4 ms·
This is certainly an interesting idea, but there's absolutely no way for anyone to judge whether the claim on this page is bulletproof true, something plausible
by crazygringo 3y ago
This is certainly an interesting idea, but there's absolutely no way for anyone to judge whether the claim on this page is bulletproof true, something plausible worth researching more, or just total nonsense.
But the fact that there isn't a single link to any scientific paper or evidence whatsoever, or even a single person's name linked to the site (or source of funding or anything), makes me assume this is just spam or a scam.
Apsec112, why did you submit this? How did you find it? Can you give us any context to suggest that anything about this is legit?
And anybody else -- are there actual published results from legit scientists on this? Is this a real thing, or just make-believe?
Because this is an extraordinary claim, and extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Not just 11 sentences.
Edit: I missed that at the very bottom of the page there's a link to a... Google Drive folder? [1] But it's disorganized and not exactly, well, professional. I can't make heads or tails of anything in it, or find anything that suggests credibility.
[1] https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/18ZDSe92LgLmS0sUbosvNxByii_1kjnEj https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/18ZDSe92LgLmS0sUb...
- apsec112 3y agoHi! These are friends of mine. There is much more detail in the Google Drive (linked from the About page): https://drive.google.com/drive/u/2/folders/18ZDSe92LgLmS0sUbosvNxByii_1kjnEj https://drive.google.com/drive/u/2/folders/18ZDSe92LgLmS0sUb...
- kelnos 3y agoSorry, but we don't know you either, so a word-of-mouth referral doesn't tell us much here. The Google Drive link doesn't provide anything substantive, like links to peer-reviewed, published research.
- apsec112 3y agoThis comment describes the research: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37635401 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37635401
- ysavir 3y agoIf your friends are looking for feedback, you can pass on that at least one person on the internet finds it in very bad taste for them to describe the delay in treatment as a "civilizational embarrassment" while planning to charge $20k for a dose. The pricing point seems equally a civilizational embarassment to me.
- corethree 3y agoNot just embarrassing. A disgusting example of the worst parts of humanity.
- dimava 3y agoI can easily imagine someone who don't brush their teeth ever to spend like $1000 a year for cavity repairs (because, well, I did). So I guess $20k is near to the market price you could expect people to pay for a lifetime (with refills and no cavities guarantee) for this product. If $20k it too much for you, just wait for cheaper generics.
- zestyping 3y agoThat's not the point — the critique (as I understand it) is about the way in which it's presented.
- KETpXDDzR 3y agoCapitalism at its finest. A civilization should be measured at how it treats the poorest. By selling such an incredible cure (if it's really working) for thousands of dollars makes it impossible for the low-income class to purchase.
- andsoitis 3y agohttps://www.bizapedia.com/ca/lantern-bioworks-inc.html https://www.bizapedia.com/ca/lantern-bioworks-inc.html has something: "LANTERN BIOWORKS, INC. is a California Non-Profit Corporation - Ca - Public Benefit filed on January 4, 2023. The company's filing status is listed as Active and its File Number is 5412825. The Registered Agent on file for this company is Tovella Dowling, PC and is located at 501 W Broadway Suite 1310, San Diego, CA 92101. The company's principal address is 501 W Broadway Ste 1310, San Diego, CA 92101 and its mailing address is 501 W Broadway Ste 1310, San Diego, CA 92101. The company has 3 contacts on record. The contacts are Aaron Silverbook from San Diego CA, Connor Flexman from San Diego CA, and Nick Mossakowski from San Diego CA.
- Mistletoe 3y agoIt seems hard to believe the ethanol producing bacterial strain would dominate your oral microbione for life from one application. But I’m willing to have an open mind and see some data. They need to get the data off of the Google drive and presented in a better way. I don’t click unknown Google drive links if I can avoid it.
- upon_drumhead 3y agoBrushing your teeth and using mouthwash wipes out the majority of the micro biome. Application of the new strain shortly after could totally replace it wholesale. That said, I can’t imagine there’s not other side effects that just aren’t known yet. The sample size and reporting (as far as we know) is just too small and meaningless.
- EGreg 3y agoDoes brushing and mouthwash really eliminate your microbiome? I heard it does precious little. Most of the microorganisms live below the gumline and surfaces. If that were true it would eliminate caries! Please post links
- hadlock 3y agoMouthwash (WITH alcohol) daily almost completely eliminates the need for daily brushing and flossing. This was later retracted by demand of the ADA to only say "as good or better than flossing"; from here: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3894074/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3894074/ "mouth rinses would be considered to be “at least as good as” daily flossing if the upper limit of the 90% confidence interval" there are a number of studies on this topic and they all seem to generally be in agreement. Mouthwash even once a week is really good for dental hygiene. They make alcohol free mouthwash but it's hard to argue with the antimicrobial properties of alcohol and the price difference is neglible.
- astrange 3y agoThat would get rid of all the good bacteria too, which can't be… good.
- burkaman 3y agoYeah, if it's in "patent hell and FDA hell" there should be applications and evidence of that online, right?
- prepend 3y agoPatent hell should be over if this was invented in 1985.
- pas 3y agowho knows. maybe invented as a concept and then developed as a concrete dentistry protocol, which then got parented recently?
- prepend 3y agoGood point. But that would be odd then to present it as solved in 1985 if only recently was figured out how to put it into a protocol. That would be a new innovation rather than “been around forever but never used.”
- Someone 3y agoI didn’t look at that Google drive, but Google search gave me: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12369203 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12369203 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caries_vaccine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caries_vaccine As a layman, I would be concerned about trying to control a bacterium called Streptococcus mutans, as that, to me, signals “this thing mutates rapidly”.
- corethree 3y agoMutations trend towards stable states. Stable states further trend towards states where fast mutation becomes disabled because it's in a "good" stable zone. Symbiosis is the ultimate stable state. You can get stable states in intermediate zones like hiv infections, but these zones are not as good as symbiosis. They have potential to kill off a weak population, additionally humans are actively combatting the virus. In symbiosis there's no negative for either side. There is no evolutionary pressure to "mutate" in symbiosis. Mutations will occur in the beginning. Those will die off fast and eventually the strain will become more and more stable as the gene starts mutating towards a configuration that has slow mutations.
- lolinder 3y agoAs I understand it you left off the key reason why symbiosis is a stable state for a parasite/symbiote: because other states tend to destroy the host, causing the mutated strain to (usually) have a harder time propagating. That's all well and good when you're looking at evolutionary theory writ large, it's less appealing when you're talking about sticking a new bacteria in a specific person's mouth.
- corethree 3y ago>because other states tend to destroy the host No untrue. That is the most extreme case. A parasite can make a host less healthy and less likely to reproduce. This all lives on a gradient where parasitic relationship move the likelihood of reproduction down a little while symbiosis is the most extreme state where reproductive success is only positively effected. >it's less appealing when you're talking about sticking a new bacteria in a specific person's mouth. What does appeal have to do with anything? Much of our medical treatments were unappealing at one point in time. Colonoscopy? Sticking a camera up your ass to prevent cancer. Surgery? Cutting you open to fix something. None of it appealing but all of it necessary and worth it in the end. Also keep in mind we live in times where much of the food we eat is bioengineered to live in symbiosis with us. The difference is instead of directly manipulating the gene, we indirectly manipulate it through artificial offspring selection. All domesticated animals and plants have been manipulated this way at a macro level for eons. The difference here is that the manipulation is happening on the molecular level rather then the macro level. Your aversion to it is just instinctive and habitual but it's no different to much of the things we already do.
- skwb 3y agoI take very significant issue with the fact their appendix A and B do not link to the original literature. When I was skimming the pitch deck, I thought they had done the experiments themselves, but it just looks like they copy pasted the results without proper citation. At best this appears as miscommunication, at worst misrepresentation of the work they have accomplished. I work in medical startup space and the evidence we develop to prove our technology works typically has a higher threshold than what I've seen presented. I would want to see significantly more work done to demonstrate the scientific validity of this research. Do they intend to carry out any additional pre-clinical research (in vitro/in vivo)? Do they intend to do a clinical trial? It appears from their slide deck that they don't?
- darkclouds 3y ago>I work in medical startup space and the evidence we develop to prove our technology works typically has a higher threshold than what I've seen presented. Like what? >I would want to see significantly more work done to demonstrate the scientific validity of this research. Like what? Educate the layman instead of saying this is no good, please.
- forgotpwd16 3y ago>are there actual published results from legit scientists on this? The main papers referenced by document on the page are by JD Hillman on 1987[0] (et al) and 2002[1]. A layman review was done few years later by PopSci[2]. This specific site and company appear to have no relation to Hillman or Oragenics (co-founded by Hillman) that holds a patent on this[3,4]. [0]: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/00220345870660060101 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/002203458706600... [1]: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1020695902160 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1020695902160 [2]: https://www.popsci.com/scitech/article/2008-01/germ-could-save-your-life/ https://www.popsci.com/scitech/article/2008-01/germ-could-sa... [3]: https://www.oragenics.com/news-media/press-releases/detail/35/oragenics-receives-new-patent-for-improved-replacement https://www.oragenics.com/news-media/press-releases/detail/3... [4]: https://patents.google.com/patent/US9260488B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US9260488B2/en
- apsec112 3y agoThanks! They have a deal with Hillman for use of the tech, it's in the slides: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1OqDqFYMQdcS0XM4hORqNV85BPdDMS-8H7pS0MTG2gl8/edit#slide=id.g24896ac594e_0_90 https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1OqDqFYMQdcS0XM4hORqN...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]