3 ms·
It's really hard to engage with articles that talk about late stage capitalism, and "things capital wants to push". It's so divisive that it belies a worldview
by robertlagrant 3y ago
It's really hard to engage with articles that talk about late stage capitalism, and "things capital wants to push". It's so divisive that it belies a worldview that is either too simplistic or too biased to say anything useful.
And the article bears that out. It's not saying anything new. Yes, "content" is a category, of which there are many subcategories, each with their own stars and losers, processes and histories. So what? It still all needs compressing and caching and firing across the internet in a similar way, hence content.
And yes, there are hangers-on to the latest fad, just as there always were. That long-predates anything we know as capitalism. It's the iron laws of fashion and ideology that are at play. Once we told young men that the best thing ever is to go and die in a field somewhere for a king they'd never met, and a lot of them did that. Once we told people that other classes are all that stands between them and a wonderful life, and they slaughtered those other classes, and then they starved because the other classes thing was a lie. Now we tell people that AI is worth working on. I'll take the capitalism version of that over the others any day.
- passwordoops 3y ago100%. We do have a problem with the current setup but unfortunately the argument gets co-opted by left-right superficial complainers, and "late stage capitalism" is a good proxy to know which side of the divide the author lies. The issue with the current system parallels what was wrong in the 1920s-1930s, i.e. too much concentrated private power, and the solution then was Antitrust, not redistribution of wealth, not regulation directing how the robber barons should operate, and definitely not communism. Just straight-up trust-busting to strike a delicate balance between just enough government and corporate power to keep each other in check
- paganel 3y agoAt this point the “center” has also become an extreme wing, I mean, failing to see the obvious societal problems brought by the current economic system (however one might want to call it) is purely based on ideology, there’s no moderate common sense that used to be the domain of the centrists in past times. As such, calling out left- or right-wing extremists from a position that has become itself ideologically extremist is bringing nothing new to the political discourse.
- h2odragon 3y agoIn your view, are there any non-extremists? Perhaps the only purity to be found is in the ignorant, the innocent, the children? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Crusade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Crusade
- pseg134 3y agoI think he would be okay with mentally retarded people as well.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paganel 3y agoAt least back then kids weren’t cutting themselves because of depression at age 11 or 12 nor were they killing themselves because of the same reason at age 16-17, and I’m talking about cases that I know directly (mean not read in the media). So, yes, the condition of children in our society was included in my original thought. But me wanting for us to resume the (even extended) family as a solution to that problem would get me branded almost on the spot as at least right-wing adjacent by what now stands for “centrists”, because “family values” as a whole are now associated to right-wing-ism. I could give at least two, three other examples (probably more) of stuff that I believe in which would probably get me branded as left-wing, stuff that used to be the domain of common sense, of the political center, until a few decades ago even in the West (for example affordable housing for all is being more and more associated with being left-wing, that wasn’t always the case).
- danaris 3y agoI think that what's actually happening is that "the center" in the US (and some other Western countries) is now so far to the right due to the moving Overton window that to maintain a "centrist" position requires, as you say, willful blindness to various societal and economic problems. This doesn't make it "more extreme centrism"; it just means that "the center" is already flirting with what would by any other measures be the far right. ...Actually, I think there is another force at work here: many of the people who consider themselves "centrists" in the US are the same who considered themselves such 20, 30, even 40 years ago. But a) with the aforementioned moving of the Overton window, they are having to suppress increasing amounts of cognitive dissonance to continue to self-identify as centrists without recognizing that they are now well to the right of where they would have been previously, and b) with the (slightly paradoxical, only possible due to the increased polarization) simultaneous increase in awareness of the marginalization of various groups, and acknowledgment that it is neither good nor neutral to continue that marginalization, anyone advocating for either maintaining the status quo or returning to some prior state has to either openly state that they want to continue the oppression of these groups, or, again, suppress the cognitive dissonance in any of various ways. In the end, I think it's really just a long-winded way of restating the Desmond Tutu quote: "If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor."
- johnnyworker 3y ago> So what? It still all needs compressing and caching and firing across the internet in a similar way, hence content. But it's not DBA and network engineers calling it that, it's "everyone". It rubs me the wrong way the same way gamers suddenly using the word "franchise" did. "oh yeah, this obviously sucks and makes it a worse game, but I can understand why they would want that for their franchise".
- robertlagrant 3y agoIt's not everyone. People who are Youtube creators say "content", sure. Wordpress says it because it manages a superset of these various things, and the users using it need the terminology to understand it. But that's not everyone. Most people watch movies or read books.
- johnnyworker 3y ago> People who are Youtube creators People who upload videos to youtube. That is what they do. And no, they don't need it. They could say "video". Easily. Also, I did put "everyone" in quotes for reason. Slice it how you want, a lot more people than those actually managing a "container" something else could be "content" in use that word. That was a shift that happened. And it's one thing when HR thinks of humans as resources, quite another when humans start referring to themselves that way.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> That was a shift that happened. You could say this about anything. When did loads of people start saying "shift" instead of "change"? Or "space" instead of "garden" or "room" or "atrium"? Saying something changed doesn't give it much significance.
- johnnyworker 3y agoIt contradicts the claim that "content" is what people say because that's what they have to say, to understand what they're posting or reading/viewing. It's no more significant than is warranted by what we're talking about here. It's fine. > When did loads of people start saying "shift" instead of "change"? I'd say "shift" is a subset of "change" and slightly more specific (every shift is a change, not every change is a shift). People didn't change how they speak, some adopted the language of website operators, and then even more people started to parrot that unthinkingly.
- RandomLensman 3y agoInvestors, i.e., capital, are quite literally pushing things in order to increase returns of their investments. People talking their book is nothing new or unusual.