3 ms·
> The issue is that a sizeable underclass is being created that have no wealth, not least because what wealth they did have has been funneled to the very wealth
by carlosjobim 3y ago
> The issue is that a sizeable underclass is being created that have no wealth, not least because what wealth they did have has been funneled to the very wealthy.
This has happened in all of the industrialized world, and it's happening very quickly right now. The reasons you mention are very US-specific, but the funneling happens everywhere, usually by more traditional means such as rents and taxes.
Yes, taxes are greatly beneficial for the rich, just scrutinize any European government budget and you'll see it is in large part a scheme to pay out money to wealthy people that are in favour with the political class.
The reason for this massive wealth distribution is the inflationary monetary system, that's the common denominator in all countries experiencing it, and it's not hard to see how.
In the past, serfdom was at least more honest. You knew your tax payments went to the lord for his own benefit.
- somewhereoutth 3y ago> The reason for this massive wealth distribution is the inflationary monetary system Inflation serves to reduce wealth (if just stuffed under the mattress), and encourages investment (to beat inflation). The real problem is that wealth begets wealth - if left to it's own devices the capitalist system will ensure wealth becomes concentrated in fewer and fewer hands. The only way this can be counter-balanced is with government regulation (e.g. anti-monopolistic laws, wealth redistribution).
- BirAdam 3y agoIn the absence of government intervention, wealth is more likely to tend toward the center. The issue is that any democratic form of government featuring any kind of legislature reliant on voting will be bought. First, large companies will want small little advantages like a new road to their factory. Overtime, it becomes massive like immunity from prosecution from drugs that kill people like opioids. Over time, these companies receiving benefits become indistinguishable from the government itself and drive nearly all policy like Boeing, Raytheon, Lockheed, JP Morgan, Goldman, etc. Generally, all attempts to stop this are subverted and used to the benefit of these megacorporations via riders on any such bill introduced by politicians who’re on the take. Further, the agencies tasked with enforcement of any regulation usually have people who previously worked at these companies or who hope to work at them in the future on their staff. Humans respond to incentives, and all incentives line up toward the merger of corporation and state in a democracy. I’d like to see a free market democracy that lacks corporate personhood to see if that changes the structure, but a human life isn’t long enough to really witness such a thing.
- coldtea 3y ago>In the absence of government intervention, wealth is more likely to tend toward the center. The issue is that any democratic form of government featuring any kind of legislature reliant on voting will be bought. Every non-democratic form will be bought even faster, if it's not operated directly by the "buyers" in the first place. Though I doubt that "in the absence of government intervention, wealth is more likely to tend toward the center". There are dozens of ways for the rich to get richer and fuck the poor/center over without government intervention. In a more anarchic, no-government-at-all situation, for an extreme example, they are the ones to afford the best mercernaries and dictate terms...
- BirAdam 3y agoMy argument is not that any government or no government is better than another, but rather that this form of corruption is unavoidable in democracies. As for anarchy, yes, you could have more or worse violent action, but the type you cite is directly how the current system works. In the USA, the US and its states have the greatest military strength and therefore set the terms. They also engage in military action on behalf of corporations like United Fruit, Coca-Cola, Exon, etc. The argument that "in the absence of a government the warlords would take over" ignores that the warlords are already in power. Further, I at no point advocated for anarchy. I merely stated that in the absence of government intervention, wealthy is more likely to tend toward the center. In the USA, the wealth gap has widened as government intervention in the market has increased and that is the basis of evidence for my argument. Today, the richest and poorest are further apart that any prior time in US history, and law/regulation is and has been in continuous expansion not retraction.
- flagrant_taco 3y agoCorruption happens under any form of government, it doesn't require democracy. The risk for corruption is always there when power is centralized, the more you centralize the more incentive there is. If anything democracy has only shown that it isn't a magic bullet for corruption. Part of the goal is that oversight by the voting public will eventually weed out the corrupt, that works somewhat and should certainly be better than no oversight from other forms of government.
- carlosjobim 3y agoInflation serves to redistribute wealth, since the first people to receive the new money created are those who benefit most from it. The reduced value of money some rich man has under his mattress is of very little importance here, what's important is the reduced value of the money received as wages by labourers. When Roman emperors inflated their currency, the first people to receive the new money created were their soldiers. Wealth of the rest of Roman citizens was in this way redistributed to the soldiers. Today we have a fractional reserve system in banking, meaning that banks actually create money and inflate the money supply when they give a "loan". While a lot of this money goes to governments and some goes to companies, the wast majority of new money enters circulation by being lent to real estate purchasers. That's why real estate is so unaffordable. It's not more complicated than that. > The only way this can be counter-balanced is with government regulation Then start regulating the banks and take away their privilege of creating money from nothing.
- logicchains 3y ago>Inflation serves to reduce wealth (if just stuffed under the mattress), and encourages investment (to beat inflation). Inflation, in the current form, transfers wealth to the first people to receive/spend the newly printed money (the financial system) from the last people to receive the newly printed money (this is termed the Cantillon effect). Since the end of Bretton Woods in the 1970s there's been a massive increase in USD inflation coinciding with a massive increase in wealth inequality, as would be expected from a system based around systematic transfer of wealth from the real economy to the financial industry. Technically inflation doesn't have to act like this; if it occurred via helicopter money airdropped equally into everybody's bank account, there wouldn't be a wealth transfer. But with the current system it's a systematic source of inequality.
- Stephen_0xFF 3y ago> capitalist system will ensure wealth becomes concentrated in fewer and fewer hands. The only way this can be counter-balanced is with government regulation I'd argue government is just the same. If you look at who holds office right now, it's predominantly the older generation [0]. They achieved that by becoming career politicians. Deng Xiaoping introduced capitalism which lifted generations of people out of poverty [1]. It has a good track record of doing that. The rich companies lobby the government to make competition for the little guy impossible and solidifying their concentration of power -- crony capitalism. I do think there should be a push and pull, but both sides are human and power hungry. [0] https://theconversation.com/politicians-are-getting-older-shutting-young-people-out-of-decision-making-around-the-world-197140 https://theconversation.com/politicians-are-getting-older-sh... [1] https://www.nytimes.com/1997/02/20/world/deng-xiaoping-a-political-wizard-who-put-china-on-the-capitalist-road.html https://www.nytimes.com/1997/02/20/world/deng-xiaoping-a-pol...
- andrekandre 3y ago> crony capitalism how to get rid of crony cpitalism?