5 ms·
This is great, and as good a place as any for the thread to sprawl from, so I'll ask: it depends on how you know the stock is going to shoot up the next day, ri
by tptacek 3y ago
This is great, and as good a place as any for the thread to sprawl from, so I'll ask: it depends on how you know the stock is going to shoot up the next day, right? Trading on private information isn't illegal, and there's a huge variety of ways to acquire private information at varying levels of confidence, and in a sense the purpose of the markets is to aggregate everyone's private information to estimate a price.
So a scenario I'm curious about:
Say you're, like, an employee at DataDog, and you're involved in a long-term M&A discussion with Cisco that you know is competitive (I've had the pleasure of witnessing one of these at Arbor Networks). Things are looking great, you've picked up a bunch of strong signals that Cisco is definitely going to make a move, and then: the talks fall apart.
Knowing Cisco, you immediately reach the logical conclusion that they're about to acquire your biggest competitor.
You have no fiduciary duty to Splunk whatsoever. Cisco is, if anything, hostile. Buying Splunk options that are valuable only if Cisco acquires doesn't impact DataDog at all.
Have you violated insider trading laws if you buy the options?
- function_seven 3y agoI love this hypothetical. It’s a kind of “triangulation” of insider info, and I have no idea what the prevailing legal theory is. But I’m willing to bet that there is a Matt Levine article that discusses a real world scenario that mirrors this…
- tfehring 3y agoThat practice has been referred to recently as "shadow (insider) trading". It's an actively evolving area of case law, but the SEC's opinion is yes, see https://wp.nyu.edu/compliance_enforcement/2022/01/19/sec-v-panuwat-shadow-trading-under-insider-trading-law/ https://wp.nyu.edu/compliance_enforcement/2022/01/19/sec-v-p... Or Matt Levine on the same case: https://archive.ph/5Dlmw https://archive.ph/5Dlmw
- tptacek 3y agoOh, neat! I hadn't read this, but my hypo is literally case (3). His answer: "who knows?". Excellent. In my hypo and his, the origin of the private information I've acquired is still business my employer has conducted, so there's a better-than-baseline probability that the SEC would see this as misappropriation --- even if my employer wasn't directly going to trade on this, or if it was hard to trace any harm to my employer, it's still potentially not OK for me to profit from it.
- growse 3y agoThe thing where it gets murky though is that the theft argument needs someone to be stolen from, or defrauded. In classical insider trading, the victims are the investors in the M&A target. I'm misappropriating MNPI about the target, so I'm essentially defrauding the target's investors. In the "shadow" case, I think it's a harder argument to make. If I work for a potential Cisco M&A target that falls through (as per the GPP), I've got, MNPI about my org, and probably MNPI relating to Cisco. Can I defraud Splunk's investors with that?
- thisisit 3y agoinsider trade? Maybe not. Unethical? Yes. IANAL but this can be grounds for firing and potentially DataDog can sue for misusing what is effectively their confidential information.
- shortrounddev2 3y agoWhat's unethical about it
- ghaff 3y agoYou’re using confidential information obtained in the course of your work duties for personal gain. I’m pretty sure my employer would consider that a business conduct violation.
- eastdakota 3y agoBut that’s easy to solve for to get to the crux of the issue: what if you realized it and then, on behalf of and with the blessing of your employer traded on the information?
- shortrounddev2 3y agoI'm sure it's against the rules but why is it unethical
- ghaff 3y agoBecause you’re abusing your professional position and employer’s trust for personal gain.
- shortrounddev2 3y agoI don't see how, but more importantly I don't see who this harms
- 3y ago
- eastdakota 3y agoThink the super unsatisfying answer is: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I think a lawyer would advise that that trade would come with a ton of risk. But the law isn’t clear. Generally, the SEC’s goal is to make sure markets are “fair.” What makes a market fair is hard to define. If you do a ton of work to launch satellites to fly over Walmart parking lots and then model the correlation of how full they are to what the company’s next earnings will be: that seems like you worked hard and earned an edge you can trade on without getting in trouble. Feels like anyone has a theoretically equal opportunity to do the same work you did and get the same trading edge. That feels fair. Your hypothetical feels less fair. Is it unfair? Maybe? So unfair that it’d be prosecuted? Probably depends on a number of things, including how much you made on the trade. At a minimum it’s an area of unsettled law. And you would almost certainly be in for serious scrutiny and a legal fight. Supposedly one idea for Google’s business model early on was that they should use search query data to trade equities. After they researched it they concluded it would be considered insider trading. Though it’s hard to distinguish from overhearing something on the train, which (not legal advice) generally has not been. Think the difference at some level is scale and intention. And, I’d guess, if you made it your business to ride the Acela every day between Greenwich and NYC, bought special hearing aides that let you better eavesdrop on conversations, and made significant profits trading on the information then you’d be more likely to be successfully prosecuted. But… how is that different from flying satellites over Walmart parking lots? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Sometimes the law is intentionally a bit unclear. Usually in areas like this where you care about a general concept of fairness and want some caution and buffer at the margins.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoSo since you mention Wal-Mart. They have, probably, a better idea of Proctor&Gamble's quarterly sales than anybody but P&G, right? Like Walmart makes some massive double digit percentage of sales of p&g products, and knows about it possibly in real-time. If I was some data analyst at Walmart,I couldn't trade on that, that's misappropriation. But Walmart could potentially spin up a hedge fund and trade (against) their suppliers, until their suppliers threaten to pull product, I think? Presumably there's a contract between Walmart and p&g that they won't trade in each other's stocks, specifically to prevent this?
- kobalsky 3y agoyou can have an idea of what will happen but the timing is really important. options change price considerably depending on the length of the contract, this required surgical precision.
- jldugger 3y ago> Say you're, like, an employee at DataDog, and you're involved in a long-term M&A discussion with Cisco that you know is competitive (I've had the pleasure of witnessing one of these at Arbor Networks). Things are looking great, you've picked up a bunch of strong signals that Cisco is definitely going to make a move, and then: the talks fall apart. I don't know about the law, but where I work insider trading policies also applies to vendor and supplier stocks. Trading on that info would cost me a job, at the least.