7 ms·
India fails to re-establish communication with its Moon probe
- throwbadubadu 3y ago"However, there was uncertainty about the possibility of these to resume functioning after facing extremely low temperatures of the lunar night which can go as low as -200 degrees Celsius. Moreover, its battery needed to remain at a certain level to be able to recharge again with the solar dawn." Naive guy would think that alone can and would be extensively tested on earth?
- toast0 3y ago> Naive guy would think that alone can and would be extensively tested on earth? The article says the probe achieved its objectives in the first active period. This attempted wakeup was for bonus time.
- NortySpock 3y agoAnd it would have been designed to achieve all those objectives in the 14-day lunar sunshine period. You could design a car that runs for a billion miles, but no-one could afford it. You pick a reasonable lifespan for a project and target your specifications around that.
- pixl97 3y agoYa, and the Indian mission was already one of the lowest budget successful missions there has been. The US is one of the few countries that can spend billions on missions where the lander may last months/years longer than expected.
- warkdarrior 3y ago[flagged]
- moralestapia 3y agoThis is a troll post, right?
- flashgordon 3y agoWe probably found it cheaper to build it, send it, test it than build a lab to get to -200°c :)
- Halfwhit 3y agoI too like to live dangerously and test in production
- AwaAwa 3y agoHopefully you never get to peek behind the scenes of much of the world's running infrastructure.
- xorbax 3y agoYou have to build the thing and test every possible problem before you build it again and do it for real We all know everyone is perfectly willing to pay and wait for thorough testing so it works perfectly Nobody would ever underfund something and then complain about how the final product didn't produce 150% of what was promised
- toast0 3y agoEveryone tests in production. Some people also have additional environments to test in.
- brushinator 3y agoAnd yet the lunar lander and the astronauts on the moon did just fine. Did the lunar lander and the body suits have heaters?
- jackmott42 3y agoThey didn't last 14 days or try to survive the lunar night, and we spent a rather large % of our GDP on the project, while India's landing was an order of magnitude cheaper than any previous moon lander.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoThey did, but they also left before the lunar night.
- evgen 3y agoThe humans inside the suits and lander also provided some useful heat. For most spacecraft, once you put humans into them the problem changes from conserving heat to getting rid of it.
- brushinator 3y agoOk so at 120 degrees C got it
- NamTaf 3y agoKinda crazy what effect different albedos have, isn’t it? :)
- seabass-labrax 3y agoIf you haven't already, I would highly recommend watching 'Apollo 13'[1]. On a technical basis it is really accurate to the real-life events. The astronauts having to shut down the lunar lander's (LEM) heating system comes into the story about half way through. It's one of my all-time favourite films! [1]: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0112384/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0112384/
- publicola1990 3y agoThere has been other probes that continued to operate over multiple lunar cycles, how did they manage?
- thefurdrake 3y agoJPL and whoever's behind engineering for the ESA have decades of experience on the Indian space program. I believe the approach is to shut down all nonessentials and run a heater to keep the battery above failure level during the night. This sounds simple but I'm pretty sure it's an absolute nightmare to design autonomous systems for, especially when you've only encountered those situations theoretically or in a controlled lab environment. Space is hard. It hates us. It hates life. It hates any form of order and will actively attempt to destroy it. Trying to make things that survive in space is Difficult. It would have been easy to go "Lol india amirite", but the fact is, this is one of the hardest things humanity can do.
- justsomehnguy 3y ago> This sounds simple Especially for someone who never experienced anything lower than -5°C. Most cars wouldn't even start at -20°C if not equipped with a more powerful generator and battery from the factory. This is measly 20° difference.
- thefurdrake 3y agoIt got below 0F a couple years ago and my garage door wouldn't open. -200C in a vacuum is an entirely-different engineering paradigm as I understand it. Materials just don't behave the way we expect at regular temp/pressure.
- suckitsam 3y agoThere was a whole writeup (on here, IIRC) about the engineering behind the only (or one of less than a handful) types of planes that can transit Antarctica during the cold, dark months. The fuel freezes, the oil freezes, the rubber in the tires and gaskets becomes brittle, and basically nothing normal works. I recall it being similar-but-different to the SR71 modifications, where the parts are loose and continuously leaks fluids because the materials all change shapes so much in the environment they're designed for. And of course it all has to return to the initial state for (a safe) landing.
- r721 3y agoKind of off-topic: first time I see a efe.com link, looked it up in Wikipedia and surprisingly it's "the world's fourth largest wire service after the Associated Press, Reuters, and Agence France-Presse ... created in 1939" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EFE https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EFE Just four posts were submitted to HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=efe.com https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=efe.com
- calgarymicro 3y ago> the major multimedia news agency in the Spanish language That's probably why.
- swarnie 3y agoSeems about right, two English speaking, one French, one Spanish. The legacy of empire.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mehulagrawal 3y agoIf I understand correctly, this was the expected and most likely outcome. The planned lifespan of the lander and rover was only 14 days.
- blackoil 3y agoYes, probability of it surviving 14 days in Lunar Night at -200C was extremely low. India doesn't have Radioisotope batteries that work at this temp. It will also increase the payload size and will require larger launch infra. Not to mention all the material and chemical challenges faced at these temp.
- sidewndr46 3y agoThat seems like an obvious opportunity for diplomatic and scientific outreach and partnership. Did India want this project to be entirely homegrown?
- gerdesj 3y ago"Did India want this project to be entirely homegrown?" I suspect so and I also think that if you are going to test your skills, then being realistic in the first place is good idea. The mission was always sold as unlikely to survive the night but that would be a nice to have if it did. For me the mission seems to have worked rather well and performed exactly as billed.
- goku12 3y agoNot entirely. There were plans for international cooperation for the missions (with Russia IIRC). However, it didn't go through. Anyway, future collaborations are planned - probably with Japan first.
- throwawaymobule 3y agoHas any country exported an RTG to be shot into space by someone else? Vertically-integrating it yourself is one thing, but I'd expect NASA exporting a chunk of plutonium to India, even if they're both are nuclear states, would be challenging.
- waffletower 3y ago[flagged]
- HexDecOctBin 3y agoHopefully, the Canadian moon rover doesn't shelter and sponsor terrorist-gangster nexuses for short term political gains. Oh wait, there is no Canadian moon rover!
- waffletower 3y agoWe are laughing, but not at your misplaced competitive jibe, but at you for stooping even lower by saying it.
- HexDecOctBin 3y agoWhat makes you think that the gangsters who extort and terrorise Indo-Canadians today will not start doing the same to white Canadians tomorrow? You have no idea what kind of monster your politicians have raised in your backyard; and seeing you domestic politics now, it might already be too late to control it. But feel free to keep laughing, it's good for the health.
- RugnirViking 3y agoI worked with a few sikh guys at one of my old jobs. Lovely chaps. I'd like for you to meditate long and hard about exactly why them wanting their own homeland is so unacceptable to an india where indian nationalists (not a majority) did bombings and assasainations when seeking independance from the raj. such things were unacceptable then and are unacceptable now. But like back then, it would be wrong to punish the rest of the population because of actions of so few, or to reject outright the idea of independance
- nirav72 3y ago>them wanting their own homeland Ahh yes the freedom fighter fighting for his homeland that was a Canadian citizen. Not even a citizen of a country he was fighting against or having even lived there for decades. Got it.
- petre 3y agoAt least they've sucessfully got a probe onto the Moon, as opposed to Russia who poisoned their lead scientist with mushrooms after it failed to do so.
- nphard85 3y agoInteresting. Is there a source for this claim?
- petre 3y agoYes, plenty. This one has the tone of The Onion. "Professor Vitaly Melnikov, 77, who had headed the Department of Rocket and Space Systems at RSC Energia, Moscow's leading spacecraft manufacturer, had been battling a sudden and grave illness before his death. The source of his poisoning was inedible mushrooms, Moskovsky Komsomolets, a Moscow newspaper reported."
- m348e912 3y agoIt's strange to me that the only footage released has been low res/low frame rate. It seems like a significant oversight to neglect to include cameras that can take, store, and transmit high quality video. Anyone have any links to footage I might have missed?
- goku12 3y agoI'm pretty sure that camera isn't the problem. It's the bandwidth of the radio uplink. That's limited primarily by the power budget.
- rammer 3y ago[flagged]
- AbrahamParangi 3y agoWhy would the authors have any kind of feelings about India succeeding or failing?
- tyre 3y agoIndia was hoping that the probe could hibernate through the night and operate again in the day. The headline accurately reflects that they’re trying to communicate with it and failing.
- dkqmduems 3y agoBlame Canada.
- vadym909 3y agoI mean Reliance Jio (India's most popular cell phone plan) is great for how cheap it is, but it has its limits!