10 ms·
The housing market is about to take a hit as student loan payments restart
- mrkeen 3y ago> 58% of economists polled in a recent survey say the resumption of payments will have a significant impact on mortgage affordability. A coin-flip of soft-scientists polled in a recent survey say...
- thsksbd 3y agoAs if what's going to happen depends on the ensemble average of predictors. Tell me why the lone economist predicts that there will be (and there will) an economic crash not how many
- Tenoke 3y agoPolling an ensemble of experts is much better than asking a single one, and there are some that vote 'not sure' or similar in those polls so it's hardly a coin flip.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoEconomists aren't really experts, though, as demostrated by the very fact that there's a 42-58 split. You wouldn't see that in any field where there's genuine expertise (e.g., mathematics, engineering, medicine...)
- thsksbd 3y agoNo. A only a reasoned argument counts for anything, no matter how many. Everything else is auguring.
- throw9away6 3y agoPeople paying off student loans probably can’t afford houses anyway different demographics.
- paulpauper 3y agobut what about the college wage premium?
- thsksbd 3y agoWhen normalized for talent, the premium is quickly diminishing and is closed for many fields of study.
- biohax2015 3y agoSource?
- throw9away6 3y agoI always took it to be a quality of life premium with better hours and work conditions but wages are quickly leveling off
- throw9away6 3y agoThe college costs ate it.
- tmn 3y agoThere are many doctors, lawyers, therapists, etc who are juggling mortgages or wanting to buy a house, and loan payments. Your point isn’t mute though
- vba616 3y agoOr moot.
- tmn 3y agoHaha yes, thanks for pointing that out
- throw9away6 3y agoThere are probably a few doctors that get hit pretty hard by that. Most collage grads even with 100k incomes can’t buy a house because any place that pays new hires 100k likely has house prices starting in the 600-1m range
- fortran77 3y agoGood! House prices are too high, and people should pay back their loans! It's a win-win! (And I say this as a homeowner.)
- darth_avocado 3y agoIt’s so ridiculous that economists, policymakers and even the fed is so out of touch with the reality of the market. The housing market highs are a result of less supply and not high demand. 90% of mortgages are locked in under 3% rates which ensures the lack of supply will continue in this high interest market, and in some sense even make it worse. A very low percentage of people will be so stretched with student payments that they’d give up on homes. If anything all sectors except housing market will take a bigger hit as housing takes priority over everything else.
- mberning 3y agoIt only takes a small nudge in the economy to force a lot of real estate back on to the market. A small uptick in unemployment could force the number of homes on the market to double or triple in certain areas.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoIf the problem is, as you say, "less supply" that means that it's mostly a local problem requiring primarily local fixes. "economists, policymakers and even the fed" aren't local actors.
- xapata 3y agoCan you make some money with that bet?
- sidewndr46 3y ago90% of mortgages may be locked in under 3%, but no one who has payed off their home is going to sell that and wind up financing another house with interest rates where they are at.
- ethanbond 3y agoInterest rates are not that high currently. Sheesh you give people a taste of 2.5% and they act like 7% is usury.
- 3y ago
- jmyeet 3y agoThe fundamentals of housing I think are still a ways away from a crash. There might be selective markets that cool off or drop. I'd also say Canada is closer to a crash than the US is. But I wanted to mention 2 hacks for legally avoiding crippling student loan debt repayments, possibly forever. 1. Move overseas permanently. This requires you to be on an IDR (Income Driven Repayments) plan, which you have to apply for. I'm not an expert in this but I believe that public student debt will allow this but private student debt may not. Side note: never refinance your debt privately with the likes of SoFi. You lose a lot of the protections you might otherwise have. How does this work? Through the Foreign Income Tax Credit ("FITC"). US citizens living overseas still have to file annual US tax returns, something only the citizens of the US and Eretria have to do. The FITC, if you claim it, exempts the first ~$110K of income from US taxes. Why does this matter? Because if your income is below that, your Adjusted Gross Income ("AGI") goes to $0 and your IDR payments also go to $0. After living overseas for 20-25 years you can get your debt forgiven. This creates a taxable event for your loan balance but inflation will reduce the real value of that and you have 20-25 years to prepare by, for example, putting money away every month since you're not paying student loan interest over that entire period. If you are a college graduate (which is likely given you have student loan debt but you may not have graduated) then you will be able to either get a work visa and eventual residency/citizenship in many other countries or you can apply directly for skilled migration. For most developed countries you'll avoid the crippling cost of health insurance that plagues the US too; and 2. The less extreme option is to find the cheapest online community college in your state and enroll in enough credit hours in anything to qualify as a half-time student. This will probably cost you less than $1000/year. That's not nothing but it will pause repayments and stop interest accruing, so it's cheaper. Keep doing this forever.
- vba616 3y ago>The less extreme option is to find the cheapest online community college in your state If you start your education with 2 years of community college, it works even better to manage debt.
- KirillPanov 3y agoThis should not be downvoted. It is a gaping loophole that ought to be closed, but downvoting it won't fix the problem. Also, it is the "Foreign Earned Income Tax Credit (FEITC)", not FITC. It covers only wages/salary, not dividends+interest. And it is $120k/yr currently, not $110k: https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/foreign-earned-income-exclusion https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/fore... However there are even worse loopholes in the FEITC. Due to a bungled tax treaty, US persons at the Pine Gap facility in Australia who are not US government employees pay no tax to any government at all on that first $120k: https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/foreign-earned-income-exclusion-and-the-pine-gap-facility#collapseCollapsible1695139537390 https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/fore...
- xwdv 3y agoNo it won’t. Any dip in price that occurs won’t be big enough to be a “hit”, and it certainly won’t be because of student loans of all things. It’s just the ebb and flow of the market.
- omgJustTest 3y agoCherry picking student loan payments is a heck of a random factor to usher this “hit”… of the available indicators: credit derating of the US, higher interest rates, historic strikes, inflation, etc. But we are talking about student loans because it goes into the Obama era affordability calculations in the post-2008 crisis. This, in my opinion, is short sighted and has little to nothing to add to the risk profile of a 30year loan. IMO borrowing rates are high and going higher, for no other reason than the US has no effective legislative actors to write the checks or govern. Also insurance agencies not covering certain areas of the country is going to torpedo large markets, and states that underwrite them, like CA are essentially trying to underwrite climate change without making the premiums unaffordable… what a pending mess.
- gigatexal 3y agoThis headline could easily be anything: dog shelters brace for flood of new dogs as student loan payments resume. Oh wait it was a headline: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2023/09/16/animal-shelters-student-loan-repayment-concerns/70825418007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2023/09/16/animal... There are so many downstream issues from this that I honestly think that promising it and then not delivering will be a huge hurtle for the Biden campaign to win over this demographic again.
- Larrikin 3y agoAs some one in the demographic that would have benefited, I saw he promised it, followed through implementing it (although in a wishy-washy kind of way that should have been bigger), and then had it snatched away from me for political reasons from the other party. It's exactly how I have come to view political issues when it comes to race, gender, etc. Better to have the Democrats over promise and sometimes kind of follow through than be targeted (either myself or family members/friends) for negative actions for a slightly lower tax coming out of my paycheck.
- czbond 3y agoThere are 2 paths for the upcoming generation to afford houses - as the prices are unsustainable. Let's see which group politicians choose to screw over: - Older homeowners, who statistically have a majority of their wealth in their home - Upcoming generations, whom if home prices do not drop - must have their wages inflated artificially significantly to afford the homes. Which then causes more inflation
- polskibus 3y agoThey will choose to screw the upcoming generations. Because they are themselves homeowners and younger ones don’t want to vote at all, at least more often than the older. Also the older generation is larger than the young ones in most western countries.
- bluehorizon2 3y agoYou missed one important point. Hedge funds and Private equity have billions of dollars waiting to buy up houses and condos. In their eyes every condo bought a family is a lost opportunity to create another renter who had no control over the rent that the funds dictate. They will never let house prices drop far enough so that regular people can afford homes anymore.
- ChumpGPT 3y agoWhy do people borrow so much money to go to school? I don't understand why kids do this shit, are they just stupid? I'm not special but family was poor and when I graduated HS, I went to work for 2 years to earn enough to go to a local State School. It cost approx 5k a semester. I did live at home but continued to work part time. I managed to graduate in 4 years without owing a single penny to anyone.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Why do people borrow so much money to go to school? I don’t understand why kids do this shit, are they just stupid? No, quite the opposite. See: https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20190723_R45090_4000d000927921a9885fad526a405e39a3f22f51.html#_Toc15047349 https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20190723_R45090_4000d00... And particularly, Table 2, Figure 4, and Figure 5. There’s a popular observation that real wages have been largely flat over the long term from ~1980. And that’s true, in aggregate. But the premium for bachelor’s (and even more so, higher) degrees has increased in that time period, with real wages for the degree-holding group going up, and for the non-degree group going down. > I did live at home Even if there is a public university campus close enough to allow that (and that’s not always the case), the student load is generally high enough that (other than the kind of people who are also likely to qualify for academic scholarships anyway) there’s no guarantee of a qualified individual getting in to their first choice school.