3 ms·
> Regulation routinely reduces cost. Can you provide an example of this actually happening in a competitive market? > Only one party is incentivised to say tr
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> Regulation routinely reduces cost.
Can you provide an example of this actually happening in a competitive market?
> Only one party is incentivised to say trot out this “regulation is bad” BS and its businesses that want to operate in an ancap utopia because they weren’t lucky enough to make regulatory capture work for them.
Businesses that want to challenge an incumbent who succeeded in making regulatory capture work for them would be an obvious counterexample, and for the same reason the customers who want to see the challenger succeed in making the market more competitive.
- patmcc 3y ago>>Can you provide an example of this actually happening in a competitive market? Tobacco companies probably made a bunch more money as aspects of their advertising became restricted/regulated/banned - because they were basically in an arms race with one another and spending more and more to maintain market share. But that is a pretty specific case, I'm not going to make any claim that's general or applies to airlines. https://www.nytimes.com/1989/01/02/business/the-media-business-ad-ban-might-help-cigarette-makers.html https://www.nytimes.com/1989/01/02/business/the-media-busine...
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoMaking more money doesn't imply that they lowered prices, and in general the relationship is the inverse. Also, they did not lower prices: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUUR0000SEGA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUUR0000SEGA
- Sai_ 3y agoDecriminalising and regulating marijuana reduced costs to consumers - such as the cost of going to jail in return for possessing marijuana.
- bfung 3y agoBut if it wasn’t “regulated”(ie: criminalized) in the first place, it wouldn’t need to be decriminalized and regulated.
- lmm 3y ago> Can you provide an example of this actually happening in a competitive market? No doubt you'll no-true-scotsman "competitive market", but buying a house in the UK got significantly smoother/cheaper when sellers were required to provide a certified survey to all interested parties, rather than each buyer having to commission their own survey. Lemon laws are widely recognised as making it cheaper to buy a reliable car. Food safety regulations made food a lot cheaper by rendering imported food trustworthy.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoWhat you're getting at here is regulations that... increase the competitiveness of a market. Which does imply something about the preexisting competitiveness of that market, and was the reason for that caveat. Competitive markets are what keep prices down, and you need a regulatory environment that facilitates them. The trouble is you can't even say things like "food safety regulations increase competition by rendering unknown sources trustworthy" because it depends on both details and context. You could easily have food safety regulations that impose high overhead and drive small providers out of business, or different market dynamics that provide an alternate way for customers to evaluate trustworthiness. And each attempt is an opportunity to make a mistake and do the opposite of what you intended -- or the exact thing the incumbents wanted and lobbied for. It has to be done with care, and rarely in only cases of great need, because it's so easy to screw up. And then competition can't fix it, because regulations are enforced by a monopoly. Which is where we are now, in all too many cases.
- renewiltord 3y agoWell, I'm as pro-market as the next person, but surely fire brigades are the classic anti-example: the market was competitive with many fire brigades, prices were inelastic sure, and there was a lot of time-elasticity of demand, but the customer had the short-term ability to shop, etc. Government regulated fire brigades reduced competition and decreased cost. I default to "regulation increases cost" as well, and think that the default position should be to justify it, but I don't think the opposite is a zero-instance situation.
- ks2048 3y agoI’m not sure if it’s relevant to the issue here, but if you want an example of a regulation that reduces cost: “you cannot sell medicine X for more than $Y”. You could argue that in a pure market such a rule would never help (a competitor would naturally offer it cheaper, if possible). But if you look closely there few “pure” markets.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoWhich is better given an uncompetitive market, an regulation that says "you cannot sell medicine X for more than $Y," or a regulatory change that restores competition to the market? The latter is better to such a degree that the former is just a toy example with no practical use outside of academic discussions and corrupt politicians who want to avoid solving the underlying problem on purpose.
- ffgjgf1 3y agoLiving in utopian abundance would be even better but sometimes not every option is feasible, especially in the short term. The objectively inferior option might still be better than doing nothing.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoInefficient hacks are often worse than nothing because they remove the momentum behind fixing the underlying problem. You reduce the margin from 2500% to 1000% and think you're helping, but what you're really doing is condemning yourself to paying a 1000% margin forever because it's now below the threshold that people get outraged enough to do something about it.
- devilbunny 3y ago> “you cannot sell medicine X for more than $Y” This leads to shortages. I am speaking from experience here. I'm an anesthesiologist, and with three exceptions I can think of, our drugs are all off-patent, so their prices are basically a function of production costs. But the federal government of the US, which buys a lot of drugs under the VA and Medicare, has a rule that you can't increase the price by more than X% per quarter (or year, not sure). Now, we all agree that this sounds like a good regulation. Right? Nobody can just raise the price of insulin by 40000%? Except that generic drugs really don't make much money, and when one company leaves the market for a given drug (there are usually only 2-3 manufacturers per drug), the remaining corp(s) can only make up the shortfall by moving to 24-hour operations (in the short term). Staffing that means hiring more people and paying overtime. So the cost of production... doubles, at least. The part that is missing: it's a drug that sells for twenty cents for a sterile ampule. Doubling it to forty cents is not going to break the bank. It's cheap, it will continue to be cheap, and yes - in the long run, someone will set up a line to make it for ten cents and sell it at twenty. But in the short run? You run out of drugs. I've seen it in almost every category of anesthesia drugs (induction, opioids, paralytics, paralytic reversal, etc.) in the last ~20 years. You'd think that "not being aware during surgery" would be one of those things that people would care about, but it isn't.
- nerdbert 3y ago> Can you provide an example of this actually happening in a competitive market? How about EU regulations on the price of mobile phone roaming between member nations (the "roam like home" rule)?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoEither there isn't a lot of competition between carriers there and they were just sticking the roaming fees in their pockets before, or there is a lot of competition and the carriers had to make up for the increased usage and loss of roaming fees by raising the prices of phone plans. This isn't the same thing as whether you like the result of the rule. Maybe paying a little bit more in total in exchange for having a more predictable monthly bill is something people like. It would still be paying a little bit more, if the market there is competitive.
- Agingcoder 3y agoAssuming markets default to be competitive is wrong I think . Natural cartels and monopolies do exist after all, or markets have high entry costs etc. Economic theory usually assumes pute and perfect competition, which doesn’t exist in many markets
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt's not assuming the market is competitive. Wireless markets are often not competitive, because entry is limited by scarce spectrum availability etc. which incumbents lock up to limit competition. The point is that if you had a competitive market, margins would be thin and the only place for lower prices to come from without a reduction in operating costs is higher prices somewhere else. It's easy for regulations to lower costs in an uncompetitive market because the lack of competitive pressure allows the incumbents to do all kinds of inefficient nonsense that would drive them out of business if it was actually practical for new competitors who don't do that to enter the market and undercut them on price. But what you want to do in those cases to the fullest extent possible is to restore competition to the market, not try to regulate the incumbents while keeping them as a monopoly/oligopoly. A set of regulations that gets you 8% of the benefit of actual competition can be a significant improvement from the status quo while still being by far the less effective solution.