4 ms·
> What's worse is there's no good reason for it, it's just a power play by execs who are kind of bad at their jobs. In the end it's more a financial thing IMO.
by mschuster91 3y ago
> What's worse is there's no good reason for it, it's just a power play by execs who are kind of bad at their jobs.
In the end it's more a financial thing IMO. When you just entered a 10 or 15 year lease right before Covid hit, you're now stuck with paying 7 years for an office you're not even using - that's objectively bad for any company's financials (and in some cases, bonuses for decisionmakers tied to stuff like "cost per employee").
The other side of rentals, the entire REIT industry, has it even worse, they're in pure panic mode: there are a lot of projects that got completed shortly before, during or after Covid... and that now lack renters while interest rates for refinancing keep going upwards as the free money ran out and central banks imposed serious rate hikes.
And if that's not enough, cities also have a problem... when people don't commute by car, they don't pay road tolls, endangering their financial calculations. When they don't commute by public transport and don't pay subscription tickets any more, the transport authorities get into financial trouble. When storefronts of bakeries, coffee shops and other ancilliary services for office drones get boarded up as no one is in the office any more to buy all that stuff, blight sets in.
Side industries are also hit: when people demand fast Internet at their homes to work efficiently or utilize other stuff such as water, electricity or trash more (because they'd have to expand their long-outdated, barely adequate service), utility providers have to invest serious amounts of money. Car insurances tied to distance driven per year lose money. The list of economic activities directly tied to an economy dedicated to people commuting from their homes to their office is really fucking long.
Hence, there are massive financial interests putting up serious efforts, both political and medial, to push for people to come back to the office even though largely only the already uber-rich profit from that.
- cies 3y ago> When you just entered a 10 or 15 year lease right before Covid hit, you're now stuck with paying 7 years for an office you're not even using Is that not a sunk cost? From here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunk_cost https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunk_cost I got: The bygones principle does not always accord with real-world behavior. Sunk costs often influence people's decisions, with people believing that investments (i.e., sunk costs) justify further expenditures. People demonstrate "a greater tendency to continue an endeavor once an investment in money, effort, or time has been made". This is the sunk cost fallacy, and such behavior may be described as "throwing good money after bad", while refusing to succumb to what may be described as "cutting one's losses".
- PixyMisa 3y agoYes, it's absolutely a sunk cost. Which doesn't mean some companies won't fall into the fallacy, but it's not likely to be the primary reason for RTO.
- plagiarist 3y agoIf you imagine talented employees leaving as a cost (a pretty obvious consequence in the current market) it fits.
- fingerlocks 3y agoWhile all these theories sound plausible, you have to keep in mind that Microsoft does not have an RTO policy. Their campus is 20 minutes from Amazon. They also have a recently completed a decade long reconstruction of their campus, and yet no RTO. So what gives?
- stiglitz 3y agoThe campus reconstruction isn’t finished yet. I’m certainly curious what will happen when it is.
- fingerlocks 3y agoIt’s mostly done. You can work in several of the buildings, and the restaurants are doing practice runs and training. Free meals last week if you time it right.
- Libcat99 3y agoA business is stuck paying for that lease regardless of how many butts are in seats in it. That is a fixed sunk cost they can't do anything about. However, every employee not in the office isn't using office pens, putting wear on office furniture that will need replacement, filling office trash cans that need to be emptied by someone, burning out office light fixtures that need to be replaced, and using office toilet paper that will need replenishment. Bringing them back to the office doesn't make the lease any cheaper, but it does make operating the space more expensive.
- Clubber 3y ago>A business is stuck paying for that lease regardless of how many butts are in seats in it. That is a fixed sunk cost they can't do anything about. There's usually a break lease clause in most contracts, no? I would imagine breaking leases is pretty common in business real estate.
- Libcat99 3y agoIn many cases, yes, and in that case it would make more sense to break the lease than to bring employees back to the office.
- tzs 3y agoFrom what I've read the majority of commercial leases do not have anything covering breaking the lease, so it defaults to whatever state law says happens when there is no prior agreement. That commonly says that (1) the landlord must try to find another tenant, and (2) the leaving tenant has to continue paying until that happens or they reach the end of the lease. Trying to find another tenant does not mean that the landlord has to take any extraordinary actions to do so. They just have to list the property as available and show it to people who show interest, just like they would with any other empty property they have. Thus, it comes down to what the market is like. E.g., when I moved from Seattle I broke a lease, but my apartment was next to the University of Washington. There are always people looking for apartments next to UW so the landlord easily found another tenant. A lot of cities right now have a glut of commercial office space available, with listings staying open for months or years. Someone breaking a lease on office space in such a city would likely finding themselves having to pay to the end of lease.
- coldtea 3y ago>In the end it's more a financial thing IMO. When you just entered a 10 or 15 year lease right before Covid hit, you're now stuck with paying 7 years for an office you're not even using - that's objectively bad for any company's financials That's the definition of the "sunk cost fallacy". "Hey, I commited to paying for something I don't need. I better force and inconvenience myself to use it then, despite this not having ANY difference in my having to pay the amount anyway".
- civilized 3y agoI think about this all the time. I cannot count how many times I've heard this narrative about RTO being driven by commercial property leases. But I'm not sure it makes sense. Why is it that CEOs were totally fine saying "oops we done goofed and overhired, sorry gotta do some layoffs now" when post-pandemic inflation hit, but they're not comfortable altering or nuancing their strategy in response to what we learned about remote work during the pandemic? I think this is a just-so story. There's more layers to this onion.
- mschuster91 3y ago> I think this is a just-so story. There's more layers to this onion. IMHO, all the amount of issues correlated with RTO are far more complex than an onion. I'd rather compare it with a wool cloth, everything is linked tightly with everything, and the tensions that came from Covid have left some parts permanently deformed.
- Tyrek 3y agoit's a pithy, feel-good explanation that lets the anti-RTO camp feel superior without having to delve into complex topics such as talent development, informal learning, meeting effectiveness, etc. that do not trivially lend themselves to the RTO argument in quite the same way.
- mlazos 3y agoCorps didn’t delve into that nuance with the switch to open office so I wouldn’t pretend that this is some data driven decision.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoIt's funny how "very overinflated prices are going just slighly less overinflated" is a catastrophy... Less renters? Lower the price. Many people would like to live in <popular city>, but not at the over inflated pre-covid prices. Commercial realestate? Louis Rossmann has a whole series of videos on youtube about the overinflated mess in NYC. Less traffic jams? How is that bad? Utilities are paid by (water, power,...) usage, and upgrades will be done where there is usage, even "at homes". Car insurances with less distance per year will also pay out less damages, since less distance == less crashes.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Less renters? Lower the price. That's my point: they can't, not with the financing options they have. REIT are virtually stuck. Not that I care much, I just wanted to offer a consolidated explanation for the whole RTO push crap of the last months.
- bastawhiz 3y ago> you're now stuck with paying 7 years for an office you're not even using - that's objectively bad for any company's financials (and in some cases, bonuses for decisionmakers tied to stuff like "cost per employee"). If your goal is to force employees to come back, and many of them quit as a result, now you don't have employees to fill your empty office with and you still owe the same money for the lease. It doesn't take a rocket surgeon to see that coming. > when people demand fast Internet at their homes to work efficiently or utilize other stuff such as water, electricity or trash more (because they'd have to expand their long-outdated, barely adequate service), utility providers have to invest serious amounts of money. Car insurances tied to distance driven per year lose money. Sorry, what? The water company is hurting because I flush the toilet a couple extra times a day on one side of town instead of the other? What extra garage am I producing sitting in my office? An extra wrapper from some lunch? The power that they use in the office almost certainly comes from exactly the same source as the power used by your home. And the whole point of pay-by-the-mile insurance is that you get it because you don't drive very much and want to save money. The insurance companies that don't get paid more when you drive more are the ones that hurt, because you're more likely to get in an accident and you're not paying extra. None of these "side industries" are hurting, and they probably haven't even noticed.
- mschuster91 3y ago> The water company is hurting because I flush the toilet a couple extra times a day on one side of town instead of the other? What extra garage am I producing sitting in my office? An extra wrapper from some lunch? The power that they use in the office almost certainly comes from exactly the same source as the power used by your home. The problem is usage patterns. Residential, sparsely populated districts have lower diameter water mains and sewage pipes, lower electricity feed capacity, small garbage cans with (bi-)weekly pickup, and often times not even enough Internet uplink for people to watch Netflix in decent quality. High density office districts are the exact opposite, and utilities make quite the amount of money on them.
- vladvasiliu 3y agoBut usually people are either at home or at the office at the same time. So if the pipes can handle everyone being at home when they get up in the morning and shower at the same time to make the office at the same time, they could probably handle everyone being at home at noon. It might even be better, since now they can shower at different times. Ditto for electric, since people are more likely to stagger their laundry and whatnot. The only one that seems to apply is garbage, and possibly the internet pipes.
- zare_st 3y agoThere are some American nuances here, although that's 100% relevant for Amazon, I have to put here that some of that business models do not exist in Europe. Stuff mentioned is chiefly state or city owned in Europe and works in different ways. There are no toll booths outside of motorways, the roads are free. People commute by public transport, which is mostly not private. Utilities also; although open market exists, it's always the main company (in most cases owned by country) and alternatives. In my area 15 y.o business space lease doesn't exist. My family company had a 5 year lease contract in the 90s. Nowadays owners want even lesser contracts because the property market is very volatile and prices tend to surge up and not down. This creates problems for normal living space rental, because most of people do not want long term tenants. They want to raise the price every year. Although these kind of models suffer losses in quarantine, they don't suffer managerial loss of profit and they don't have same goals. The point of a city owned bus transport company is to exist and provide decent service for lowest amount of money. There is not a "this is not feasible for me anymore, not bringing enough profit" situation.
- mschuster91 3y ago> There are no toll booths outside of motorways, the roads are free. People commute by public transport, which is mostly not private. Note, I'm German (living in Munich) myself, but most of the problems are valid here just as well. Public transport for example... the Deutsche Bahn, Berlin's BVG or Munich's MVG, they all have complained that they continued service during covid at a ridiculous expense and didn't get reimbursed for a large part of the expense, and on top of that now the Deutschlandticket is cutting into income even more.
- dagw 3y agoThere are no toll booths outside of motorways I know of lots of European cities where you have to pay to drive into the city. People commute by public transport Again, while less common than in the US, commuting by car is incredibly common in Europe as well. I can see one of the main roads into my city from my window and it is bumper to bumper traffic every morning and afternoon.
- 3y ago
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> In the end it's more a financial thing IMO. When you just entered a 10 or 15 year lease right before Covid hit, you're now stuck with paying 7 years for an office you're not even using - that's objectively bad for any company's financials Amazon is a different beast - as they're more like Walmart and less like Google and Apple. The rest of the big tech companies people actually want to make at have ~40% profit margins, and <5% of expenses come from office space. If their offices are underutilized by 50% - that's a rounding error. And beside Microsoft - basically none of the big tech companies have anywhere near enough space. You've got people make $800k with less space than people who work in universities making $30k.
- xyst 3y agoEverything you have pointed out is a direct result of car centric transportation in America and underscores the bad city design. > When you just entered a 10 or 15 year lease right before Covid hit, you're now stuck with paying 7 years for an office you're not even using This is priced in. The “cost per employee” metric you cite or hypothesize will stay the same regardless of whether it’s used or not. Also companies that do use this metric for bonuses are outdated. As such this is a “me” problem. > other side of rentals, the entire REIT industry, has it even worse, they're in pure panic mode: They wouldn’t be in “panic mode” if American cities weren’t built with these mono-zones, single purpose use (ie, “commercial only” zones, “resident only” zones, SFH only zones). > enough, cities also have a problem... when people don't commute by car, they don't pay road tolls Cities don’t give a shit about whether or not you take toll roads. That money is sent to the toll operator which is often sent to the state OR a private entity. Not using local road infrastructure is actually a benefit as maintenance is reduced and city workers can focus on other items. City can also defer replacing expensive local roads for just a bit longer. > When they don't commute by public transport and don't pay subscription tickets any more, the transport authorities get into financial trouble I guess people only take the bus for getting to and from work… For everything else, TAKE THE CAR!!1 Sadly, for many Americans this is a reality. Again, this is a direct result of poorly designed cities around car centric transportation. Cars as the only means for getting groceries, getting to/from entertainment districts, general living. > When storefronts of bakeries, coffee shops and other ancilliary services for office drones get boarded up as no one is in the office any more to buy all that stuff, blight sets in. Wouldn’t be a problem in a mixed-zoned region. Walkability is key. > when people demand fast Internet at their homes to work efficiently or utilize other stuff such as water, electricity or trash more (because they'd have to expand their long-outdated, barely adequate service), utility providers have to invest serious amounts of money. Urban density is what pays for a large portion of these services. It’s when cities are forced to increase coverage for suburban and low density areas is where it begins to fall apart. This has been happening for decades and long before the “remote worker” demand. Again highlighting here that car centric transportation is the main cause for these race to build suburbs. Heavily subsidized highway infrastructure is fueling the demand. > Car insurances tied to distance driven per year lose money This is not an issue. As a matter of fact, insurance companies hope you drive less. This deceases the likelihood of an accident and thus having to pay out. It’s when they payout claims is when they lose money. Otherwise the premiums they collects is essentially “free money”
- sparrowInHand 3y agoIts just a economic bubble then, just one made of inefficiency and cultural bias... an now it popped
- karg_kult 3y agoThey can sub lease it out to some bum on seats call centre like company.
- thelastparadise 3y agoThe way you describe it it sounds like one big ponzi scheme. "We bought offices so we must fill them up so the value of our offices doesn't go down."
- taylodl 3y agoSo you're saying we should lower the quality of our life so we can protect the interests and assets of the wealthy? Fuck that shit. We've been let out of the cage that we didn't even realize we were in. Now we know. We're not going back.
- mschuster91 3y ago> So you're saying we should lower the quality of our life so we can protect the interests and assets of the wealthy? I think the last sentence of my post should show what my opinion on this entire matter is. I merely wanted to provide a more detailed explanation than "CEOs be power trippin'" on why we're seeing so much RTO bullshit being pushed the last months.