6 ms·
Open Air Schools of the 1900s
- asow92 3y agoWere there examples of schools trying to follow something similar during the peak of covid lockdowns? Such a simple solution if you think about it.
- radicaldreamer 3y agoThere are open air preschools in the Bay Area. The weather being temperate year round helps a lot as well.
- asow92 3y agoIf Scandinavian babies can sleep in the cold, I think our kids be lectured in it, no? https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-21537988 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-21537988 As far as the hotter areas in the South, there's probably some solution for that too.
- egypturnash 3y agoFans. Possibly misters near the fans if you want to splurge. There's a lot of restaurants with open-air sections here in New Orleans that do this. You do need some sort of shielding from the sky, heatstroke is a thing, so's an absolute drenchpour that lasts about twenty minutes, usually in the afternoon.
- selimthegrim 3y agoTulane does have a sort of outdoor classroom with a chalkboard but I don’t really see it used for lecturing that often
- alwayslikethis 3y agoIf the temperature and humidity are high enough, no amount of fans and/or misters will cool you down.
- klysm 3y agoI.e. wet bulb temperature
- blueyes 3y agoFwiw, I send my pre-schooler to one. They often go by the lower-case name "forest school", although there is an official Forest School in the east bay, and frankly the outdoors that the kids spend time in is more of a cross of beach and park, less forest. When it rains, they wear galoshes and get suited up. Forest schools tend to have a "learning through play" philosophy, at least the ones I'm aware of. https://learningthroughplay.com/explore-the-research/the-scientific-case-for-learning-through-play https://learningthroughplay.com/explore-the-research/the-sci... I suspect they do well at socializing kids, and letting them figure things out for themselves. Definitely not doing some version of teaching to the test. Other advantage: it stayed open during COVID. Disadvantage: The smoke season in CA is a problem.
- INTPenis 3y agoThe open air day cares in my hometown in Sweden never closed afaik. The ones in the pildammsparken park of Malmö, anyone noticed if they closed during covid? I just remember walking my dog there daily and seeing kids.
- robinwassen 3y agoDaycares did not close during covid in Sweden. On the topic there are a category of preschools in Sweden called "Ur och skur" which have most education outdoors. Back in the 90s I know some primary schools in Sweden also had education outside, but I think that have changed with schools becoming more competitive lately.
- jetrink 3y agoYes, a school near my parents' house in Michigan did this! They built several large outdoor pavilions and also have a clearing in the adjoining woods that they hold classes in. I visited in the dead of winter and sure enough, there were about 100 kids out in the freezing cold all day long. Even from a distance, you could see that they were bundled up in multiple layers to keep warm. I was back recently and they still do outdoor classes, but I think it is only for a portion of the day now as I didn't see nearly as many students outside at a time. 1. https://wwmt.com/news/local/moving-forward-kazoo-school-offers-outdoor-learning-sees-increased-enrollment-in-2021 https://wwmt.com/news/local/moving-forward-kazoo-school-offe...
- r00fus 3y agoNot entirely but my kids' K-8 has pushed some of their classes outside (mostly science) to their local "woods" (a part of the land parcel of the school that's not developed and has trees, a pond and some work tables). Also a lot of effort was done during the pandemic to do events outside (like music) in the quad area. Also all meals have been outdoors (indoor not possibly during pandemic) - I remember this being the case even when I was in school in this area. Being in CA, that's easy year round due to milder weather. That said, the effort was nothing close to outdoors all the time, which has significant challenges.
- sokoloff 3y agoMy older kid’s school was founded in the 1915 respiratory pandemic era and had a significant outdoor component for the intervening 100 years. They still closed for part of the time early in COVID, but quickly switched to partial in-person with significant outdoor time. I think it was effective, surely better educationally and socially than my younger’s elementary school that stayed closed for a far longer time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cik 3y agoThis is exactly what schools did in Israel. There were two different approaches that were juggled depending on the situation - but all schools did this. The culture already existed somewhat - since varying classes have always been outside. 1. Divide into "capsules" where people could learn indoors but with half of the cohort - spread apart, windows open, masked, etc. 2. Learn outside with forms of this. Youth groups, scouts, synagogues, etc all did the latter. I spent the better part of a year praying in a parking lot or a park with others. Entire communities were doing shared meals - just spread apart. The park across the street from my place had a lot of picnicking going on. As an example, the local Planetarium rejigged to do outdoor events. They were so popular that the planetarium continues to do ~40% of each season's lineup outside.
- asow92 3y agoSomething I’ve noticed in this thread is that Californians think they’re the only people with nice weather.
- roughsquare 3y ago"for certain children who are inmates of one of its schools for the mentally defective deaf." Wow, that is a loaded statement that certainly has not aged well.
- hotnfresh 3y agoIt’s just a couple steps behind on the euphemism treadmill, is all. Plus “inmates” has narrowed in meaning a bit, so that reads harsher than it was probably intended. That doesn’t help.
- aintgonnatakeit 3y agoInmates describes most public school children pretty well though. You got your locked doors, your tall fences, your armed guards, and a limited time to spend in the yard…err playground.
- klysm 3y agoIt is true by literal definition - you are confined to that space.
- hndamien 3y agoThis fixes myopia as well
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoIf by "fixes" you means that there is evidence that time outdoors slows/halts it, yes. But you can't just spend time under a tree until you no longer need glasses.
- hndamien 3y agoYes, that is what I meant. I probably should have been clearer in meaning it fixes our behaviours that seem to unnecessarily contribute to factors that cause myopia.
- Stevvo 3y agoIt's cheaper if you don't need to provide classrooms or textbooks for the "invalid" children. Just let them freeze to death out in the forest.
- anotherhue 3y agoVaguely related: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedge_school https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedge_school
- jmkd 3y agoThousands of Forest Schools in Europe now; a huge growth sector spreading globally. [0] https://forestschoolassociation.org/ https://forestschoolassociation.org/ [1] https://www.thenativeschool.com/forest-school-101 https://www.thenativeschool.com/forest-school-101 [2] https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20220105-how-asia-fell-in-love-with-forest-schools https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20220105-how-asia-fell-in...
- elxr 3y agoWhat an awesome movement. Most of my best memories at school as a kid were when I was outdoors. I also still vividly remember the feeling of being forced to go back inside after lunch period at as a kid (lunch was semi open-air, and after our meals we'd always play outside). It was a huge mood killer. Imagining having classes outside in the yard, under some trees now, that'd be quite nice.
- hutzlibu 3y agoThousands? I would like that, but on the map [0] I see only a couple in england. Where is the rest?
- ljf 3y agoNot sure what the data source is for that map - but in my small part of Norfolk I know of 4 forest schools my kids could go to - plus if you click on the lower of the 2 blue dots over the map of the UK, it opens out to show you 61 schools. Also a friend in Sheffield runs https://www.forestschools.com/ https://www.forestschools.com/ - they have a few of their own schools in the area, and then run training sessions for people that want to run their own. Most of his training is in the UK, but it is a full time job for him and his team, so I can only assume either there are loads of forest schools opening up, or people just like doing the training and then apply the learnings to 'normal' school processes. My kids school is a standard state school, but they all do one day a week 'forest school' from the woods that form part of the school grounds. I doubt they are on the 'forest schools' list.
- jmkd 3y agoAround 2000 in Germany: https://www.bvnw.de/natur-und-waldkindergaerten/deutschland https://www.bvnw.de/natur-und-waldkindergaerten/deutschland 450-500 in Denmark here's a good research study including impact on ongoing educational attainments: https://nexs.ku.dk/forskning/idraet-individ-samfund/krop-laering-og-social-forandring/boern-og-unges-bevaegelsesaktiviteter-i-skole-og-fritid/teachout/ https://nexs.ku.dk/forskning/idraet-individ-samfund/krop-lae... About 1000 in the US: https://naturallykatey.wordpress.com/2021/01/08/list-of-forest-schools-outdoor-based-nature-inspired-schools-in-the-us/ https://naturallykatey.wordpress.com/2021/01/08/list-of-fore... Plenty in the UK, Spain and France too. There are more projects for early years education than later, and they very typically don't have websites or much digital presence.
- monktastic1 3y agoExcept for a small handful of Waldorf schools, there seem to be precious few schools that will give my son significant outdoor time. In fact, I'm told that WA state won't even accredit fully outdoor schools (though I haven't checked this myself). That really saddens me. From one perspective, nature is dying because nobody can be bothered to notice her (and thereby care about/for her) any more.
- hotnfresh 3y agoPost-NCLB, already-low amounts of recess time in many public elementary schools dropped a bunch and never rebounded. Schools are desperate to show the required improvement YoY in math and reading, so they cut time for things like music and recess to get more time for those subjects. I think my kids get half or less as much recess time as I did in the same grades. Sucks.
- rhuru 3y agoDharampal a student of Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi wrote a book called "A beautiful tree" which documented at great lengths how British administration destroyed the local schooling system in India which at that time had managed to produce higher literacy rate (even among working low status masses) than England. Among many things that British got wrong, one was the refusal to call a place school if it did not have a permanent building neatly separated into classrooms and such. More than the learning outcomes, the infra that mattered more for British to recognize anything as a school and they went about closing down the informal "under the tree" schools in this manner. Of course as you go deeper you realize this policy was driven more by the corruption in the East India Company and British government where missionaries wanted funding from government to build "infra" in the same of schools. Much later in 2005 or so James Tooley another British Economist in charge of World Bank aid to school system in India discovered similar trends and quit his job to promote low cost high quality private schools. Indian government around that time brought an evil law called Right to Education and permanently killed this concept. Running an open air school in India might get you jailed today.
- nemo44x 3y agoIt’s funny how the concept of rights have been twisted from things the government can’t do to you to things they must do to you.
- nosefurhairdo 3y agoIt sounds like you're talking about the distinction between positive versus negative liberties as defined by Isaiah Berlin. I'm not sure the original concept of rights was ever limited to just negative liberties, i.e. freedom from government. There's a nice Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on the topic: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberty-positive-negative/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberty-positive-negative...
- nemo44x 3y agoI’m talking about the “Bill of Rights” which is a description of government limitations. It was a completely novel concept in terms of rule. And now we talk more about what you’re entitled to for existing. You aren’t owed shit regardless of what some communist at Stanford wants to word salad about.
- nemo44x 3y agoMany turn of the century homes have large “sleeper porches” as the science of the day thought there were health benefits to sleeping outside. TB was an issue back then.
- hotnfresh 3y agoThey also get so fucking hot in the summer that, If there’s no breeze to drive air up-and-out through the attic and give you good cross-breezes through various important airways in the house, it’s cooler to sleep outside. Source: have owned a 1910s-construction house on the national historic registry that didn’t have any insulation or central AC. We weren’t in a hot part of the country but still slept on the front porch about two weeks a year, when window AC in the bedrooms couldn’t keep up with the heat.
- nemo44x 3y agoDoes your home have working windows and are they double hung sash windows? The intent was the bottom sash would be opened on the cool side of the house and the upper sash on the hot side. This would create an airflow of cooler air entering and warmer air exiting. Well placed fans would help create airflow. But you’re right, people also used them for the hottest nights too.
- hotnfresh 3y agoYeah, the layout of the house and lots of huge, openable windows could get you pretty far in terms of keeping it comfortable (most modern houses cannot do that, and are horrible even in moderate temps without AC) but if the breeze was weak and temps got past 90F nothing would help much. You could run a window AC non-stop all night and keep it close to 80, maybe, but that was still too uncomfortable to make it worth the insane electric bill that would follow (no insulation, original single-pane windows, no modern mostly-airtight envelope in the walls—I do mean the AC unit would run all night). Without that option we’d probably have had more like 5-6 patio-sleeping weeks per year, instead of 1-2.
- monero-xmr 3y agoYou really don’t need anything special for a high quality school. Protection from the elements, a communication tool, and students who want to learn or can be punished (such as expelling) if they don’t. All of the tech this or that is totally unnecessary. Most kids should start working around 12 years old. The very motivated and intelligent can be identified by then and put into longer learning. Those who start working should be able to go back to school if they have the desire and aptitude. Too many kids develop an intense hatred of school, caused by a combination of terrible teachers and poor quality peers. Experiencing more of the real world can provide an incentive to try hard in school before life brings them someplace else.
- deaddodo 3y agoReading the headline, I thought this was going to refer to the open layout school campuses similar to what is common in the Southwest US. Pleasently surprised at a little piece of history I was unaware of.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoI am reminded of commentary I have seen about how if we taught baseball like we teach science, no one would play. They would study it in books for years without being allowed to play at all. No one would be excited about it. When I homeschooling my sons, we went to zoos and museums and did a lot of hands-on stuff. There was also a lot of reading, but not in place of hands-on learning.
- zubairq 3y agoReally nice article!
- known 3y ago[dead]