3 ms·
What's the deal with flagging on this site? How does it work? Are people just able to flag shit they find inconvenient whenever & that's that? There are some v
by jauntywundrkind 3y ago
What's the deal with flagging on this site? How does it work? Are people just able to flag shit they find inconvenient whenever & that's that?
There are some very censor-ous voices about, it feels like.
This seems like such apt on the nose social commentary, poignant. Are the calls for censorship just abided when asked for? Are there any checks or restrictions on flagging on HN? Can flagging get overruled, and by whom and when?
- fortran77 3y agoThere's a "vouch" option that (I think) can negate a flag. But I'm not sure.
- defrost 3y ago[ vouch ] exists but it's an odd one, sometimes I see it, sometimes I don't - I think I might have lost my 'vouch' privleges by sticking up for too many flagged articles but then perhaps there's another hidden pattern at play <shrug>.
- catlover76 3y ago> What's the deal with flagging on this site? How does it work? Are people just able to flag shit they find inconvenient whenever & that's that? Yes, de facto, it's flag stuff you don't like and/or otherwise do not want gaining attention.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoIt just seems like there should be some means to not let whomever wants to remove content for any reason they feel like. I have sometimes seen "vouch" options but I guess maybe those permissions got removed. Because I ragged on the UK's fascist internet surveillance bill as horseshit, I think? So now I am unable to help others keep their voice. The systems here are undocumented & opaque & it sucks & is sad that hackers are subject to such unclear whims with no transparency & no way to negotiate for speech, of themselves or others. Edit: I still have vouch options on some flagged posts.
- happytoexplain 3y agoHow else could community based moderation possibly work? There may be guidelines, but ultimately the flag button means exactly one thing: "I think this should be flagged"
- fragmede 3y ago> Can flagging get overruled, and by whom and when? dang can, at his discretion, put a flag shield on posts to keep them up longer, and if you email hn@ycombinator.com he's happy to discuss things with you.
- joecot 3y ago1) I expect a lot of people saw the site and didn't realize it was satire, 2) as a Leftist tech person who reads Hacker News, whenever there's a discussion on here that is even slightly political, and I see the responses from a lot of HN users, I remind myself I read Hacker News for the insightful tech discussion.