9 ms·
How to Roman Republic, Part IV: The Senate
- jackconsidine 3y agoWhoa! I picked up The Fall of the Roman Republic by Plutarch this week and have been glued. Will definitely be reading this whole series
- swasheck 3y agothe fall of the roman empire is such a fascinating, and surprisingly divisive, topic. enjoy the read and then pick up other works and it will feel like hearing the same story through a brand new lens. this may be part of the enduring curiosity with the roman republic and subsequent empire - it's so complicated and nuanced that you cannot simply distill it down to a single factor.
- Symmetry 3y agoIt's amazing this showed up on Hacker News before it showed up in my RSS reader.
- monocasa 3y agoMakes you wonder how prevalent RSS->HN submission scripted automation is, or if it's just the thundering herd of users.
- bee_rider 3y agoThis guy has absolutely nailed the nerdy-but-accessible vibe, no surprise his posts are recurring first-pagers.
- belval 3y agoI wish we had a Bret Devereaux for more topics, but then I might never get things done.
- ethbr1 3y agoIt seems like there's a ridiculous amount of time to sink into a single blog post. So you're probably looking at mostly historians to be able to do something like what Devereaux puts out. The closest I could think of would be: Derek Lowe Neil deGrasse Tyson (when not playing for camera) Adam Savage Nigel Braun (NileRed) Salman Khan Dianna Cowern (Physics Girl) Grant Sanderson (3Blue1Brown)
- OscarCunningham 3y agoMatt Levine for finance topics.
- snowpid 3y agoThis is the reason I think about the Roman Empire at least once a week!
- Ian_Macharia 3y ago"I'm thinking about it right now!"
- belval 3y agoThis has the be the funniest trend to come out of Tiktok. My SO point blank asked me how many times I thought about the roman empire and I replied "I don't know, once or twice a week". Little does she know we get a post from acoup every week! Reference (for those out of the loop): https://www.forbes.com/sites/conormurray/2023/09/18/how-often-do-men-think-about-the-roman-empire-a-lot-according-to-new-tiktok-trend/?sh=7883feb4a388 https://www.forbes.com/sites/conormurray/2023/09/18/how-ofte...
- genewitch 3y agothanks for the reference. I mean i could have websearched around for a while, but i've been asking everyone that comments in my friends group, about this topic, and i'm getting "it was a trend" but not where or why it started. when 1/8th of the planet knows about a trend and i'm out of the loop...
- jjulius 3y agoI was completely out of the loop as well, until my wife shot me a completely out of the blue text this morning asking me if I thought I could help land a plane in an emergency, and how often I thought about the Roman Empire. After I begged for context, she told me about the trend, and then about three minutes later I happened upon this thread and this comment chain was at the top lol.
- swasheck 3y agomy wife asked me and i said once per week. then she and my daughter cackled and asked me to repeat my answer and i knew i was about to become part of a trend so i refused. but isn't it fascinating how truly interested in the roman republic and emopire we are? people are coming up with theories about why this is the case but i'm not sure any of them resonate with me. i was always more of a greece person until i visited italy 7 years ago and i was thoroughly smitten.
- gmaster1440 3y ago[flagged]
- CydeWeys 3y agoHN really needs to add "No AI generated comments" to the site rules. I'm not interested in reading AI summaries in comments here; I come for actual discussion by real people.
- gmaster1440 3y agoI don't see how a short AI summary dissuades actual discussion by real people. If anything, it can lower the barrier to entry and encourage more people to comment and participate, especially for longform pieces.
- riazrizvi 3y agoPoint to Charlie Munger, whom I was critical of a few days ago, how is so much written on how the Roman Republic worked, without talking about the most basic of incentive structures that drove its citizens to work like no others in the first place - The Law of Twelve Tables? It gave every citizen property rights that were protected by the State. The system was _the_ get rich game for the common man (after Alexander replaced ancient Greece's Solonian Constitution with his Royal authority). Roman soldiers were citizens looking to make money, it was a so called army of merchants. Joining the empire was an attractive proposition because people saw an opportunity to break out of their own opportunity-poor regimes, so the model spread like wildfire, though obviously resisted by hereditary rulers who stood to lose their cozy positions.
- arrosenberg 3y agoAnd look! The problems started when the wealthy Senators started hoarding land in the aftermath of the Punic and Greek conquests. The Gracchi - land reform issues! Marius - land reform issues! Caesar - land reform issues! It's as if history rhymes.
- 1980phipsi 3y agoSlavery certainly had an impact on that as well.
- riazrizvi 3y agoRhymes indeed. Caesar rode a popular wave of resentment to a system that was increasingly gamed by the powerful few, and it ultimately lead to power being captured by an even more concentrated body, the office of an emperor, Augustus, Caesar’s heir. Isn’t this the exact thing we see in the USA where the economically disadvantaged seek solutions from the right whose policies aim to further concentrate wealth and opportunity?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ulizzle 3y agoI think I’m almost out of this illness. Still sweating the fever but no migraines Ive been reading a lot because that’s about the only thing I can do so I read the original Gallic wars from Julius Cesar and its funny because he’s painted like a bad guy today for becoming a dictator but the Senate was at that point so corrupt and inefficient and everyone hated it so he wasn’t the only one trying to get rid of democracy. Julius Caesar had actually been involved in four attempted coups before he got it done. And he was popular with the public even after his death so that makes sense I’m sure a lot of here think of the Roman Empire almost obsessively. How bad is this turn toward extrémeme censorship and surveillance? At what point do people say to hell with it and bring back kingship?
- rootusrootus 3y ago> At what point do people say to hell with it and bring back kingship? That seems to be well in progress, though I don't think anyone is actually using the term 'king' yet.
- lokar 3y agoJudges are: “the president is not a king, and you are not the president “
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoYes, they're using it in the negative. But Yarvin and the "Dark Enlightenment" people seem to be using it seriously (so far as I understand them).
- lokar 3y agoBut that they thought it worth pointing out is telling
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoI had a ton of time to kill in an airport recently, so for a little while I hung out at the end of the TSA line to let the confused passerby know that yes... this is the end of the line for peasants. Nobility goes over there. I think I did a much better job than the existing signage--branding sort of confuses the matter. Had a lot of fun conversations with other peasants about whether this is the kind of privilege that the french revolution was fought over. The nobility didn't have as much time to stand around and water the seeds of revolution. Seemed fitting.
- philipov 3y agoI hope he does a series like this on civic governance in Han China next!
- fladrif 3y agoUnfortunately he as a historian specializes in the Mediterranean, specifically Rome.
- DylanSp 3y agoAs great as that would be, it's well out of Devereaux's area of specialization; I don't think he'd feel like he could do that topic justice. If you look up his older series on farming, he notes in the introduction and in his addendum on rice farming that he's not as familiar with Chinese history.
- red_admiral 3y agoHe does guest posts though, so maybe there's a chance?
- eru 3y agoYes. Though I'd be more interested in Song China, ever since reading The Gunpowder Age by Tonio Andrande. Btw, Tonio Andrande's 'How Taiwan Became Chinese' is available for free online at http://www.gutenberg-e.org/andrade/intro.html http://www.gutenberg-e.org/andrade/intro.html
- DylanSp 3y agoHe's referenced Andrade's work in the past, so that's actually a possibility, though I think he'd focus more on their military due to his focus and background.
- swasheck 3y agobret devereaux is a great follow on twitter, uh ... X, as well. his thoughts on the ukraine/russia conflict are very interesting to me
- pphysch 3y agoI was curious, so I looked. He's out there boosting Timothy Snyder. Oof. I'll pass.
- lying4fun 3y agoI’m not familiar with Timothy’s persona/work, why did that repel you?
- _whiteCaps_ 3y agoCan you explain further? I see on his Wikipedia page: "Since Russia's 2022 invasion of Ukraine, and the bombing of its energy infrastructure, Snyder has spoken and written widely on the history of Ukraine and its worldwide importance for democracy, on the disastrous geopolitical effects of the invasion, and on the need for other nations and individuals to stand for the protection of territory belonging to that state." which seems reasonable to me.
- pphysch 3y agoSnyder leans heavily on moralizing and evidence-free psychoanalysis to explain current events. It's far too much "trust me I'm an established intellectual" and far too little evidence-based reasoning for me. To each their own.
- ethbr1 3y agoHis modern stuff is more... eh. E.g. I thought there were a lot of flaws in his early-war "NATO can't supply X, because Russia will threaten nukes" positions, as he completed ignored the obvious opposite "Russia can't escalate, because NATO will threaten nukes" 110% love his Roman-period deep dives though. There's probably a smarter quip than me out there to the effect of "Great people share their brilliance on many matters, while the greatest speak on but a few."
- eru 3y agoThe same blog's posts on Sparta are also really worth reading: https://acoup.blog/2022/08/19/collections-this-isnt-sparta-retrospective/ https://acoup.blog/2022/08/19/collections-this-isnt-sparta-r... The author also did a guest appearance on Drachinifel's Youtube channel about the Punic war: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVnXG0Yrfns https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVnXG0Yrfns