4 ms·
> It is not in dispute that India has a complex and bloody history discriminating heavily against it's Sikh minority in Punjab. I am not entirely aware of what
by throwaway12asd 3y ago
> It is not in dispute that India has a complex and bloody history discriminating heavily against it's Sikh minority in Punjab.
I am not entirely aware of what happened during the 80s. But India was ruled by Congress party under Indira Gandhi, not the current "Hindu nationalist" BJP. When the farmers protest happened recently, even though the farmers (most of them Sikhs) were literally chasing away policemen with swords and tractors, the government didn't do any violence (beating protesters with batons, water cannons don't really count since its a standard practice in my South Indian state as well). In South India, the local government literally used police snipers to kill 12 protesters when people were protesting against pollution by a factory [1]. So, when compared to that, the farmer protesters (majority Sikh) were pampered.
If the government has actually killed him, and if it would prevent the deaths of 1000s in the future, it is definitely worth it.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thoothukudi_violence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thoothukudi_violence
- deanCommie 3y ago> the government didn't do any violence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Blue_Star#Casualties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Blue_Star#Casualties
- fakedang 3y agoThe current Hindu nationalist government didn't resort to violence against the Sikh farmers. Compare that to what they did in Gurgaon after the religious riots, where they practically demolished the homes of the entire Muslim community. Also, Operation Blue Star was carried out by a secular but hardline government led by a pseudo dictator. Although looking back, it was probably justified considering the Pakistani support for Khali Stan even today. And the Prime Minister lost her life for those actions.
- screye 3y agoOperation Blue Star was run by Indira Gandhi, the child of an atheist socialist and an atheist Parsi. It was a hard decision, it was badly executed, but it was not rooted in religious extremism.