3 ms·
This used to be what everybody in Germany had to do to open a bank account or request a new credit card, until the alternative of KYC by video call became popul
by lxgr 3y ago
This used to be what everybody in Germany had to do to open a bank account or request a new credit card, until the alternative of KYC by video call became popular.
It's not efficient by any means, but in my view it beats the US practice treating an SSN as a password, together with bizarre "security questions" sourced from public records that some banks use as a "verification method". And no, "phone number verification" (that really only works for phone numbers with the big three mobile carriers) should also never have been a thing.
I really, really hope to see a usable-by-everyone identification method one day, as opposed to "usable by enough", with a sizable fraction of the population just being denied access to credit, banking, and more, just because they don't exist in the expected form in some creepy data miner's database.
Ironically, German ID cards support exactly such a method: You can just tap it on your iOS or Android phone for a "qualified electronic signature" as defined by EU law. And as a non-citizen, you can now finally get an "e-ID only" card, so nobody is excluded from that scheme! Unfortunately, I don't know a single person that remembers their six-digit PIN that's required for that feature...
- cesarb 3y ago> Unfortunately, I don't know a single person that remembers their six-digit PIN that's required for that feature... IIRC, enabling that feature is optional (disabled by default), and if you never enabled it, you don't even have that six-digit PIN.
- lxgr 3y agoAs far as I know, it's now mandatory, i.e. you'll receive a random PIN in the mail after requesting a new ID card whether you want to use it or not.
- overlordalex 3y agoThat's if you even got a pin in the first place! I discovered this recently when I wanted to use the gloriously named AusweisApp2 (ID app 2, superseding a PC app which was at least forward thinking enough to be called ID app 1). In theory it's simple to request a new pin - you can even do it within the app! However I've moved since I acquired the card, and so instead of the reset mails going to my registered address, I can only assume they went to the address stored on the card. And in a catch-22 of course you can only update that with a pin... But no worries, you can simply book an appointment at your nearest buergeramt to have a pin reset in person; except there are no free slots in the next 3 months.. anywhere! I needed documents for a new visa, which should give me a new card (and hopefully a new pin!), which ultimately turned out to be faster to do than trying to sort out the damn pin
- hellotheretoday 3y agoA fun anecdote from those “security questions” I bought pet insurance at one point for a dog and now I regularly get quizzed on pet names when I get those questions. It will be things like “have you ever owned a pet by the name of a b c” and the answers are absurd because they are pet names. The best one was Ulysses S Twinkletoes. I still have a screenshot of that years later
- miki123211 3y agoPoland does this too, if you want to create a trusted profile (essentially an SSO account for government services), in-person verification at a post or municipal office is an option. A far more popular option is logging in via your bank, which is an excellent idea IMO, as they already have your data anyway and can usually verify that it's you with fairly high confidence.
- lxgr 3y ago> A far more popular option is logging in via your bank The US has that too, in a way – I've once had a call center agent of a prospective new bank call my existing bank and have _them_ verify my identity on the line! Of course, that identification then was also only the usual "what's your dog's zodiac sign" and "which gives you more goose bumps, nails on chalkboard or fingers on unpainted concrete".
- seanw444 3y agohttps://www.id.me/ https://www.id.me/
- lxgr 3y agoI know that one (and use it for IRS stuff!), but I have yet to find a single bank that actually uses that, rather than "give us your SSN, address, and a list of three states in which you don't own property"...
- nicbou 3y agoThese systems are remarkably hostile to recent immigrants. PostIdent (go to post office, get verified, send confirmation by mail) does not support Indian passports, among many others. The video replacement has the same flaw. You are legally entitled to a bank account, but a large portion of immigrants are left out. Many banks now require a plastic residence permit. In Berlin it takes a few months to arrive. How do you pay your rent while you wait? The residence permit is an eID, but I don't know anyone who activated it. You get an activation code weeks before the permit arrives, but it doesn't explain why it's useful and the activation requires an in-person visit somewhere. So I'm told; I have not activated mine. Soon they want to use the eID for the address registration. This would save everyone an in-person appointment... except immigrants who must register long before they get a residence permit. Fortunately, there are old Germans who must also be accounted for, so old-fashioned bureaucratic services exist in parallel. France allegedly has a good method: the postal worker knocks at your door and verifies your identity.
- hef19898 3y agoHow do ypu pay your rent? Good question, but I have an even better one: How do you get your salary without a bank account in the first place? As a side note, it is kind of funny when Indians complain about German bureaucracy.
- rafram 3y agoSay what you want about Indian bureaucracy, but Aadhaar is a good example of a system that’s been designed to be accessible to every single segment of society, even people with minimal documentation or little access to technology at home. EU bureaucracy (and German bureaucracy in particular) doesn’t even try.
- nicbou 3y agoI'm not Indian, but I help people immigrate for a living. There is no straight answer. It's just complicated. You either send money through another channel, or choose from a smaller selection of banks until you get a residence permit. I can't answer so easily because I opened my account 8 years ago and things got harder since then.
- YeBanKo 3y agoWhy is it not efficient though? How many times do you need to open an bank account? Once every few years. And I think you need to do it once to establish a relationship, once you have it, opening an additional account would not require another trip. Seems reasonable and secure.
- lxgr 3y ago> How many times do you need to open an bank account? Once every few years. This is exactly why European banks aren't offering market-level deposit interest rates. KYC friction like this introduces a huge market entry barrier. It should be perfectly normal to open a new bank account with a new bank online!
- YeBanKo 3y agoThe US banks aren’t exactly eager to offer market level interest rate either. KYC has very little to do with deposit interest rate. They don’t have to, so they don’t.
- pests 3y ago> together with bizarre "security questions" sourced from public records I just had one the other day give me a multiple choice option for the last 4 digits of my SSN. The same SSN I had free form typed into a box a half page up.