6 ms·
The era of America’s subminimum wage for tipped restaurant workers may be ending
- DaveExeter 3y agoI think it's important to move bartenders away from a tip model to a salary model. They would have a lower, but more consistent, income.
- invalidname 3y agoDo internship next! It's insane that internship is legal in the US. Minimum wage is the bare minimum.
- constantly 3y agoWe pay our interns the same rate as an entry level SWE, $185k, but divided up weekly for the intern period. There’s nothing wrong with internships at all. You may mean unpaid internships specifically? I got my start when I otherwise wouldn’t have had an entry to my industry with an unpaid internship, but also recognize that it’s a privilege to be able to not be paid for months at a time early career. I would personally never not pay an intern, but think there is probably a place for unpaid interns.
- Volundr 3y ago> We pay our interns the same rate as an entry level SWE, $185k, but divided up weekly for the intern period. Not everyone does this, and it certainly sounds like you wouldn't be affected by any laws requiring paying interns minimum wage. > There’s nothing wrong with internships at all. At your company.
- rightbyte 3y agoNewbies know nothing. I don't see how any company actually benefits from having interns or apprentices other than that it is a good thing to do for the community. You are getting a dime on the dollar for an intern. Even a intern working unpaid is a loss.
- tzs 3y agoPaying an intern less than minimum wage may be legal if it really is for the intern's academic benefit. Here are the factors that are considered to decide that [1]. [1] https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/71-flsa-internships https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/71-flsa-interns...
- nixass 3y agoTipping is such a bad idea in general. America please keep it to yourself
- DiabloD3 3y agoWhat a flippant attitude. Most Americans think tipping is undermining regulation and authority of the government to regulate, and should be a banned practice, but the rich keep fighting the majority on the issue. We don't want a tipping culture, this was done to us.
- Ericson2314 3y agoI think for many years people were also worried that abolishing tips means a one time negative shock to restaurant staff wages. Thankfully, now that we have tight labor markets and blue collar workers feel like they have actual bargaining power and are not just begging for alms from power-tripping small business owners, attitudes are changing.
- DiabloD3 3y agoPeople always had actual bargaining power. Why do you think the Far Right, wayyyyyyy back when we were kids (or before you were born, depending on what gen you're in) ran a specific actor, who was previously known for trying to run the Screen Actors Guild into the ground while still being an actor and part of it? They were afraid that the average man might get some ideas, so they got Reagan elected to fix that. This war on America started a long time ago because they're afraid of, apparently, paying people a living wage even though its the law, and has been so since 1933 when FDR signed it in. They still fight it like the law doesn't apply to them, somehow, magically.
- Ericson2314 3y agoI don't think people always had it, because I don't think money is neutral. It's unforgettable to admit, but a teeny tiny row in a database somewhere has a huge effect on people's wellbeing. When the government is doing (relative) austerity during a downtown, and household balance sheets get weaker, it's not mass psychosis, people really are squeezed and employers have more power, real power.
- Ericson2314 3y agoExcellent news! One problem in the industry is that it errs on catering to "luxury experience" and neglects the "I just don't want to cook market". This will also help with that: Better wages -> labor saving -> less frivolous pretending one has servants and more emphasis on the food itself
- shw1n 3y agoPersonally I would love to see the restaurant service model in Australia implemented here in the US: - workers paid a decent wage - tipping not expected - tax included in price Aka price you see is the price you pay
- wazoox 3y agoThat's basically how it works in Europe too. Actually I'd say it's how it works in civilized countries.
- guiriduro 3y agoIts jarring for a european when you visit the US and expect the workers to be compensated a living wage from the ticket/menu price, to find everyone hustling for tips and it being a weird expected thing because their actual wage is low (despite the prices being more aspirational than the food, often.) It also promotes poor hustling behaviour, whether thats non-owner taxi drivers driving like maniacs, or servers pestering every second with dreadful weak coffee you don't want, then expecting a tip.
- hotpotamus 3y agoI wonder - does Australia mandate that?
- jpollock 3y agoWhat part, tax inclusive pricing? Yes. It keeps the populace from realizing how much tax they're paying. :) No tipping? No, that's social. Workers paid a decent wage? I'm pretty sure that servers would claim they're not paid a decent wage. Australian minimum wage is AU$23.23, or USD$15 - USD$16.37 using PPP. Cost of living comparison: Sydney vs San Jose, CA https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?country1=Australia&country2=United+States&city1=Sydney&city2=San+Jose%2C+CA&tracking=getDispatchComparison https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?cou...
- mrmincent 3y ago
- GoRudy 3y agoI’ve been to low or no tipping countries like France and Brazil and the service is incredibly bad. Coming back to the states is a breath of fresh quality service air.
- chank 3y agoTimes I've been to low/no tipping countries; service was literally idistinquishable from what I experience in the U.S.
- yardie 3y agoThe service is what it is because the restaurants haven't offloaded paying the staff directly onto the customer. A restaurant owner in the US doesn't care if 1, 25, or 50 servers are on duty. They pay almost nothing for them to be there. A french restaurant is staffed just like a retail store. Just enough staff to provide minimal to adequate coverage and nothing more. Because the owner eats the cost not the server.
- Ericson2314 3y agoSome of us don't want to be pampered, we just don't want to cook. We're tired of subsidizing others' ludicrous desire for aristocracy role-playing when we just want to eat food.
- Ekaros 3y agoI only need what 3 to 5 interactions in whole process. 1. Bring me to table (or let me find it myself) 2. Take my order (food and drink) 3. Bring my food/drinks. 4. Allow me to pay... Could add one or two in between, but I don't see any reason why there should be need for anything beyond these basics.
- Ericson2314 3y agoDream bigger :) I want more buffets/ cafeterias. We can cut the labor down far more than that. I'm not saying I would go on a date to the cantina, but I sure as hell would do that instead of cook 10/10.
- quietthrow 3y agoPardon my lang, but it’s about #%!#ing time. Profits over people have given us a lot as a society and I say that as a beneficiary of it as someone living in the states. I think it need to evolve to sustainable profit along with people, community and planet. We can’t and should not get rid of profit. But we need to preserve it by evolving. Tipping wages keep things artificially low and sustain a system in which a certain class of people are perpetually exploited. I for one, as a resident of US can’t wait for it this to go away.
- deaddodo 3y agoThe largest proponents of tipping have always been the service staff themselves (followed closely by restaurants). The service staff like it because they generally take home far more than minimum wage (something they're still guaranteed, btw, they only get the subminimum when tips exceed minimum wage), and the restaurant likes it because they can increase their margins since consumers pay their staff. The people who generally hate this the most are consumers because they're the ones getting the short end of the stick. Don't get me wrong, I hate the ridiculousness of tipping in the US and how 20-25% has somehow become the norm over 10-15% a few decades ago. But I hate it as the fucked over consumer, not over some misguided notion of worker exploitation. And honestly don't even understand how people have bought into this weird, obviously incorrect, talking point.
- bane 3y agoWe travel internationally a few times per year and have come very soundly down that the American tipping culture is more or less a cancer in our culture. It sort of hides the true cost of service, and doesn't really motivate service workers (after all you can tip in no-tipping countries if you want) but now three things have happened: 1) Tipping is regularly hitting north of 20% -- even for self-service or fast-food type venues. When 1/4-1/5 of your bill isn't figured into the food price, people take mental notice and restaurant patronage is significantly down. Payment processors at POS are also somewhat responsible for this trend, as much of the Tip request process happened by the store, who usually put it as a blank line on a paper bill, but now it's offloaded to the processor's systems and all kinds of nonsense shows up on the Tipping screens. 2) Due to recent rapid inflation, services are trying to "fake it" to keep prices down, but adding in other fees before the tip, which makes consumer costs go up anyways. It's becoming a significant legal problem in many areas when an additional 10-15% "fee" shows up on the bill. 3) Even with tips, workers can't make ends meet as housing and other basic living costs have gone through the roof. There's a nationally recognized worker shortage, and it's because even taking extra shifts and providing exceptional service isn't bringing in enough TIPs to make ends meet, so workers are leaving or switching to other industries. Which makes the service worse when you do eat out. This means consumers can't figure out how much it costs to eat out anymore. That $10 sandwich and drink combo from 2020 is now $16 + tax + fee + tip = >$20 and now you're getting the same thing for more than twice the price, all a change in the last 2-3 years. So fewer people are eating out. The food industry is tipping over into a death spiral and it's become time to properly professionalize the service industry and return Tips to a "not expected but welcome" option.
- dingnuts 3y agoWages will adjust such that restaurant workers make roughly the same amount that they would have with tips, except for one critical thing: they'll be more reliably taxed because their wages will be reported by their employers on their W-2s instead of part of their wages potentially being received as cash. I am convinced this is the real reason that there is suddenly a push to end tipping culture in the US. The tax man wants his. Anyone that understands economics understands that the overall effect of ending tipping will have very little real effect on wages. All it does is give employers and tax collectors more power over these low wage earners.
- FireBeyond 3y agoIt also explains why service staff simultaneously play the underdog of impoverished and selfless, while resisting the urge to move to a more regular taxed income mechanism.
- darth_avocado 3y agoGreat but let’s not make this into a minimum wage job that has the same expectations of tips as right now. It’s going to be worse for consumers and the workers.
- Kalium 3y agoLet's be honest with ourselves, that's exactly what's going to happen. Enforcement of minimum wages among tipped workers is famously lax, and this is unlikely to change anytime soon. Coupling this with taking away the tax dodge that is cash tips, and you'll see a backlash from workers who see no reason why they can't have both.
- doktorhladnjak 3y agoPlenty of states don’t have a tipped minimum wage right now. It hasn’t changed tipping culture there at all.
- _delirium 3y agoDC recently eliminated the tipped minimum wage and tipping culture is definitely in flux. Mostly because many restaurants have started adding a 10-20% service charge (called various things, like a “restaurant recovery fee”) to make up for the higher wages, which they claim is not a tip. But many diners interpret this as a mandatory tip and do not tip additionally, or if they do, they tip a lower amount than they previously would.
- frob 3y agoIf a company is charging me a service or recovery fee that is a percentage of my bill, I am taking it out of the tip. If they want to use that money to pay the expense that is their employees, they can make it part of the cost of the food, just like everything else. It's not like I pay a separate lease fee or food inspection fee or menu printing fee or electrical hookup fee or whatever. Paying your employees a decent wage is part of running a business. It's disgusting when bosses pull tricks like this to try to lay the blame on their employees.
- jdenning 3y agoI’m dubious that tipping is going away, based on my experience living in Portland. Waiters in Portland make a minimum wage of $15.45/hr, tips cannot be used as “credit” to this wage (illegal in Oregon). You’ll still get stink-eye for tipping less than 25%, and that’s at a restaurant where you order at the counter, and bus your own table.
- lvspiff 3y agoIts blown my mind coming from the tipping capital of the world (Vegas) to Portland. The attitude when you don't give a 20%+ tip is so annoying . In Vegas no one ever shot me a glance or gave a sarcastic "thanks", however here its been shocking how entitled they are especially at the food carts and bars.
- ripper1138 3y agoI was just trying to convince my friend recently: if you order at the counter and bus your own table, you don't have to tip! Even Subway shows the tip screen now, and only an insane person would tip at Subway.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 3y agoMost countries have a minimum weekly take home wage. That isn't the minimum hourly wage for every hour... It is the minimum amount a person must walk away with when divided by the number of hours they worked in a week. The difference is subtle... But it means you can be paid $6 per hour for some hours, as long as you are paid $25 for other hours in the same week. Likewise, your employer can 'fine' you for being careless... but the fine must still ensure your pay for the week doesn't fall below the minimum. And the employer can pay you hardly anything yet let you have very generous tips - again, as long as the total is above the minimum.
- londons_explore 3y agoGovernment has a good reason to get rid of tips... They are frequently untaxed or not correctly taxed. It isn't the employee who loses out - it is uncle sam.
- londons_explore 3y agoIf the US wanted to get rid of tips, state or federal government could simply make tipping a crime - akin to bribery. There are a lot of parallels between tipping and bribery anyway. "I'll give you a nice big juicy tip, especially if you push my food order to the front of the queue!" Make both accepting and giving a tip illegal. And give rewards to either side for reporting the other.
- Simulacra 3y agoNo matter how much a person makes in wages, they will always want more money. That's completely natural. The only way to solve tipping is for people to stop. Just stop. Every time you tip it's furthering the system of abuse and coercion.
- nunez 3y agoThis is gonna absolutely demolish many small and medium sized establishments, but as someone who loves dining and drinking out, if you can’t pay your staff a real living wage, then you don’t deserve to exist. While I’m happy to tip 100% or more on my tabs, I think tips are a cancer that needs to be eradicated.
- rognjen 3y agoI "love" articles like this because you can run basically the same content dozens, if not hundreds of times, with very slight modifications.