4 ms·
>In the end it's more a financial thing IMO. When you just entered a 10 or 15 year lease right before Covid hit, you're now stuck with paying 7 years for an off
by coldtea 3y ago
>In the end it's more a financial thing IMO. When you just entered a 10 or 15 year lease right before Covid hit, you're now stuck with paying 7 years for an office you're not even using - that's objectively bad for any company's financials
That's the definition of the "sunk cost fallacy".
"Hey, I commited to paying for something I don't need. I better force and inconvenience myself to use it then, despite this not having ANY difference in my having to pay the amount anyway".
- civilized 3y agoI think about this all the time. I cannot count how many times I've heard this narrative about RTO being driven by commercial property leases. But I'm not sure it makes sense. Why is it that CEOs were totally fine saying "oops we done goofed and overhired, sorry gotta do some layoffs now" when post-pandemic inflation hit, but they're not comfortable altering or nuancing their strategy in response to what we learned about remote work during the pandemic? I think this is a just-so story. There's more layers to this onion.
- mschuster91 3y ago> I think this is a just-so story. There's more layers to this onion. IMHO, all the amount of issues correlated with RTO are far more complex than an onion. I'd rather compare it with a wool cloth, everything is linked tightly with everything, and the tensions that came from Covid have left some parts permanently deformed.
- Tyrek 3y agoit's a pithy, feel-good explanation that lets the anti-RTO camp feel superior without having to delve into complex topics such as talent development, informal learning, meeting effectiveness, etc. that do not trivially lend themselves to the RTO argument in quite the same way.
- mlazos 3y agoCorps didn’t delve into that nuance with the switch to open office so I wouldn’t pretend that this is some data driven decision.
- steveBK123 3y ago100%. When the alternate to remote is a return to hodge hodge seating in an open floor plan - or worse, hoteling in an open floor plan.. its all theatre. Seating staff level engineers next to the desktop support row, or C-suite admin row, and other loud areas with no virtuous "informal learning" overlap was the norm at my last company. You also get to sit near idiots who want to debate politics all day or talk about the latest TV shows and sportsball. A day in the office without top of the line noise cancelling headphones is essentially a negative productivity day. CEOs want to treat many of us like cattle into pens.
- mydriasis 3y ago"Oops, we dun' goofed, gotta lay people off" is an expression of power in the hands of the CEOs. Altering their plans on RTO to fit the needs of the workers is an expression of power in the hands of those workers.
- PLenz 3y agoFirst: It's a power issue. Employment is at will so ceos feel they have more power (or at least leverage) and can say they're firing ypu for a reason. Leases have the power with the landlords so ceos feel they need to be more circumpect. Second: it's a positioning issue. Ceos are usually thinking about their next gig. Layoffs because we overhired: agressive, good ceoing. Too much real estate: bad ceoing, doesn't look great on the next job search.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- steveBK123 3y agoAbsolutely a power issue. My current employer has been reasonably lenient on RTO, however.. They periodically keep asking people to come in more while actually not even having enough desks in 2 of our major offices. The desk shortage is bad enough you have to beg for consultant desks and every couple months we get a mass mail ordering everyone to stay home next week to accommodate some visitors. So on the face of it, would seem that our company is at full utilization of office space given COVID era remote hiring & hoteling, and yet they still want to nag. They really just want employees in "how high sir?" mode, with tears in our eyes.
- flagrant_taco 3y agoI don't quite think this falls into the fallacy part, though it's definitely a sunk cost. If companies don't have any financially viable ways to offload the real estate costs they have to weigh the pros and cons. Remote work comes with its own expenses, from software licenses only needed for remote teams to home office stipends and team off sites. None of these are required obviously, but expected by most remote workers in large tech companies. I expect it turns into a bit of an actuarial process, trying to estimate how many quality employees you will lose versus the additional expense and potential inefficiencies of remote. Theres also the fact that this is a perfect excuse to cut a number of employees without officially doing layoffs. If you over hired for a few years while the money rolled in you might be happy for an excuse to see people leave.