3 ms·
It’s a BS definition but not quite that BS: “one mile from a supermarket in urban or suburban areas and more than 10 miles from a supermarket in rural areas”
by Retric 3y ago
It’s a BS definition but not quite that BS:
“one mile from a supermarket in urban or suburban areas and more than 10 miles from a supermarket in rural areas”
The initial idea was urban areas are often mostly served by small convenience stores with high markups and few choices. However, being able to walk or use public transport can both work it’s really more a question of effort not distance.
- bombcar 3y agoOne mile is pretty darn low, even for suburban. I’m technically not in a food desert because there is a grocery store a block away. But if it were to explode, I’d suddenly be in a desert because the next grocery store (Walmart) is 1.2 miles away at the end of a nice bike path. I don’t even know if a grocery store’s customers can fit within a one mile radius circle without urban density.
- runako 3y agoDeciding that a mile is low is a top-down analysis. But if you've ever walked a mile to a store to buy groceries, you'll quickly conclude that much further is not really a viable foot journey to buy groceries.
- dahfizz 3y agoBut nobody is walking in a suburban town. This definition makes basically all suburbs a food dessert, even though the grocery store is only a few minutes from most people's house.
- runako 3y ago> nobody is walking in a suburban town I guess YMMV on this one. When I drive through suburbs, there are always people walking there. Watch especially how the staff arrives at your suburban stores & restaurants.
- dahfizz 3y agoOkay, to be more pedantic - the vast vast majority of people living in suburbs have access to a car and do not consider a 2 mile drive to the grocery store an inconvenience. To say these people live in a food dessert is silly. You are very clever to point out that people can actually walk around in a suburb, doesn't change the point.
- runako 3y ago> the vast vast majority of people living in suburbs This conversation is by definition about people living on the margins. Similarly, the "vast vast majority" of people do not qualify for SNAP. Pointing out that most people don't live on the margins is clever, but not particularly relevant, in a discussion about people who live at the very edge of society.
- Retric 3y agoFood deserts are more about human health than people living on the margins. Easy access to healthy food doesn’t guarantee people will eat it, but it dramatically increases the odds. If the closest and most convenient place to buy food is a grocery store then it’s a moot point.
- bombcar 3y agoI suspect that food deserts are also an attempt to explain certain health issues in certain areas, but I'm not entirely convinced that "adding grocery stores" will solve those issues. In other words, we have two things, and want to make one the cause of the other, but that's not entirely clear. Maybe the grocery stores die in areas where the population doesn't frequent grocery stores for whatever reason, or maybe people don't frequent grocery stores because they died, or maybe a mix of both.
- Retric 3y agoSolving isn’t the only possibility, adding grocery stores may improve things without actually fixing things. A 54.3% obesity rate is horrific even if it’s better than a 53.7% one. In public policy the question is generally if something has a measurable impact, and if that impact is worth the investment. Multiple small but very cheap improvements may be better than large but extremely expensive ones.
- Retric 3y agoWalking 1.2 miles down a bike path is also easier than 0.8 miles through urban areas without sidewalks. It seems clear the default was chosen to use round numbers, be easy to calculate, and make the issue seem more important. Stricter criteria mean fewer people fall into the category, but it also means those people have more significance challenges.
- ghaff 3y agoI’m urban by census definitions though I certainly don’t look it. I’m also not really rural in spite of living on several acres in a town with a few thousand people. Certainly I couldn’t walk or take transit to a grocery store at all reasonably. But I’d laugh if you told me I lived in a food desert. I also couldn’t reasonably live where I am at all without a car or regular assistance.
- bombcar 3y agoThere is some fast and loose with "urban" and "rural" - most people consider New York to be Urban, Los Angeles to be Urban, and anywhere outside of the suburbs to be rural - but the census counts anything as urban that is "populated": To qualify as an urban area, the territory identified according to criteria must encompass at least 2,000 housing units or have a population of at least 5,000. https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/geography/guidance/geo-areas/urban-rural.html https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/geography/guidance/g... Many people would consider small towns "rural" but if the town is small enough, it can be an entirely "walkable" "urban" area - because there's a walmart, a gas station, and a hospital, all in a town that is less than a mile across.
- ghaff 3y agoYeah. My town has a population of 7,000 and is within an hour of Boston. I also have a Christmas tree farm on one side and an apple orchard and horse farm on the other. 75 acres in all and probably over 100 acres when you add some conservation land. Not what most people consider urban. But we don’t have a meaningful commercial area at all in the town. And I’m not walking anywhere except recreationally in the woods.
- tzs 3y agoNearly everybody is getting the definition of "food desert" wrong. It varies somewhat depending on who is defining it but for non-rural areas it is generally along the lines of a low income area with no sources of affordable healthy food within walking distance or reasonably affordable public transit distance and most people don't have other good transportation options. Places where nearly everyone has a working car and can generally afford gas, whether rural or not, generally won't be food deserts unless stores selling affordable healthy food are all pretty far away.
- dahfizz 3y agoThe problem is the definition of "urban or suburban". The census classifies any town of 5000 (!!!) people or more as urban. I live in a small town of more than 5000 people, so it's technically urban. It takes me 5 minutes to get to the grocery store, but it's technically more than a mile so I am in a food dressert even though I have easy access to fresh produce.