3 ms·
Genuine question: why is this only published as a PDF? OpenAI have the resources to also publish this as HTML. They chose not to. They're not alone in this -
by simonw 3y ago
Genuine question: why is this only published as a PDF?
OpenAI have the resources to also publish this as HTML. They chose not to.
They're not alone in this - most of the academic and research world, plus the concept of a "whitepaper" seems predicated on the idea of publishing PDFs.
Is this some stupid thing where human beings are expected to attach more prestige to information published in this way?
PDFs are a terrible way of publishing information in 2023:
- they render poorly on mobile devices, where many (most?) people do their reading
- they're hard to copy and paste information out of
- you can't link to headings within them (like HTML fragment links)
- you can't easily run them through translation tools like the one built into Chrome
The benefits of PDF I can see are:
1. Easier to print and get the exact expected output
2. You can save one file offline
3. Easier to author
I'm not arguing to replace PDFs with HTML (though I wouldn't miss them personally) - I'm saying publish documents as both!
Provide an HTML version and a PDF alternative for people who want it.
Am I missing something here? Why does the academic and research world stubbornly stick to such a hostile way of publishing their results?
- solveit 3y agoI would guess OpenAI uses LaTeX as their default choice because they want to write equations.
- behnamoh 3y agoI’ve been using Word Equations and never have I needed to use Latex. I think most people are still under the wrong impression that only Latex can handle math expressions. I use my custom shortcuts in Word to speed it up tho.
- yberreby 3y agoUsing LaTeX does not necessarily imply rendering to PDF. https://ar5iv.labs.arxiv.org/ https://ar5iv.labs.arxiv.org/
- Tijdreiziger 3y ago> they render poorly on mobile devices, where many (most?) people do their reading Acrobat Reader solves this with their ‘liquid mode’. But yeah, it would be nice if there was a FOSS renderer to do the same.
- simonw 3y agoApparently https://www.zotero.org/ https://www.zotero.org/ is an open source tool that can render PDFs in that way - I haven't tried it myself yet.
- lwneal 3y agoI think it's about citation. Traditionally, a pdf is a complete and finished work, analogous to a published journal article or book. It is static content and will not change, unlike HTML which might be "under construction". This isn't necessarily still true: HTML content can stay up on the web forever and a pdf can change, but people still prefer to cite something that looks like a paper document. Since a whitepaper is often meant to be cited, it's published as a pdf to take advantage of this preference. The best approach is to publish a PDF for citation along with a public HTML demo, like https://jonbarron.info/mipnerf360/ https://jonbarron.info/mipnerf360/
- civilitty 3y agoIt's also feasible to track changes this way. Download the PDF and compare the md5/crc/sha hash to an older pdf file - if they're the same, then there haven't been any changes. With web pages, you have to download all the linked files and turn them into a deterministic archive and hope that the Javascript included doesn't pull any dynamic content (which isn't really practical to begin with).
- simonw 3y agoThis is a really convincing answer, thank you.
- behnamoh 3y agoOn top of the other comments, using PDF also makes it harder to crawl data to train or finetune language models. I absolutely hate the PDF format for the reasons you mentioned. I went to long lengths to find PDF viewers with dark mode and Vim key bindings just to make my PDF experience better.