2 ms·
>If your metric for code success is the money it returns, then that is the only metric in which open-source has lost. What? The dream of open source and its id
by coldtea 3y ago
>If your metric for code success is the money it returns, then that is the only metric in which open-source has lost.
What? The dream of open source and its idea of winning, as it was discussed on peak FOSS movement era (late 90s, early 00s), was about widespread user adoption and overthrowing the Microsofts and Apple's of the world on the Desktop, with people using FOSS software, open protocols, and so on, and taking control of their computers.
It wasn't about what Google or Uber or Facebook might use for its backend. Or what FOSS libs some company like Apple or Adobe might use to create their proprietary software.
So, this dream has never happened. Instead businesses used FOSS for their closed off backend stuff, or for the behind-the-scences OS backend of their proprietary mobile phone platforms, whose crucial part is all the proprietary add-on services, and which almost everybody uses in its corporate official release, while people's computers and smartphones were never more locked-in.
The mass movement of FOSS idealism has also vanished (the kind that every kid in computer science cared about, the kind that made headlines, launched thousands of blogs and discussions on the subject) and so on. Now it's either a hobby or a corporate paying gig for most, seen in a pragmatic light.
- dbish 3y agoAgreed, and I think there is a bit of a shift to where open source is being used more frequently as a marketing technique/getting the first traction for funding and eyeballs then land and expand to nearby non-open source areas which muddies the waters of the entire community. Not only do the equivalent of the old hackers of yesteryear who supported this movement no longer feel they need to be running Linux machines as their daily driver (ever startup engineer seems to have a Mac), but those running many well respected projects have to justify business impact which might put the OSS side at risk at times. There are well known huge OSS projects today that change licenses for future releases even after contributions (ex: text gen), or relase open source models/software that would be very commendable except they have their own modification to the licensing agreements to filter out competitors or just make it ambiguos enough that you don't want to touch it since you don't want to pay for lawyers yourself (ex: Llama, Falcon) to figure out what the non standard additions would mean to your project. Building a customer base off open souce to funnel towards your revenue or kneecap competitors is the direct opposite of what the FOSS advocates of old would advocate for (even if the right strategic move) an would have been such a philosophically bad thing to do that they'd be to embarrased to do it (there are ways to make money without doing that, see Redhat), there was an emotional aspect to the the devs who grew up in or adjacent to this movement 15+ years ago. Open source for many companies now rhymes with the Open in OpenAI, where yes, it may have started that way with the best intentions, but things change. The idealists are gone, which is a bit sad, bu it's probably ok to not have the next RMS evoling in a computer lab today with a new rendition of the open source software song reconfigured for tik tok virality (j/k the GNU project was a key piece of what drove Linux forward of course).