3 ms·
How about he was interested in giving a performance on his terms, and based on what he wanted to artistically convey, to people who could appreciate that and ca
by coldtea 3y ago
How about he was interested in giving a performance on his terms, and based on what he wanted to artistically convey, to people who could appreciate that and came for that, and not to be a performing monkey for people?
- kjkjadksj 3y agoThen he could have just not played the song instead of getting an attitude about it.
- coldtea 3y agoYou'd still be complaining in that case that "he got an attitude and refused to play the song". And perhaps he cared to not hurt them by not playing it at all, but was hurt himself and pissed that they cared for the "hits" and didn't appreciate his performance. How about that? The thing is, it's his concert. The artist choses the songlist. Would they pull the same shit on Miles Davis, or do they think because it's rock, the singer is their performing monkey?
- mannykannot 3y agoI think your proposal - that he was pissed and that he was acting out on account of it - is quite probably correct, and that's just self-important entitlement, whether its Lou Reed or Miles Davis doing it, and particularly in conjunction with his vigorous pursuit of royalties on his most popular works. If you choose to enter the marketplace, you have no basis for complaining when you are judged by it.
- coldtea 3y agoSorry, but the idea that the musician should be a "song-and-dance" man, pleasing the audience, or else they should forfeit their "vigorous pursuit of royalties", is some next level entitlement. It's also more of what a label producer would say to made-by-the-company boy bands, or can be said about market friendly "entertainer" types, and tribute bands, not something that should in any culture should apply to artists.
- mannykannot 3y agoIf artists choose to participate in the marketplace, then while doing so they are, to a not inconsiderable sense, choosing to be "song and dance men". And even when not, they have no justification for demanding or even expecting that others will agree to their personal estimation of their own works.
- jjulius 3y agoI'm genuinely curious about your relationship with music - is it that of a consumer, or have you ever interacted with it in a more direct way (eg, playing an instrument, making your own music, getting involved with your local scene, etc.)?
- mannykannot 3y agoAnd I'm genuinely curious as to why you might think that is of any relevance, especially as we have the opinion of an established musician quoted elsewhere in this discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37625189 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37625189 and also the examples of Brubeck and the Rolling Stones. As it happens, I am merely a consumer, while several of my close relatives are musicians, two make a living from it, one of whom also composes and has had their work performed in professional concerts by other musicians. Now, how about you? And let's hear from coldtea as well, especially given his remarkably condescending reply to the above post (I associate that sort of attitude largely with teenagers - which, of course, he may be.)
- jjulius 3y agoAs I read your last post I suddenly had a hunch, is all, and I wanted to see if maybe it was correct. I thought that, given how firm-footed you've been in your view here, it was unlikely that you'd been involved with music yourself beyond being a consumer. That perhaps you hadn't ever really interacted with it from an artistic/creative standpoint. That's not to say that there's anything wrong with that, or that I'm trying to use it as a slight towards you, I just feel that how we interact with an art form might also play in to how we view the output of artists. In short - I'm asking because I wanted to better understand what shapes your thoughts. >Now, how about you? Sure! I was raised in a very music-first household, picked up the violin at the age of 9, and ended up teaching myself to play the bass, the alto sax, the guitar, piano and how to DJ by the time I left high school. I've played extensively in a few jazz bands and have had mild success as a local dance music DJ. I also worked with a variety of underground concert promoters throughout my 20's, and still volunteer to set up sound or work the door at shows from time to time. My vinyl collection is also getting to be a bit too large, but c'est la vie.
- mannykannot 3y agoUnless he had made this clear beforehand - and apparently he had not - then the audience can justifiably feel that there had been an element of bait-and-switch to the performance. (I suppose you could argue that churlishly and begrudgingly performing that which had induced the audience to pay him for recorded and live performances in the first place was part of Reed's public persona!)
- coldtea 3y ago>Unless he had made this clear beforehand - and apparently he had not - then the audience can justifiably feel that there had been an element of bait-and-switch to the performance If the audience didn't knew who Lou Reed was, and what songs he likes to play in concerns and how, then they were not paying attention. Perhaps they went in thinking it's some crowd pleaser performing a meddley of their hits? That's not "bait and switch" that's more like "they bought pigs in a blanket". >I suppose you could argue that churlishly and begrudgingly performing that which had induced the audience to pay him for recorded and live performances in the first place was part of Reed's public persona! I'd go further and say that it was also part of his sincere preferences and character.
- mannykannot 3y agoApparently he is unstinting in collecting royalties on the works in question: https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/tribe-called-quest-lou-reed-got-all-the-money-for-can-i-kick-it-71760/ https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/tribe-call... And he did, after all, play them in concert, though condescendingly (and perhaps realizing that if he did not, future earnings from performances would come to reflect how well-regarded his preferred works are.) In aggregate, his behavior looks to me to be petty and entitled, rather than high-minded.
- penneallagricia 3y ago> he is Was. He died years ago. Show some respect and at least learn that before going on finding evidence to support your claim that "his behavior is petty and entitled". You clearly don't know who you're talking about