3 ms·
F-35 fighter jets can only fly 55% of time, US watchdog says
- wslh 3y agohttps://archive.is/2023.09.21-183552/https://www.ft.com/content/a3741488-3350-44fd-940f-f0d494d54587 https://archive.is/2023.09.21-183552/https://www.ft.com/cont...
- FrankWilhoit 3y agoDid they get that number by averaging South Carolina with the rest of the world?
- halJordan 3y agoI'm not saying LockMart execs are traitors, but I am saying it takes a special kind of person to occupy such a grey area so clearly.
- ReactiveJelly 3y ago> Part of the challenges stem from a heavy reliance on contractors for maintenance that limits the Pentagon’s ability to control depot maintenance decisions. Delays also arise from spare parts shortages, inadequate maintenance training, insufficient support equipment, and a lack of technical data needed to make repairs. All solvable problems, right? It doesn't sound doomed.
- cbm-vic-20 3y agoIt would be interesting to know how that compares with other fighters in the arsenal.
- greedo 3y agoSuper Hornets (F/A-18E/F) have under 60% according to the CBO. F/A-18C/D are even lower than that. F-15C/D are around 50%. F-16s look to be around 60%. A great snippet from the CBO report is: "Availability rates for DoN’s aircraft fell from 48 percent in 2015 and 2016 to 45 percent in 2017, 42 percent in 2018, and 40 percent in 2019." There are several factors that affect availability rates. Some is aircraft age (F-15Cs have lots of mileage on them, as do the B-1s). Some is aircraft complexity. But one of the most important things is adequate (or inadequate) spare parts supply. This can be due to the various services not prioritizing this, or Congressional funding etc etc. https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57433 https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57433
- AustinDev 3y agoWe had 16's before 22's and yeah 60% sounds about right for the Vipers. They were pretty damn reliable all things considered.
- KyleBerezin 3y agoIs there some kind of financial incentive for anti F-35 press? 55% is an acceptable rate. I recently (like this week) decided to make a spreadsheet analyzing the claims of the F-35's high incident rate and airframe loss. From what I can tell, the F-35 is our safest fighter aircraft by a mile. I'll post my numbers here, but please don't take them as fact, this was done for personal curiosity. incidents|fatal accidents|lost airframe|total flight hours Typhoon |11 |7 |10 |650,000 Gripen |16 |1 |9 |337,500 F-35 |14 |1 |3 |721,000 F-22 |14 |2 |6 |300,000 Rafale |10 |2 |5 |600,000 F-16 |732 |195 |652 |19,500,000 F-15 |219 |71 |190 |7,350,000 V-22 |49 |11 |19 |666,750 incidents/100kH |fatalities/100kH |losses/100kH Typhoon |1.69 |1.08 |1.54 Gripen |4.74 |0.30 |2.67 F-35 |1.94 |0.14 |0.42 F-22 |4.67 |0.67 |2.00 Rafale |1.67 |0.33 |0.83 F-16 |3.75 |1.00 |3.34 F-15 |2.98 |0.97 |2.59 V-22 |7.35 |1.65 |2.85 All incident/fatality/loss data are from aviation-safety.net. Flight hours are from various sources and some are extrapolated. *Fatalities is a count of the number of accidents which resulted in the death of one or more PILOTS, not bystanders. The loss of 2 pilots is counted once.
- elashri 3y agoI think you should also factor out the cost. The cost of one F-35 airframe might exceed a squadron of some jets in this list.
- KyleBerezin 3y agoA F-35A is 70M, and the F-35B is 80M. This is pretty cheap compared to most other jets that are still in production. I don't have perfect numbers for all of them, but the Typhoon is 124 million, the Rafale is 100-120 million, the F-15EX is 80 million, and the Gripen is 85 million. I think the only one that is actually cheaper is the F-16v at 63 million. These are just base procurement costs, when a country buys combat aircraft, they also but a lot of supporting equipment like simulators and maintenance systems. The F-35 is going to cost more per flight hour to maintain than most of these non-steath aircraft though. Especially the Gripen, which was designed specifically to have a very low cost per flight hour.
- KyleBerezin 3y agoEdit: There is an error in the numbers, the F-35B wasn't included in the F-35 numbers. Aviation-safety.net tracks the F-35A/C separately from the F-35B. The new numbers are F-35 |28 |1 |8 |721,000 F-35 |3.88 |0.14 |1.11 Still the safest aircraft in our inventory that I know of, but more airframe loses than the Rafale.