4 ms·
The Uncertain Future of the U.S. Military’s All-Volunteer Force
- CobaltFire 3y agoAs someone who just finished 22 years in the Navy: It’s getting harder and harder to get young people in with the capability to adapt to the demands. I don’t know that this is good or bad (it’s a pretty unreasonable lifestyle); it just is. Couple this with the cutting of recruitment incentives that are motivating, and retention incentives being gutted (retirement was cut almost 20%), and we’ve known that there was going to be a failure to meet manpower needs for a while now. That’s even leaving aside the points brought up in the article, which are all relevant. I, personally, recommend against anyone joining unless they really don’t have an alternative.
- halJordan 3y agoI'll disagree that it's hard to get people "capable of adapting." And I also resent the implications. The Service however is increasingly ossified. It increasingly wants to ossify. And Cyber is of course the perfect example. The Navy was charged with building something like ten Cyber Mission Teams and instead of doing that they just battle-rostered the key individuals to whatever team was being externally inspected. For years; and Navy leadership is totally unrepentant. The Army? Not much different. The Army cannot keep talent in the ranks. So Congress mandates incentive pay for key workroles. If enlistedmen demand their Congressionally mandated pay the 22-year veterans get pissed off at the 'mercenary' young people who don't adapt to the all-consuming Mission. Despite the fact that the DoD Civilians earn twice as much for the Exact Same Role.
- CobaltFire 3y agoI thought I was fairly open that I don’t necessarily consider the failure of many of our recruits to adapt to be their problem; the military isn’t a very good way to live. Specifically, I was very nearly a fatal failure to adapt (suicidal attempt), and am speaking from that perspective. There is much they could do to address this from the services side. The Army tried to recruit me to the cyber warfare side towards the end of my career, and after taking one look I ran. I wanted nothing to do with that structure.
- jschveibinz 3y agoMandatory national service-whether it is military or civilian-could be a great way for a majority of high school graduates to identify vocational opportunities that they wouldn’t have otherwise investigated. And, it could be very motivating for some: 1. “do well enough in school and you will get a better position in your national service placement.” 2. “do well in your national service placement, and maybe you’ll get acceptance or even a scholarship to a great college.” Change is difficult. If I were a teen and someone told me I had to do 2 years of national service, I would freak out. But with the demographics being what they are, something profound has to be done.
- lovich 3y agoWe actively chose to have a volunteer army instead of conscripts because professional soldiers perform better than throwing people who don’t want to be there in the first place into a fight. We should look at how to convince more people to enter the military by doing things like increasing the pay or not leaving veterans at the mercy of a complicated bureaucracy to get healthcare for their combat related illnesses before we throw our hands up and decide to just start throwing unwilling kids into the meat chipper again
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- QuarterReptile 3y ago>We should look at how to convince more people to enter the military by doing things like increasing the pay 'More money' really hits diminishing returns when you can't balance it against other factors. I walked away from raise to about 200k/yr (and favorable tax situation if my wife works) and 10 more years to a valuable retirement, including very good insurance, and that particular role is still substantially undermanned.
- lovich 3y agoYou walked away from a role in the military paying that much or you walked away from the military to a 200k/yr position? My understanding is that the military is looking for people to fulfill jobs that the private sector is paying multiple times more in salary on top of not having to deal with all the loss of rights and strict lifestyle that comes with military positions
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SCSIfloppy 3y ago[flagged]