4 ms·
You're looking at this from an assumption-of-LARPing. Imagine an FBI agent looking at evidence of Timothy McVeigh at a gun show in 1994. He's selling a flare g
by ethbr1 3y ago
You're looking at this from an assumption-of-LARPing.
Imagine an FBI agent looking at evidence of Timothy McVeigh at a gun show in 1994. He's selling a flare gun he claims can 'shoot down an ATF helicopter' and ATF hats with bullet holes in them.
When interviewed without charge, imagine McVeigh claims that it's part of his LARPing activities.
What standards would you suggest that agent applies, in order to avoid a false negative?
- Karunamon 3y agoAnother way to phrase that first sentence is "assumption of innocence". And while random commentators on the internet are not obligated to honor it, law enforcement is supposed to.
- mrguyorama 3y ago>And while random commentators on the internet are not obligated to honor it, law enforcement is supposed to. This is not the standard actually applied to law enforcement in the US. You can be convicted of nothing other than resisting arrest. Resisting arrest for what? Literally does not matter. Also if you are arrested and found innocent, you are not compensated in any way for that arrest, which was clearly wrongful. Police in general are simply exempt from unlawful detention, except in cases of a well connected individual.
- gs17 3y ago>Also if you are arrested and found innocent, you are not compensated in any way for that arrest, which was clearly wrongful. Not only that, there are likely fees and fines.
- jjk166 3y agoAssumption of innocence is for the court. The prosecution and law enforcement are not supposed to assume innocence, they are supposed to do everything in their legal power to prove guilt. There are things they can't do without reasonable suspicion, or probable cause, but these are vastly lower thresholds.
- ethbr1 3y agoThis document is seemingly targeted on the investigation phase, before a charge has been filed, to distinguish what characteristics legitimate LARPing may have vs militia claims-of-LARPing. Presumption of innocence does not extend to the initiation of an investigation, but comes into play with increasingly invasive methods (and ultimately, charges). US law enforcement is empowered to initiate duck investigations on things that quack pretty liberally.
- pixl97 3y agoYea, this entire thread really tells me that most people on HN have absolutely zero experience with the investigation phase of law enforcement. If your in some group that reenacts pointing weapons at each other, or coming up with idea on how to blow up buildings and you have someone overhear this and report it, law enforcement themselves have no idea if you're the real thing our not (statistically, no your not, but investigators deal with outliers all day every day). If there is some kind of audio or video evidence saying something actionable (even though it may be pretend) and that gets in front of a judge, expect a warrant to get issued to tap into just about every part of your life.
- screwturner68 3y agoReally? I don't think due process and law enforcement have anything to do with one another. Law enforcement arrests people on made up laws all the time just because they are doing something the law enforcement officer doesn't like, there is no consideration of presumption of innocence. Law enforcement's job is to enforce "the law" as they interpenetrate it -unlike civilians where "ignorance of the law is not an excuse" in law enforcement they certainly an go with ignorance of the law as long as the judge thinks it's "reasonable". Let's not forget the police have been embedding themselves in peaceful protest groups for the last 100 years.
- Jensson 3y agoYour example just proves that this document doesn't hold water, he did that in public and didn't care about people seeing what he did, so the document would suggest he was LARPing for real. I don't see how this document would help find criminals and help free innocents. It seems to give way too rigid guidelines that will be misused by many officers.
- ethbr1 3y agoHe wasn't practicing building pipe bombs in public. By the rubric this document suggests, McVeigh would have satisfied 0 / 10 LARPing signals in Table 1.
- Jensson 3y agoYour scenario was: > Imagine an FBI agent looking at evidence of Timothy McVeigh at a gun show in 1994. He's selling a flare gun he claims can 'shoot down an ATF helicopter' and ATF hats with bullet holes in them. Not "Imagine an FBI agent looking at Timothy McVeigh building pipe bombs in private". I don't see how this document would have helped stop McVeigh.
- ethbr1 3y agoClueless FBI agent today is looking at a stack of next-McVeigh-claiming-LARP + 5 LARP/military RP groups. Maybe this doc helps them sort the wheat from the chaff, because the agent doesn't actually know anything about LARP groups.
- prepend 3y ago> assumption-of-LARPing. And this seems accurate as the ratio of larping to terrorism is probably millions to one. Thousands of people larp every day in the US. Terrorism is fairly rare with maybe a few events per year.
- 2devnull 3y ago“Terrorism is fairly rare” The only people who make that claim are terrorists.
- smrq 3y agoNot only is this a weird generalization, but it doesn't even make sense. Why would a terrorist want to downplay the frequency of terror incidents? That defeats the entire purpose of trying to, you know, inspire terror.
- prepend 3y agoIt always seemed that terrorists are stupid and irrational in their attempts to achieve their goals, fortunately for society. So maybe this is another case of terrorists just being stupid. Or I expect that GP had some sort of brain fart, disagreed with my statement, and typed the first version of “nuh uh” they came up with.
- prepend 3y agoI’m fairly certain I’m not a terrorist and I made the statement. Therefore; I think your conclusion is false. I made the statement because according to statista [0] there were only 149 terrorist acts in North America from 2007-2022. That seems fairly rare to me. [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/489581/terrorist-attacks-by-region/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/489581/terrorist-attacks...
- sircastor 3y agoI think this might expose (again) the wrong-headed assumptions of law-enforcement for how common terrorism is. It’s rare, but in order to justify the military-industrial investment behind it, we need to be told that we are under constant threat. That terrorism is everywhere, always.