3 ms·
> and noscript is more of a fallback mechanism That is exactly the good reason to get rid of it, for Google. Why would they want to allow a fallback to script-
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
> and noscript is more of a fallback mechanism
That is exactly the good reason to get rid of it, for Google. Why would they want to allow a fallback to script-less web?
- chrismsimpson 3y agoExactly. Once they can lock everyone into a JS only world, they can maintain their position as the only viable web index.
- sublinear 3y agoCreating a page that doesn't display content without javascript is literally the single worst thing you can do for SEO on Google or any search engine. Noscript has nothing to do with the issue you all are talking about.
- chrismsimpson 3y agoGoogle: Please make your pages easy to scrape, we’ll incentivise you to do so Also Google: If we detect you’re scraping us or any of our “partners” (read: the public web) we’ll shut you down. We have ways of ensuring we’re the only bot capable of indexing the web. Heard of web fingerprinting?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sublinear 3y agoGoogle does not have control over WHATWG. That's the point of its existence. Javascript can fail to load for a lot more reasons than just the user disabling it. Noscript is the only way to let the user know that's occurred or to ensure some functionality doesn't break. In fact Google Analytics uses a noscript tag containing an iframe as a fallback to keep the data flowing even when stuff like a content security policy or bad network request causes the javascript to fail.