4 ms·
There’s no point in denying the fact that users want root access on their phones. Power users do. Most do not. That alone is the reason Google will never make
by untog 15y ago
There’s no point in denying the fact that users want root access on their phones.
Power users do. Most do not. That alone is the reason Google will never make it a priority.
- ajross 15y agoThis argument is a tautology. "Power users" are just a synonym for people who want stuff not in the default. To the extent that the default installation lacks desired features (wifi hotspots are a good example) we are all "power users". But yes: gaming, browsing and texting don't require it. And a big portion of the user base never leaves that box.
- shabble 15y agoThe issue is more about where on the functionality vs usability/support costs graph you draw the line. If there's a desirable feature that also has significant drawbacks (maybe accidentally racking up heavy data charges because you unintentionally created a public unsecured WiFi WAP, or shitty battery life, or something) then it might get the chop just because it costs (too much) money to support, rather than because the general public don't want or need it. I think the most practical solution, given that people are always going to want to push the limits of the devices, is to permit, but disclaim responsibility/liability where possible. "By accessing the root features of this phone, you're no longer eligible for $x direct support, and you're aware of $bignum ways in which this could be a Bad Idea" The problem with that is too many people are going to put on their disclaimer-blinders, and click straight through anything that isn't Making Their Damn Internet/Facebook/Game Work, and call you anyway when it screws up. Maybe a certain barrier to entry does have some merit after all...
- ajross 15y agoI'm sorry, but the "expensive support" argument is a red herring. Is there any example anywhere of an otherwise-successful product (in any realm) whose profitability was impacted by users hacking/modifying/diddling the hardware? Carriers and platform vendors (but not, in general, hardware manufacturers) don't want users running unauthorized code because they don't want to lose access to revenue streams therein; and by extension that they fear the loss of control means they will lose access to any future revenue streams.
- bmj 15y agoI wonder how Apple did this math? I look at this way: Microsoft pushed tier-1 support, at least, to the resellers, right? I buy a Windows laptop and do Bad Things via the admin account, what do I do? Go back to where I bought it, or I call the Geek Squad. In the case of Apple products, I'd take my shiny laptop back to the Apple store, and they'll deal with it (generally). So is that support cost baked into the already-high cost of Apple hardware+software? That said, your argument is probably a good one, too--the carriers and platform vendors really do like lock-in, so they would likely do whatever they could to turn off root access.
- ajross 15y agoApple is a content provider. They get a cut of iTunes downloads. So they aren't a pure hardware manufacturer. Samsung frankly doesn't care if you root their phones once they leave the factory, but Apple loses money when you jailbreak an iPhone and start dropping torrent-sourced videos on it.
- eli 15y agoBut the default Android installation does have wifi hotspot features! If it's not on your phone, you're either running a very old version of Android, or your manufacturer or carrier choose not to enable the feature.
- ajross 15y agoI know; obviously I meant that it doesn't work (either at all, or without a very expensive carrier upgrade). Rooted phones can simply install a wifi hotspot app from the market; that's probably the single biggest driver of phone rooting. Yes, there are issues about carrier licensing. Let's not get into that. I'm simply talking about why people root their phones.
- eli 15y agoSure, but to respond to the question in the headline, helping people cheat their carrier out of expensive plan upgrades is probably not actually a brilliant business move for Google.
- hobin 15y agoA relatively low percentage of users * the total number of people who buy smartphones = a heck of a lot of users. If they manage to pull those people away from other companies (and such a future would do that), it's a big win.
- eli 15y agoBut there are lots of features that different small subsets of users would want.
- huxley 15y agoI'm not sure that it's established that people will actually buy smartphones for that reason. Take webOS which you could put into dev mode (essentially rooting) by entering the Konami code (upupdowndownleftrightleftrightbastart ). Didn't seem to do them a bit of good. So easy rooting may be a desirable feature but doesn't seem to sufficient feature to ignore other more important features.
- hobin 15y agoI stand corrected. I didn't know that, and indeed assumed the impact would be signifcant.