7 ms·
Patents Threaten To Silence A Little Girl, Literally
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- raquo 15y ago> policy should not be unduly influenced by populist emotional response to it Why not? Populism, lobbying – this is standard practice in politics. That's the rules of the game. They will be here for decades if not forever. You either play by the rules and have your voice heard, or refuse to play and get nothing. The fact that this system needs to change in long term has nothing to do with getting what you need today. It's not mutually exclusive.
- fungi 15y agoit's how the patent lobby works (american jobs!) and humanises the story to people who would otherwise tune out. we are fighting with one arm tied behind our backs if we think this is a pure technical debate.
- donw 15y agoOnce again, software patents to the rescue. If the patents involved applied only to the hardware, then this would not even be a case.
- runako 15y agoWouldn't this simply result in a flurry of single-purpose hardware devices that could be patented? If not, why not?
- sologoub 15y agoThat might be so, but if those devices face stiff competition from software running on relatively generic platforms, they are either going to have to be that much better or all they will become irrelevant. In either way, consumers will benefit.
- bobbles 15y ago"None of their options were suited to her daughter, and they all carried hefty price tags—as in $7,000+ hefty. She began asking around to see if PRC or any of the other big companies were planning on releasing an iPad app, and learned that although many customers were clamoring for one, the companies had no intention of meeting their demands. They didn't want an affordable option out there reducing sales of their expensive systems." Time for their business model to die
- amcintyre 15y agoUnfortunately, they can afford the lobbyists and lawyers necessary to buy life support for their business model.
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoThat business model won't die without a fight. Not even HN posts will do it. This sounds like a losing battle, unfortunately.
- cabalamat 15y ago> This sounds like a losing battle, unfortunately. Saarland Pirates would disagree with you.
- olalonde 15y agoOff-topic, but related: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_emotion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_emotion (as much as I hate patents)
- notJim 15y agoVery relevant, IMHO. I don't want to hear "think of the children!1!!11" as an argument against patents any more than I do for or against anything else.
- chime 15y agoWhen people use the "think of the children" argument, they are usually talking about the hypotheticals. "Think of the children" when you let guns or drugs in the neighborhood. "Think of the children" when you legalize prostitution. In this instance however, it is think of this very specific child. There is no hypothetical child here who might be harmed. There is a real, actual child who will lose her ability to communicate if this app is pulled off and remotely deleted from her iPad.
- Karunamon 15y ago>pulled off and remotely deleted from her iPad When Apple yanks apps from the store, they are not remotely deleted from customer's iDevices or PC's. There are a small handful of cases where remote deletion was used, and IIRC, it was all various forms of malware.
- antidaily 15y agoThe word "literally" never gets old, does it? Oh wait...
- smber1 15y agoI'm not blind to the notion that patents exist to protect business (both big and small) however, I still can't help but think, when these sorts of things just end up hurting the consumer then something is terribly wrong! I guess the question becomes, "Overall, are patents good or bad for consumers?"
- TheEskimo 15y agoThat is not at all the question. The point of patents is supposedly to protect inventors and innovators. There is no question that it will (short term at least) hurt consumers; a limited monopoly means a higher price and fewer competing products (if any). People don't argue that patents are good for consumers because they aren't. People argue about if they're good for inventors and technical progress; if inventors will only innovate and share the results with the monetary benefit provided by a patent.
- schiffern 15y agoThe point of patents is to encourage the spread of information by discouraging guilds and trade secrecy.
- luriel 15y agoThe point of patents is not to protect anyone, but to encourage innovation. It has become quite clear that patents make innovation harder (is impossible to create anything anymore without taking a big risk of infringing someone else's patents, and those with patents only use them to slow their progress by their competition, and to avoid having to compete/innovate until their patent expires).
- creamyhorror 15y ago"People don't argue that patents are good for consumers because they aren't. People argue about if they're good for inventors and technical progress" And the point of technical progress is to benefit the public (i.e. consumers) in the long run. So it all comes down to that. The issue is in the implementation and outcomes. As you say, do inventors only innovate+share when provided with the monetary benefit of a patent? It would probably depend on the field, but I suspect innovation would still occur even with shorter patent protections for software design.
- andrewpi 15y agoEven if "Speak for Yourself" is pulled from the App Store, it should continue to work for this girl, correct?
- sosuke 15y agoYes it will continue to work for her, but the mother feels strongly that it should be still available for other children in the same position. If it does go into litigation hell perhaps open source is the answer, let parents build it for the device themselves?
- chime 15y agoTechnically, Apple can remove an app remotely from all iDevies if they are legally required to do so. Whether they will be required to do that in this case is unknown.
- alastairpat 15y agoI was under the impression that the iOS kill-switch was exclusively for rogue apps/malware. Has it been used for legally questionable apps before? A bit of Google-fu didn't turn anything up immediately.
- chime 15y agoThis is horrible. I've spent the last 18 months of my life developing an AAC text-to-speech app too ( http://ktype.net http://ktype.net ) and have dreaded this exact scenario. I've built the app from ground up, solving each problem my users might face on my own - from my own prediction engine to handling unintentional multi-touch taps ( http://ktype.net/wiki/research:articles:progress_20111105 http://ktype.net/wiki/research:articles:progress_20111105 ) without consulting any external sources. One tiny feature (say, allowing the user to change the size of cursor) could get me in the same position if some company owns a patent on it. It is heart-breaking to know that you are absolutely helpless to defend yourself against behemoths with lawyers. By the way, the reason TTS AAC apps are so expensive (Speak for Yourself is $299, Proloquo2go is $189) is not just the developers. If you're using someone's TTS library (no good open-source ones exist), they can contractually require you not to sell your app under a specific amount because they want X% of your sales. And then of course the license fees to various patent-holders. Patent reform isn't just about one-clicks and black-border-around-touchscreen tablets. It's about preventing the stifling of innovation. I built a truly unique feature in KType - guess which of the 2-10 multi-touch taps is intentional (i.e. based on the user's preferences, guess which one is the 'index' finger). As far as I know, no app or system can do this. Without this feature, users with speech and motor disabilities have a very difficult time using a touch-screen. I would love for this feature to be a part of all touch-screens, in the Accessibility configuration. That's why I openly described the algorithm the day I came up with it instead of patenting it. But I could be sued and shutdown because one of the many features of KType was broadly patented by someone two decades ago. I dread being in an industry where trying to help others for barely any money can get you shuttered. I can make 10x more money making an ad/affiliate-network but I love seeing the look on my users' and their caregivers' faces when they are able to use my app to finally communicate after years of needing others' help. I hope this case ends well for Speak for Yourself but honestly, I'm not too optimistic.
- moonchrome 15y ago>That's why I openly described the algorithm the day I came up with it instead of patenting it. AFAIK this is what patents were supposed to do, instead of people locking away their inventions they would give incentives for people to share their knowledge so everyone would get the results but the owner would be able to benefit from publishing. Now it's "property", and people start talking mortality and trying to take moral high ground, starving artists and equating it with stealing, or some perverse economics rationalization focusing on profit as objective. Frankly I don't think I ever heard anyone saying that he read a patent to understand/learn something - although some papers were probably published after they got patents, I know two of those, but I would argue that those patents were blatantly obvious anyway, since I started working on the same problem and arrived at the same solution independently - found those papers after solving the problem/colleague pointed me to them - without even being an expert in the field - they did develop their ideas fully but I'm sure if I kept working on it, or someone else did, they would solve it, and both of those have immediate applications/have been developed for a product so the R&D would have to be done for product development, having it patented provided was not required for the investment.
- PaulMcCartney 15y agoThis case is at it's core, a question of property and rights. As heartless as that may sound, property and rights are principles the United States is built upon. They are laws of the land. The same argument can easily be made to cut profit margins on medical devices. To a further extreme you could argue to take money from the wealthy to pay the medical bills of the needy. I believe that this is what this case boils down to.
- pingswept 15y agoHistorically, you're correct. But the people who codified patent law certainly didn't anticipate the development of software, in which every program of substantial size necessarily uses multiple different patented techniques. Do you think this is the way property rights and software ought to work together?
- runako 15y ago> every program of substantial size necessarily uses multiple different patented techniques Do you think that this is not true of other engineering disciplines? For instance, can an auto maker build a new car without infringing tons of patents? What about robot makers? Airplane manufacturers? Do you believe that nothing that e.g. SpaceX (or your favorite innovation shop) is working on is worthy of patent protection? > Do you think this is the way property rights and software ought to work together? This consequence is clearly horrible. However, let's say there was an innovative physical device (with no software) at play instead. Then we'd say that's exactly how property rights work. We'd presumably be happy that in a few years the rest of society would have access to the device without paying the monopoly rates. The point is the monopoly is an incentive that helps an inventor take an idea from concept to useful product. If the idea had value by itself, we could use my idea for a cancer cure and be free of it tomorrow. (Unfortunately, I am missing the useful -- patentable --parts of the cure.) What specifically is so different about software that would make it unique among engineering pursuits as the only one unworthy of patent protection?
- pingswept 15y ago
- noonespecial 15y agoPatents aren't property, they aren't "self evident rights", and they aren't in any way entitlements. They are temporary monopolies granted by governments based on the idea that monopolies are bad, but they are slightly (and it looks like usually only a very tiny bit even in the best cases) better than the alternatives. When its clear that patents aren't doing their job, and especially in the case where demonstrable public harm is resulting from them, the government should have the right to perform a simple predetermined "due process" like procedure to simply terminate them. Concerned citizens should be able to bring cases like this to the attention of a special office of the USPTO to make this happen.
- slowpoke 15y agoI've said this before here on HN, but you won't fix a system that's a gigantic clusterfuck of bureaucracy by introducing more bureaucracy. There's but one way to "fix" patents, and that's to get rid of them and never try again. We've seen over the last decades (or, indeed, since their inception) that they do nothing but stifle and harm progress, both actively and passively. Today, in a globalized, digitally connected world, progress is speeding up and will continue to do so, probably by magnitudes. The patent system is utterly unsustainable in such a world, and we need to abolish it before it causes even more irreversible harm to humanity.
- noonespecial 15y agoOf course it is and we should, but way too many big money interests have way too much stake in the system to just shut it off. Ron Paul has more chance of abolishing the IRS. Lets just start with the "Be a dick, lose your patent" act. Baby steps.
- ktizo 15y agoAnd after this act comes out, who do you expect to have their patents removed for 'being a dick', would it be the people with cheap lawyers, or perhaps the people with lots of expensive lawyers? Also, this issue is endemic to the whole disabilities industry. If someone has a specific deformity and needs something shaped to that deformity, then that is a patent right there, covering everyone with a similar deformity who needs that functionality. And for some reason this logic doesn't fail the obviousness test.
- moomin 15y agoI wonder if you could go for a surreal argument and go for first amendment rights...
- rbarooah 15y agoI'm not sure that's surreal. Interfering with this child's ability to develop communication is genuinely going to impair her ability to function as a citizen. That's why this case is interesting - it shows that patents have adverse effects beyond deciding who gets to profit from an invention.
- eridius 15y agoAt the moment, it looks like she just plans on turning off all connectivity on the iPad so that it will no longer sync and the app will remain even if it is removed from the iTunes store. Huh? Removing an app from the store doesn't remove it from devices that have it installed. There's no reason to disable connectivity. If you sync the device with iTunes (instead of just backing up to iCloud) then you can keep the app forever.
- ekianjo 15y agoAnalogy in the video games world. If someone had patented 2d scrollers in the 1980s, we would still be waiting for 3d games in 2012. This 20 years monopoly is hilarious. Patents were invented by kings to reward their friends with monopolistic market positions. They have never been designed to promote innovation. Open sourcing is a way better method to achieve that.
- dutchbrit 15y agoWhat happens if they just release this app under a European company. Problem solved right (like all other software patents)?
- tgflynn 15y agoI'd really like to see the main stream press pick up this story. It could help non-technical people understand the problems with patents (especially software patents) and how they adversely affect the lives of real people, and possibly help generate some political momentum for real change in this area.
- jack-r-abbit 15y agoI'm sure my opinion is going to be very unpopular and result in some down votes. That is sad... but it doesn't really matter to me. While a very heart stomping tale, it doesn't change the facts. The article even says the lawsuit and patent look solid. Even the mother says she doesn't care about the legality of the app. People are so quick to jump on the sympathy wagon and rail against the big bad corporation for profiting from all their work. But how many of those people would hold the same view if THEY were the ones who's hard work (protected with a patent) was being used without permission? It really scares me when I see people thinking they are entitled to something for free just because they need it and it costs too much. I think $12 for a movie ticket is way too much but that doesn't make it any less illegal to download a bootleg of it. Do I do it? sure I do. But if I got caught I'd take my lumps like every other "criminal". Sure that isn't going to get the sympathy that this girl will get, but at the end of the day it is the same argument (without the emotional appeal). The ends do not always justify the means. A man who robs a bank to feed his kids is just as much the criminal as the man who robs a bank to buy crack.