo Winner series so maybe I just got very lucky with the New Hugo volumes I’ve picked up.
- iainmerrick 3y agoThat reminds me of the HN discussion a little while back of Cordwainer Smith: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35978901 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35978901 In SF, I’d suggest James Tiptree Jr as someone with both great writing skills and great ideas.
- uxp100 3y agoI find Ballard kind of mesmerizing but frustrating. Crash I quite enjoyed, but other short stories I often felt his concerns and subjects quite alien. I join just about everyone else in saying read him, but I would never say he was prescient, as some do. He was chasing after something that feels kinda foreign to me. Too English for me maybe?
- andybak 3y agoHis prescience isn't what makes him interesting. In many ways he is writing about the past and the present. He is unique for his tone. "Ballardian" conveys something immediately recognisable to anyone that's read more than a handful of his short stories and it conveys something that is fairly unique. The recent craze for "liminal spaces" captures some of the flavour. But it's also intrinsically British and very much a 70s thing. Maybe it's just my memory of Britain in the 70s but the movie of Crash failed to capture the right mood, whereas High Rise did remarkably well.
- uxp100 3y agoYes, his fiction feels more of the past other authors writing in the same period. I grabbed a volume of his stories just now, and it starts off with a story that I would say feels very, uh, mid century, The Concentration City. Then Manhole 69, which captures some of that liminal space thing you mention. And then Chronopolis, which seems very mid century to me again.
- davidgerard 3y agoHe was also stupendously influential in post-punk music - not for the music (Ballard had zero interest in music) but for the lyrics. He supplied the imagery for the subgenre. I wrote about it a bit here: https://rocknerd.co.uk/2016/10/25/j-g-ballard-and-music-how-to-write-the-entire-new-wave-into-being/ https://rocknerd.co.uk/2016/10/25/j-g-ballard-and-music-how-...
- andybak 3y agoWithout looking and off the top of my head - Joy Division, John Foxx-era Ultravox, Gary Numan (probably by way of John Foxx... Erm. There are others. Can I peek now?
- spondylosaurus 3y agoLiterally just finished High-Rise last week (which was good but not amazing) and I disagree with the essayist's take here that Ballard's just-good-enough prose is somehow reflective of the themes he writes about: > Not only are his rhythmic cycles, in which phrases and images return in orders and arrangements that mutate and reconfigure themselves as though following some algorithm that remains beyond our grasp, at once incantatory, hallucinatory, and the very model and essence of poetry; but, mirroring the way that information, advertising, propaganda, public (and private) dialogue, and even consciousness itself run in reiterative loops and circuits, constitute a realism far exceeding that of the misnamed literary genre. On a page-by-page level, Ballard's prose is honestly pretty bland. Which is okay! But I don't think it's an intentional act of genius. There were so many paragraphs in High-Rise where 3+ sentences would start with a participle phrase, often back to back. The premise itself of the novel was interesting enough, so I managed to turn off my editor brain and enjoyed it for what it was. But there are novelists whose prose does legitimately mirror themes of alienation or paranoia (Pynchon and DeLillo come to mind) and I don't think Ballard is one of them. As an aside, I've tried to read Crash at least three times now but the increasingly unbearable sex scenes keep driving me away. Not that I'm scandalized (if anything, I wish I were!)—they're just such a slog to get through. If I have to read the phrase "natal cleft" one more time...
- smallerfish 3y ago> But there are novelists whose prose does legitimately mirror themes of alienation or paranoia (Pynchon and DeLillo come to mind) ...or PKD.
- spondylosaurus 3y agoHa, Ubik is one of the next books on my list!
- richie_adler 3y agoSafe when taken as directed.
- 3y ago
- yonatron 3y agoOh G-d we need less of this, please.
- thinkingemote 3y agoLove Ballard's novels. Recently finished The Day of Creation which had echoes of Conrad's Heart of Darkness but where the hero this time is Kurtz. Seems like all of his novels are about an everyday man who encounters some unsettling kind of wildness or chaos and then "goes native" and achieves some kind of abnormal stability.
- cgh 3y agoKind of the opposite of Paul Bowles, whose characters seem unable to grasp the alien cultures and situations in which they find themselves, to their peril. Since it's Bowles, most of the time "alien" means "Morocco".
- dang 3y agoRelated. Others? J. G. Ballard, The Art of Fiction No. 85 (1984) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25521617 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25521617 - Dec 2020 (11 comments) Banham avec Ballard: On style and violence (2019) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22701113 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22701113 - March 2020 (7 comments)
- hermitcrab 3y agoI've read a fair amount of Ballard's work and I think really like his prose. It was particularly interesting to read his autobiographical 'The kindness of women' which does a lot to explain the themes that recurr in his work. If you haven't read any of his work, I recommend starting with some of his short stories, such as "The drowned giant". Probably give 'The atrocity exhibition' and 'Crash' a miss, at least until you have read some of his other work.
- davidgerard 3y agoI also highly recommend Extreme Metaphors. It's a collection of interviews with Ballard where he tells you precisely what his writing is about.
- davidgerard 3y agoAnyone who seriously sits down and thinks Ballard's prose isn't precisely what he intended it to be needs to read more widely.
- maxverse 3y agoAm I missing something? I've never read Ballard, but found this article to be pretty terrible. Is it meant to satirize or mimic Ballard's writing? The run on sentences, the [a and b, c and d, e and f] structure, the superfluous language all made this writing feel like a pretentious slog. I feel like I'm missing something.