8 ms·
Thoughts on how this will get us towards when libre software privacy&security type people are ready to advise friends to move to Matrix for personal communicati
by neilv 3y ago
Thoughts on how this will get us towards when libre software privacy&security type people are ready to advise friends to move to Matrix for personal communication?
(To be clear, the platform has to be all open source and open standards, actually decentralized, guided by those principles -- not an effectively proprietary play even if nominally open. For example, you should be able to get all the same functionality with Element, Fluffychat, Thunderbird, and other user agents, and with any home server, both now and on an ongoing basis. And the user agent implementation difficulty should become tractable enough, in terms of size&complexity and specification, that one person could write a new one -- not like Web browsers have become, where there's mainly only one, that company has been funding the runner-up, and that company can pretty much dictate 'standards'.)
- Arathorn 3y agoMatrix 2.0 is a major step towards getting friends & family on Matrix. Firstly, it's not introducing new features - it's just making the current featureset work super-efficiently (while retaining compatibility with today's Matrix). So there should be no fragmentation between Element/Fluffychat/Thunderbird, with the possible exception of the new scalable encrypted VoIP conferencing (but then very few Matrix clients implemented the old VoIP conferencing, plus you can always just embed an Element Call instance to get at it now - as Element X does today). Secondly, we're explicitly working to protect Matrix from the commercial interests from Element (the company set up by the team who created Matrix, of which I'm ceo/cto as well as Matrix project lead). We already have The Matrix.org Foundation (https://matrix.org/foundation https://matrix.org/foundation) as an independent non-profit to hold the Matrix IP and maintain its neutrality - but we also just hired Josh Simmons (former President of the OSI) as its independent Managing Director (https://matrix.org/blog/2023/09/introducing-josh-simmons-managing-director/ https://matrix.org/blog/2023/09/introducing-josh-simmons-man...). So: going forwards, the Foundation increasingly does not have to depend on Element not being evil, but instead has its own independent management to ensure the protocol exists to support everyone in the ecosystem, without fragmentation, as per the guiding principles at https://matrix.org/foundation https://matrix.org/foundation - under its own autonomy. I'd say this is is good news for libre software privacy & security type people, but then again I'm biased. Practically, the only thing getting in the way of getting friends & family on Matrix is that Element X requires fancy OIDC-native homeservers for registration, so newbies won't be able to use Element X to join Matrix yet. But the app itself should be an excellent way to get folks on board in the very near future.
- neilv 3y agoThank you for the comments. I'll keep my fingers crossed that this plays out well. > plus you can always just embed an Element Call instance That sounds like potentially a commercial embrace&extend&extinguish situation, which we need to avoid.
- Arathorn 3y agoYup, good call point, which is why we deliberately implemented two different independent group VoIP implementations - the one in Element Call (based on matrix-js-sdk) and the one in Hydrogen (based on hydrogen-web-sdk). Admittedly the new livekit-based implementation takes us back down to a single implementation for now, but in its defense it’s only a few weeks old (with e2ee). Hopefully others will spin up independent implementations rapidly - although right now it does introduce a potential commercial EEE situation… but from on LiveKit rather than Element. Eitherway, it’s something we’re painfully aware of… while also trying to ensure we find enough $ to pay for dev on Matrix (and Element) otherwise the whole thing collapses.
- em-bee 3y agoelement still has serious usability issues that need to be fixed before i can get friends or family on board. the way threads are displayed in the browser versions makes them hard to follow. in our hackerspace, where many are tech minded people, i see regular complaints about that. scrollback to unread messages often fails. i have never had another chat application where that was a problem. this should just work. the handling of encryption keys is very confusing. there are to many moving parts, it's not clear what i must save so that i can restore the keys in a new client. private rooms are also confusing. i want to have a private room be the name of my chat partner, and they want it to carry my name. being able to do that would be very helpful. i am also missing the ability to use a different nickname in every room. different groups know me under different nicknames. discord and wechat can do it. it would be great if matrix/element could do that too.
- mike-cardwell 3y agoEncryption in Matrix is a nightmare. I set up Synapse and pulled half a dozen or so people onto it. We have a few chat rooms. Randomly different users clients are unable to decrypt the messages of other users clients. You click some button about syncing encryption keys, and nothing happens. Then randomly a week later you can start reading each others messages again. shrug This has been going on for years now. This alone makes Matrix the worse chat platform out there from a users perspective IMO. I invested too much effort in getting things up and running and using it now though, so I'm just hoping that this gets fixed one day, or something better comes along that I can migrate to.
- kevincox 3y agoFWIW my partner and mother are using it. We have had the occasional key synchronization issue with Element but has been mostly smooth sailing. I did walk them both through the setup but they probably could have managed. However they have some basic tech skills. I suspect that others in my family with little tech literacy would need to have it set up for them but would probably be fine after that.
- sneak 3y agoOne of the big problems as I see it is that all notifications on iOS must be proxied via APNS and those can only be sent by the app publisher, so all home servers must send their iOS notifications to Vector (the Element publishers) to be sent to APNS and on to an iPhone or iPad. This is a centralized point for surveillance of metadata. I also do not know how much information is actually contained in the notification itself. In any case Vector has knowledge of every home server with an iOS client, and their approximate traffic levels.
- Aerbil313 3y agoThen everyone should just roll out their own app… this seems like an EU-regulation-needed situation.
- sneak 3y agoThis requires paying about $10/month to Apple and doxxing yourself with a lot of PII. It also requires that you as a homeserver sysadmin a) have a Mac, b) install Xcode, c) know how to modify and compile iOS applications, d) want to deal with rebuilding and reuploading and re-seeking app approval on major API changes because long-un-updated apps are not allowed in the App Store, etc...
- inhumantsar 3y agoSecurity, Convenience, and Speed will always be in constant tension. If you start by assuming that a perfect solution will always be unattainable, deciding on what tradeoffs are acceptable becomes easier. Imho it almost always going to be worth trading the large PITA of self-managing APNS infra for the small surface area that routing push notifications through Elements systems.
- sneak 3y agoThis comment makes it seem like Apple's anticompetitive stance on sideloading is a basic force of nature instead of something dreamed up by control freak hippies and implemented deliberately in code. The problem is iOS's privacy-hostile design (in service of their locked down revenue model), not some unbreakable iron triangle. On Android, messaging apps can run in the background and periodically talk to their homeserver without an intermediary.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]