3 ms·
The problem isn't so much with specific compounds like glyphosate, but the whole method of industrial farming. The current method is the "nuclear option"; chemi
by jbotz 3y ago
The problem isn't so much with specific compounds like glyphosate, but the whole method of industrial farming. The current method is the "nuclear option"; chemically kill everything, plant the one crop you want (preferably genetically enhanced to withstand your choice of poisons) together with the basic nutrients this plant needs in a easily absorbable ionic form and apply more nutrients and pesticides at predetermined intervals. After harvest, kill everything again and repeat. This is simple and effective and produces consistently high yields. The price is residual chemicals on the food produced this way and "leakage" of the poisons into the environment. You'll pay some variation of this price no matter which specific chemicals you use. And in all fairness it must be added that from an ecological perspective this is already an improvement over the heavy use of tillage from before the age of RoundUp(tm) because the tillage was causing severe top-soil erosion, and GM-crops do reduce the need for poisons (a bit).
There are alternatives (sustainable polycultures) but they are more labor and knowledge intensive. As a society we don't have much of that knowledge (some research is being done, but far too little) and don't want to commit the labor.
There is one possibility that could resolve this conundrum, though... very smart robots could provide the labor in the future. But we'll have to invest more on the knowledge side if we want to get there quickly and feed the world sustainably.
- lloeki 3y ago> produces consistently high yields Up until soil has been exhausted for that particular plant, at which point yield is maintained by a) temporarily turning it back to fallow or b) artificially bringing in nutrients.
- jbotz 3y agoSoil exhaustion is mostly irrelevant to this industrial method... it just means adding a more complete nutrient mix. In much of the US or Europe they can get awawy with only adding NPK (until, as you say, the soil gets exhausted, meaning some of the other nutrients are no longer available in sufficient quantity), but in a lot of the tropics (where I've practiced agriculture) the soils are so poor that they go with a complete nutrient mix from the start, i.e. treat the soil as just a substrate to hold the roots and add everything else, both macro and micro nutrients (often in the irrigation water, so it's basically hydroponics in soil). The method remains the same.
- maxerickson 3y agoI've jokingly used sandponics to describe industrial agriculture, but apparently that's a real other thing.