You're not contradicting the point of the article. >> As Evans summarized, models that have memorized "Tom Cruise's parent is Mary Lee Pfeiffer" in training, f

You're not contradicting the point of the article. >> As Evans summarized, models that have memorized "Tom Cruise's parent is Mary Lee Pfeiffer" in training, fail to generalize to the question "Who is Mary Lee Pfeiffer the parent of?". But if the memorized fact is included in the prompt, models succeed. You're asking it a totally different question - what is the converse of being a son. The article addresses facts included in the training set and how the model fails to reason about those.