7 ms·
LastPass: ‘Horse Gone Barn Bolted’ Is Strong Password
- HenryGrant 3y ago[flagged]
- azimmm 3y ago[dead]
- jrockway 3y agoChoosing a good key derivation function has always been critical to making passwords work. I guess lastpass didn't do that. I have not benchmarked these recently, but I fear that they had to compromise # of iterations to give "2012 low-end Android device" some chance of ever being able to unlock their vault. As a result, everyone else is vulnerable. Adding icing on the cake is leaking everyone's encrypted vault. Whoops!
- Scaevolus 3y agoKDFs only add 10-20 bits of security in terms of attack costs, there's only so much you can do to make 8 character passwords safe. If you control the parameters you can improve that boundary-- say, FDE with a KDF that uses 8GB of RAM and 10 seconds to compute-- but consumer products are limited.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoUsing LastPass is like reusing a password with extra steps.
- lifeisstillgood 3y ago>>> KrebsOnSecurity last month interviewed a victim who recently saw more than three million dollars worth of cryptocurrency siphoned from his account. That user signed up with LastPass nearly a decade ago, stored their cryptocurrency seed phrase there, and yet never changed his master password — which was just eight characters. Nor was he ever forced to improve his master password. This does fascinate me. How many people who have won the crypto-lottery like that still keep invested? Is most of the crypto gain unrealised so far? Or most of it been drained out?
- thghtihadanacct 3y agoOr not realize they have a terrible password. The thing I notice is not all services allow spaces. A sentence of regular dictionary words has proven a good password for a long while otherwise.
- codetrotter 3y agoThe more early someone was in mining or buying Bitcoin, the greater the possibility that they believe in Bitcoin in and of itself. I.e. to someone who was early into Bitcoin, they might wish to never sell off all of their BTC. And besides, even if you wanted to sell off your Bitcoins, there are a number of things to consider: - Taxes. Why sell millions of USD worth of Bitcoin now, and pay taxes on all of it today? Possibly better in some situations to sell enough to live comfortably for a few years, and then sell more later when you need to again. - What are you gonna do with the money instead? Put it in stocks? Buy a bunch of houses?
- Doxin 3y ago> The more early someone was in mining or buying Bitcoin, the greater the possibility that they believe in Bitcoin in and of itself. Citation needed. I got into bitcoin back when mining on your CPU was actually a reasonable thing to do. I tried selling it when it was worth about $50, only for mtgox to promptly fold. Suffice to say I firmly believe bitcoin isn't really a solution to anything. Of course anecdote does not data make, but neither does an unsourced claim.
- araes 3y agoThis is a classic issue with money. What do you do if you're Taylor Swift? You're a 750 millionaire, with the next couple 100 on the way from this tour. Whelp, spent the first 50 on a house all humans will drool over. Got the compulsory car. Got the compulsory jet. Got the compulsory yacht (not quite as large as Bezos' (ehmm, banana?) that could not leave its construction port). [1] And with the other 600 million? Private air force? [2] Air craft carrier for your private air force? Or you end up like every wealthy human, dumping your money into real estate so that you can buy 1000 houses for every normal human, and completely "disrupt" the housing market. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koru_(yacht)#Koru_and_De_Hef https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koru_(yacht)#Koru_and_De_Hef [2] https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/32869/this-man-owns-the-worlds-most-advanced-private-air-force-after-buying-46-f-a-18-hornets https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/32869/this-man-owns-th...
- handsclean 3y agoThe first paragraph very nearly lost me – irrational, rage bait, directly contradicts later stated facts – but there’s some good content later. The chief complaint seems to be that LastPass is not forcing this upgrade, they are just blast emailing unaffected people that they “forced” it while not actually doing so. And they’ve pulled similar stunts in the past, and in current communication seem to clearly be blaming users for their weak settings and passwords while erasing the fact that LastPass chose the settings, ok’d the passwords, botched the upgrade, and still hasn’t fixed most of their mistakes. Everybody with a clue knows LastPass is a lost cause, but what’s more interesting to me is how we can generalize the lessons we’re learning here. I’d propose that user blaming in general is evidence of bad tech and magical thinking around it, and that points a finger at some very interesting targets.
- autoexec 3y ago> Everybody with a clue knows LastPass is a lost cause, Yeah at this point, I have to wonder how there are still lastpass users to worry about whatever the latest lastpass scandal is.
- ThrowawayTestr 3y agoI'm too lazy to change.
- kstrauser 3y agoTake the 10 minutes to migrate to Bitwarden or 1Password or such and be done with it.
- kawfey 3y agoit takes a bit more than 10 minutes to convince my family to also migrate their passwords and re-figure out how to use it when all their life they used the same password for everything.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y ago
- aklein 3y ago“For example, another important default setting in LastPass is the number of “iterations,” or how many times your master password is run through the company’s encryption routines” How does this help?
- bawolff 3y agoIf you are complaining about the idea of iterating a hash multiple times, this is actually a fairly standard construction to increase the cpu cost of brute forcing hashes.
- aklein 3y agoOk I googled. I guess it makes sense as it helps to protect against pre-hashed rainbow tables or dictionary attacks by making them more computationally expensive.
- bawolff 3y agoUsually people use salt to protect against rainbow tables. Iterating a hash function (e.g . PBKDF2) is most just a way to make hashing take longer. Since attackers have to make very many gueses (while legit users only have to hash the password once), increasing each guess by a few seconds can really slow things down. However in modern apps they usually try to use more complex constructions like argon2 to make it so you cant use GPUs to do lots of guesses at once.
- codetrotter 3y agocorrect horse battery staple :) Speaking of which, if you want to generate long memorable passphrases, I have an open source cli tool I wrote for that, which I myself use. https://github.com/ctsrc/Pgen https://github.com/ctsrc/Pgen Give it a spin
- peter422 3y agoAs somebody that has been using lastpass for many years and continues to do so… I just do not understand how people who pick weak master passwords complain about this. The lastpass documentation makes clear over and over that your entire DB can be compromised but as long as they don’t have the master password, you are safe. How people do not think one step past this and realize they need a very secure master password is beyond me. And yes I know there will be a host of comments telling me they are in the password business so they need better something and guides and whatever, fine. But for anybody with the slightest bit of common sense, lastpass was and still is secure and lived up to their promise.
- daydream 3y agoWhy do you still use lastpass?
- kstrauser 3y agoYou’re right to a point, but there’s a world of difference in ways you can store a password. If their algorithm were a single round of MD5, it’s going to be a lot easier for an attacker to guess a password than if they were using Argon2. I don’t think LastPass is using MD5, but my point is that their job is to make any master password harder to guess. They’re not doing it.
- michaelmrose 3y agoYou are overestimating the technical ability of users by orders of magnitude. Even people who are nominally "experts" in one technical area at least adjacent to computing who are completely useless outside of the most basic thing. Running a business or a project implies dealing with people as they actually are not as we might hope they could be.
- WalterBright 3y agoI wish people would stop publishing my password. Now I have to change it again.
- username135 3y agoImo, Keepass > all
- XorNot 3y agoAgreed: combined with Syncthing for making it accessible on my devices (which plays nicely with Keepass2Android Offline edition). Then handle backups with a cloud provider of your choice + additional encryption (basic rule I've been happy to see validated: never upload personal files to the cloud without encryption, after the whole Google content scanning debacle).
- anon_cow1111 3y agoIs there any reason NOT to set the number of iterations/hashes as high as reasonable by default? From an end-user standpoint, it might take an extra second or two vs 0.1 seconds, but then you've increased the brute force time needed by ten. The most efficient way to brute force "Horse Gone Barn Bolted" would be with a minimal dictionary attack, say the most common 2000 words, plus s ed *ing variants. you're still looking at 1+ quadrillion combinations for that password, not including spaces. That can't be that fast assuming a slower hashing algorithm, right? -non crypto person's wild guess
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThe whole approach that LastPass uses of only encrypting the vault with the master password is just bad security - it really doesn't matter how many rounds of a key derivation algorithm they use. The 1Password approach provides much better security. The vault is protected with the master password together with a long randomly generated string. That random string is saved on device on first login, so subsequent decryptions just require the master password. Logging in on new devices require this "account key", but the added security of having a completely uncrackable encrypted vault, regardless of the entropy in the master password, is very much worth it.
- danparsonson 3y agoSerious question - I've never used 1Password - what happens if you only ever use one device and that device becomes permanently unavailable for some reason (stolen, destroyed, etc)?
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoAs part of the setup process 1Password has you print out an "Emergency Kit" that contains your secret key, https://support.1password.com/secret-key-security/ https://support.1password.com/secret-key-security/. But you are absolutely correct, if you lose your device and the Emergency Kit you're SOL. It reality, though, that is mitigated by the fact that: 1. I think it's probably pretty rare to install 1P on only a single device, as the biggest benefit of any hosted password manager is syncing. I think the vast majority of people will install it at least on their phone and a laptop/PC. 2. I think the user experience for setting up the Emergency Kit is done well and most people are likely to do it.
- danparsonson 3y agoThanks!
- time0ut 3y ago> Since then, a steady trickle of six-figure cryptocurrency heists targeting security-conscious people Such as… > That user signed up with LastPass nearly a decade ago, stored their cryptocurrency seed phrase there, and yet never changed his master password — which was just eight characters. I don’t want to victim blame and I agree with the anti-LastPass sentiments. I just find it amusing that Krebs keeps trotting out the “security conscious“ victims with 8 character master passwords.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- verteu 3y ago1Password does it right: Everyone's master password is augmented with a big randomly generated "Secret Key" that is stored (only) on their machine. Even if their entire database was leaked, the Secret Key guarantees a good minimum password strength. (The main drawback is that the user now needs to save this Secret Key or get locked out forever. But it's less sensitive than the master passphrase, since it's mainly designed to protect against this mass-leak scenario.)
- pmarreck 3y agoA little while back I created a completely frontend-only (to the best of my knowledge) complex password generator in Codepen, maybe someone else can find it useful (or fork it and make it better). https://codepen.io/pmarreck/pen/gOQxdqW https://codepen.io/pmarreck/pen/gOQxdqW Here's an online demo of the zxcvbn library which makes a good-faith attempt to rule out passwords based on semantic/contextual evaluation: https://lowe.github.io/tryzxcvbn/ https://lowe.github.io/tryzxcvbn/
- Sanders7 3y agoI never believed I could recover all my funds back to my wallet, my colleague introduced a professional hacker to me ADRAIN LAMO HACKER AGENCY, and this hacker recovered the $766,000 that was stolen from me by these online scammers. ADRIAN LAMO HACKER AGENCY recovered all my funds within 24 hours. If you’re a victim I do advise you to consult These professional hacker via email: Adrianlamo@consultant.com