3 ms·
The same work should bring the same payment, period. Everything else just ends up rewarding those with the best "negotiation" skill which is completely unrelate
by mschuster91 3y ago
The same work should bring the same payment, period. Everything else just ends up rewarding those with the best "negotiation" skill which is completely unrelated to one's actually work-relevant skills.
- blfr 3y agoThere is no such thing as "same work" outside of a production line and the like. You learn this in the initial weeks of your career. In every tech company there are programmers, project managers, and sales people who have the same titles but deliver vastly different quality of outcomes. And everyone knows this because they instantly pick the good ones whenever they have the slightest optionality. You have a new project, difficult client, some fuckup to straighten out, and everyone's eyes turn to the same person. It's such a common occurrence, you must have seen this. You must have seen people being fired without a single tear or with a sigh of relief and others quitting to widespread worry over who will manage to step in for them. People with the same roles on paper.
- mschuster91 3y agoSo what, you can use a well defined bonus structure. At least that is transparent and related to one's own work skill.
- sokoloff 3y agoLet’s imagine that msc91 is the person we always turn to when the chips are down and they always deliver great results in the clutch situations while maintaining all of their regular duties as well. How long until we rationally decide to pay msc91 a monthly “in case the chips are down” bonus/retainer? Msc91 is made better off; the company and its customers are made better off and thereby, msc91’s colleagues are made better off. If we decide on principle that we won’t do that, how long until a better-funded or better product-market fit company comes along and hears through the grapevine of ex-msc91 colleagues that they should pay their overall higher wages to msc91 and get them to join? Now, all of the good things that could have happened in the prior paragraph are lost.
- blfr 3y agoInterestingly, you can't. Although to be fair, plenty of managers still believe they can. Imagine a job where results seem fairly easily quantifiable: sales. You want to hire a great salesguy you know. His current salary is 168k and he collects another 85k in bonuses. How do you get him? You offer him 260 base and some unspecified bonus you will work out later. Why? Because he already knows what kind of bonuses he can collect where he is but only has a vague idea of your company's product potential. This uncertainty and unattainability of full information forces companies into either wide bands or made up titles. That's even before he goes to his current boss for a competing offer.
- sokoloff 3y agoNow define “same”, particularly for creative work where value created can be a factor of 10 or more off. There are qualified, employed SWEs that I’m 3x as good as. There are other SWEs who (correctly) look at me and draw that exact same conclusion.
- Kerrick 3y agoBecause you are able to confidently measure yourself as 3x as good as somebody else, and because you're able to confidently measure value created to be a factor of 10 or more higher, you're able to measure what's needed to define "same." (Hint: it's those things, but at 1x.)
- sokoloff 3y agoI'm flattered that you think there are no SWEs who are capable of creating 3x as much value per year as I am. I think you're incorrect, but I'm flattered.
- Kerrick 3y agoYou misread my comment. If you can definitively say that there are some who can create 3x as much value as you, then you can also definitively say that value is measurable. The measurability of value is what was at question in this thread. “The same work should bring the same payment” is not incompatible with “some SWEs provide more value than others.”
- pseg134 3y agoWell negotiation is definitely a work skill and every single person does it many times per day so it’s a valuable skill to improve. Most professional jobs allow for a range of working styles and productivity so it’s only natural people with the same job would be compensated differently based on the value they offer the company.
- ahtihn 3y ago> The same work should bring the same payment, period. How do you reward good job performance?
- cutemonster 3y agoIf it's a small company, what about revenue and profit sharing over the next X years (so they do what's good long term not quarterly), weighted by how many days they've worked for the company?
- fnimick 3y agoOr worse, it rewards those that are "in demand" elsewhere, and harms those that due to some factors outside of their control (sexism, racism) would receive less interest elsewhere, so they can be paid less to keep them here. I once spoke with someone who acknowledged this, but said it wasn't a bad thing - if the market has decided that someone is worth less, why should he pay them more than he has to?