7 ms·
US car giants gripped by history-making strike
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoIt’s interesting to see how they’re strategizing this strike by individually shutting down plants to apply pressure to the automakers gradually instead of all at once. This keeps more workers collecting a paycheck while the threat of a larger shutdown looms. It’s a great idea from a labor organizing standpoint.
- whateveracct 3y agoIn a world where the next quarterly earnings report is king, small strategic moves like this take advantage of that leverage.
- dehrmann 3y agoThey're doing it because unions pay people while they're on strike, their war chests aren't big enough to maintain a full strike for long, and striking members might not be eligible for unemployment (this varies by state). Picketing all three automakers at once might have been a mistake because it means any strike will ultimately be shorter-lived.
- sithlord 3y agoif the final outcome is that everyone will be on strike eventually, the automakers would be wise to just cut to the chase and lock them out until resolved.
- p1mrx 3y agoOne of the reasons for the strike is that EVs can be built with fewer workers. But they will also require a lot of power grid upgrades to operate without fossil fuels. Is there some way for the UAW to expand their scope? In some sense, an electric vehicle still has an "engine" to build, but it's geographically distributed.
- HPsquared 3y agoThe union(s) of power grid workers probably wouldn't be happy with a sudden influx.
- p1mrx 3y agoMichigan's power grid is currently 62% coal and gas, before all the additional load from EVs and heat pumps. It seems like a sudden influx will be needed. Maybe something like an inter-union peering agreement? https://www.michigan.gov/mpsc/consumer/electricity/data-price/fuel-mix-disclosure-data https://www.michigan.gov/mpsc/consumer/electricity/data-pric...
- flagrant_taco 3y agoI wonder what the training and transition would look like to go from working in the auto industry, or specifically manufacturing, to the nuclear power industry.
- autoexec 3y ago> "I’ve been working here for 40 years and I haven’t received a raise in 10 or 12 years" > "We made a lot of concessions in 2008, but now it’s 2023 and inflation is skyrocketing, everything is through the roof, and we’re just asking for something back. We didn’t even ask for more than we had before." > "We are defending our way of life, trying to get enough money to take care of our families and stay in the middle class. They work hard here, six days a week, 10 hours a day. We don’t see our family, and we have to work longer hours to earn the same as what we did 20 years ago" I suspect that a lot of Americans are watching their standard of living decline and seeing their kids have to struggle in ways they never had to at that age. It's no surprise that employees will try to fight to keep what they have, and it'll be interesting to see how much more effective unionized workers are at that. I imagine that a lot of companies are terrified that if these unions succeed it will lead to the creation of new ones for non-union employees looking for the same thing.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoThe fact that the automaker CEOs (and even POTUS) were putting out statements that they didn’t believe a strike was imminent only to turn around and see 150k workers authorize the strike says a bit about their mindset.
- thegrim33 3y agoHow the system is supposed to work is that if they aren't getting paid what they think they should, then they leave that company and let it fail. This will open up opportunities for other companies that pay better and aren't shitty to take over from the broken company.
- nickthegreek 3y agoWhy is that how the ‘system is supposed to work’? Who decided that?
- esarbe 3y agoI think, they are arguing from a deregulated/free market capitalist perspective. Supposedly workers can freely chose to whom they sell their working capacity and thus can negotiate a fair share of the value created. I personally don't see that working, at least not with strong union laws or even complete syndicalisation of all means of production; the global worker pool and the mobility of companies (vs. the immobility of workers) gives companies just too much of an edge in this negotiation (at least outside of bourgeoisie knowledge workers). As evidence I point to the decoupling of company earnings vs. labor income share since the 1980ies.
- dehrmann 3y agoThis strike and the Hollywood strikes are going to be really interesting to watch play out because both are industries in transition, and there's more negotiating from positions of weakness rather than strength on both sides.
- bugglebeetle 3y agoHollywood is not really in transition. Streaming services just did a bunch of Uber-like shit to skirt union agreements and the lack of proper anti-trust enforcement has allowed for obscene consolidation among studios and all the bad decision-making that comes with a lack of competition. AI can’t write 100 lines of correct, testable code without major hand-holding. It’s certainly not going to write films and television most people are ever going to want to watch.
- ta8645 3y ago> It’s certainly not going to write films and television most people are ever going to want to watch. Time will tell, but I think you're wrong. I've heard way too many people say "computers will never X" in my life, only to see it to come to pass. Computers will never provide useful language translation... Computers will never be controlled by human speech... Chess computers will never beat the best humans... etc.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoI agree with this, but I also think we’re going to start to see a social rejection of AI being applied this way if things continue. It’s threatening so many people across so many industries that I think it will become a brand risk to companies, particularly in high profile industries like entertainment. Anecdotally, I watched the new Indiana Jones movie and I found the de-aging scene to be so weird and creepy, the friends I was there with felt the same and it was widely discussed among reviewers and critics. It really represents the planned uselessness of humanity in the AI era and I think more people are going to wake up to that reality as time goes by.
- bugglebeetle 3y ago
- prepend 3y agoGuess even more Toyotas and Teslas will be sold.
- blisterpeanuts 3y agoAnd EV mandates that are going to end ICE production lines in a few years. And millions of Chinese EV's at bargain prices, poised to enter the U.S. market. It does seem like not very prudent for the union to demand a 32-hour work week & 40% pay/benefit increase, at a time when nimbler competitors are waiting in the wings to basically come in and take over the market.
- flagrant_taco 3y agoThose EV mandates have no chance of holding up on the scale of a few years. The supply chain and infrastructure just isn't there to get us to pure EV anywhere near that timeline
- justin66 3y agoNo idea what’s happening in Crazytown, but Toyota is already selling vehicles as quickly as it can make them, with quite a waiting list for custom orders. I get the feeling Honda is in a similar place with most of its vehicles.
- prepend 3y agoWe’ll see how much Toyota and Honda increase capacity. They’re pretty good at it and this much increased demand should really benefit them.
- KevinMS 3y ago[flagged]