3 ms·
10 feels like the classic "find a half-way mark" decision between 5 and 15 which reflects expediency more than evidence. I suspect 5 is too long but both produ
by ggm 3y ago
10 feels like the classic "find a half-way mark" decision between 5 and 15 which reflects expediency more than evidence.
I suspect 5 is too long but both producer (ag companies making herbicide) and consumer (farmers who are serially addicted to it) want more time to convert their dependency.
As a casual backyard gardener it dripped all over me for a while. Not every day. Not all day. But I am sure many people like me read of the risks now, and worry what we've been exposed to unbeknownst (it was casually sold to us as "the safer option" although nobody would have said safer meant totally safe)
More weed tolerant forms of food production are also not risk free: There's been a small outbreak of poisoning from immature non-spinach leaking into the crop for bagged baby spinach sold in the supermarkets. Cross contamination with unexpected plant material poses some risks.
Another systemic poison "Confidor" was bloody good at keeping bugs off our plants but always came with "you can't eat anything afterward" which was a painful lesson in what it takes to kill a modern mite. It's mostly off the market now too. Chlorpyriphos was used for Cockroaches and other bugs as a surface spray, "your kid would have to lick the walls to be affected" they said: now, banned for domestic use. The lists go on.
- deepsummer 3y agoMy understanding is that there is no alternative to Glyphasate which is definitely safer. There are some candidates, but there's not research to be sure whether they are better, or worse. What would you propose?
- michaelt 3y agoI don't know how safe there are, but not only are there glyphosate-free weed killers on the market, there are even Roundup-branded glyphosate-free weed killers available. They seem to use acetic acid (Roundup Speed Ultra) and nonanoic acid (Roundup NL). Are they safe? Are they effective? Hell if I know. I'm going to be wearing gloves and washing my hands after using, no matter how safe Monsanto says it is.
- janekm 3y ago60g/l acetic acid ... that's literally just slightly strong household vinegar. (safety precautions, especially not breathing it in, are definitely advisable though, it's a fairly strong acid)
- hutzlibu 3y agoBut is it the only active ingredient?
- michaelt 3y agoIt's the only one listed in the MSDS [1] so... probably? [1] https://www.lovethegarden.com/sites/default/files/content/products/documents/spec_sheets/UK_119727_RUP_msds.pdf https://www.lovethegarden.com/sites/default/files/content/pr...
- Tarsul 3y agowhat I don't understand is why they only count in multiples of 5. It's the same with EVs (it doesnt have to be 2030 or 2035, it could also be 2032 etc.). It strikes me as needlessly imprecise. But I guess that's what you get when you have to make a decision between dozens of people with different opinions :)
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoWe now have laser weed removal https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkoetsier/2021/11/02/self-driving-farm-robot-uses-lasers-to-kill-100000-weeds-an-hour-saving-land-and-farmers-from-toxic-herbicides/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkoetsier/2021/11/02/self-dr...