5 ms·
For an article this pedantic they still miss several details. “If we measured the day starting and ending when the sun’s center breached the horizon, we’d be fi
by Retric 3y ago
For an article this pedantic they still miss several details. “If we measured the day starting and ending when the sun’s center breached the horizon, we’d be fine; day and night would be equally parsed.”
It then list a few caveats but that’s not sufficient as the sun is going to cross the the equator at some random point in the day say 2:15:45 pm which means it’s not over the equator at sunrise and sunset thus distorting the day. The horizon is generally defined based on local terrain not the more abstract true horizon. Earth isn’t a perfect sphere rotating at a constant rate etc etc.
It’s got some amusing bit’s of trivia, but I don’t think anyone’s definition is going to actually change.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- irrational 3y agoIsn’t that addressed in the first sentence? > On Saturday, September 23, at 6:50 A.M. UTC (2:50 A.M. EDT or 11:50 P.M. Friday PDT), the sun will be directly over Earth’s equator, which is how astronomers define the equinox.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Retric 3y agoThey mention it, but not the implications of it occurring at a specific time rather than a full 24 hour period.
- irrational 3y agoDo they need to mention the implications? I’d never considered it being a single moment (I’d always thought of it was being a 24 hour period), but I distinctly remember, after reading that sentence, saying to myself, “Oh, it isn’t a 24 hour period but a moment in time.”
- Retric 3y agoNeed to no, but even Wikipedia’s mentions them: “The word is derived from the Latin aequinoctium, from aequus (equal) and nox (genitive noctis, plural noctium) (of the equal nights). On the day of an equinox, daytime and nighttime are of approximately equal duration all over the planet. They are not exactly equal, however, because of the angular size of the Sun, atmospheric refraction, and the rapidly changing duration of the length of day that occurs at most latitudes around the equinoxes.”
- irrational 3y agoIsn’t that what paragraphs 5-9 are about?
- Retric 3y agoIt mentions this bit: “ They are not exactly equal, however, because of the angular size of the Sun, atmospheric refraction,” But not this bit: “and the rapidly changing duration of the length of day that occurs at most latitudes around the equinoxes.” An article about something should IMO be more comprehensive than its freaking Wikipedia page.
- irrational 3y agoIsn’t that part also discussed, starting in paragraph 18?
- avidiax 3y agoI hadn't thought of this part. I don't think that's the only limitation, though. Even with a spherical planet, no atmosphere, and 0-diameter sun, there might at most be a circle on the planet that experiences equal day and night. The planet, after all, is still rotating around the sun as it is rotating around its axis. It doesn't stop rotating around the sun at precisely the moment that the Earth's axis is orthogonal to the Earth-sun gravitational vector. Hence the day and night lengths are continuously changing, not changing once per day. So I imagine that there is at most a path/line/circle on the Earth's surface that has equal night and day by this measure, and at a minimum, a point, but I'm not mathematically inclined enough to calculate this. Edit: Same line of reasoning: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37629367 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37629367
- shkkmo 3y agoThat circle (or "longitudinal line") would only share the same length of day and night if it were measured from the center of the Sun crossing the horizon. This is because of another point glossed over the the article. The length of time it takes the sun to traverse the horizon varies and gets longer the further you are from the equator during the equinox (or the further from perpendicular the suns apparent path is with the horizon). This means that on the equinox, days nearer the poles are longer than days at the equator because we measure days as when any part of the sun are over the horizon. This becomes clear when you think about how at the equinox the north and south pole are in the middle of a week or two long sunrise/sunset.