4 ms·
In America, it looks like real estate is becoming a victim of capitalism: companies buy properties, convert them to rentals, the collude with each other to "max
by cyanydeez 3y ago
In America, it looks like real estate is becoming a victim of capitalism: companies buy properties, convert them to rentals, the collude with each other to "maximize" the value of those rentals. Then they claim the real problem is zoning codes so they can buy up more property just to expand their monopoly.
Homelessness is the a low water effect caused by inflation.
- epistasis 3y agoThis is not caused by companies. This is caused by individual homeowners exerting local control over the amount of housing in their small local area. The few companies making money off this are just piggy-backing on the homeowners who drive the political process. Private equity saw what homeowners have done in the US and thought "hey we can benefit from this regulatory capture without even having to do any of the work of capture," and even with that they are a tiny minority of housing. Let's correctly place the blame so that we can fix the problem. Even banning all corporate ownership of homes does nothing to house these homeless folks, only building more home will get people into them and break the sell-side power.
- thfuran 3y agoPrivate equity may own a fairly small amount of the total housing stock, but there are metros where 20+% of home sales over the last year or two were to investors. That's surely enough to distort the market.
- epistasis 3y agoNot really, it's only a tiny fraction of purchasers. Their market power during purchase time is not enough to drive down prices and benefit them, and post purchase they do not own enough fraction of existing homes to help drive up sale prices. Unless they are systematically paying above market, which is what Zillow did (for a tiny tiny number of homes, relative to supply). Which would be a transfer of wealth from Private Equity to individual home buyers. Housing is one of the least centralized markets that we have, and even when ownership is highly concentrated in a market, it's very rare that pricing can be controlled by an entity. Even the widely publicized "pricing software" for rentals was just better at showing comparable apartments with less work, enabling price discovery. It didn't enable price collusion. The shortage of housing and resulting high prices are best understood (IMHO) through class politics, where class is defined as already owning a housing asset or not.
- someguydave 3y agoThe centralisation in real estate is on the gov-backed mortgage side. We should end the thirty year mortgage and require home owners to purchase debt in the private market.
- epistasis 3y agoI am so glad to hear somebody proposing this! I support these ideas 100%, though I had not been bold enough to say it before. Ending the mortgage interest tax deduction would also be a good move. It does nothing but subsidize larger mortgages and asset price inflation.
- thfuran 3y agoI think these are probably good ideas but terrible first moves. We need to build a lot more housing before doing things that'll make a lot of people a lot less able to afford the houses they already own or purchase other housing.
- delfinom 3y agoPretty much, here in NY, they tried to forced villages to suspend zoning for apartments. Except, these villages here are already being heavily developed, by nothing but luxury apartment buildings. (There are in fact 4 going up next to me right now). The real estate mafia controls NY and they wanted the inconvenience of building codes suspended so they could build more luxury units faster. Also, what keeps happening is the developers cheat, don't offer affordable units in the end, and the villages get sued for displacing low income individuals which violates some HUD rules and suddenly the remaining village taxpayers are subsidizing the rents of people in these luxury apartments by federal order. (Because my village currently is doing this). You know, instead of the luxury apartment apartment building that caused the displacement.