3 ms·
The sexual assault allegations have not been put to law because every victim realizes that (a) it's a deeply miserable experience having to describe what happen
by pjc50 3y ago
The sexual assault allegations have not been put to law because every victim realizes that (a) it's a deeply miserable experience having to describe what happened to you over and over again, (b) a load of people will call you a slut on social media, (c) it may impair your chances of ever getting work again, and (d) if people don't believe you you may get countersued.
Courts and police are terrible at dealing with this stuff. That's the lesson of Weinstein, Savile, Rotherham, etc.
See e.g. David Carrick, Met police officer, who after 17 years was finally prosecuted and admitted guilty to 85 offences, after the Met had a brief outbreak of taking this stuff seriously after Wayne Couzens, another police officer was jailed for the murder of Sarah Everard.
- jjgreen 3y agoAre you then suggesting that allegations suffice? That there is no need for "innocent until proven guilty" in the face of such allegations?
- jwestbury 3y agoI think the point is that this is a particularly fraught area of discussion, and that the "best" approach may not be the one which is legally enshrined, because the legally enshrined approach is severely flawed in its ability to actually address sexual assault. Whether that means we should treat allegations as proof is a related but -- I think -- separate question.
- jjgreen 3y agoSome kind of extralegal response then?
- pjc50 3y agoThat standard is required for criminal sanctions, but it is not required for private parties to change who they freely associate with, who are free to take a more balance-of-probabilities approach. I'm free to say that he's probably a rapist, because I'm not a court of law and I have free speech. (The irony is that Brand spends all the time on his youtube channel making unsubstantiated and probably false allegations about all sorts of public figures such as Bill Gates)
- jjgreen 3y agoI'm free to say that he's probably a rapist, because I'm not a court of law and I have free speech. I really hope that you're not in the UK, if you are you've just exposed yourself to a libel suit which could cost you your house, and that obnoxious turd has enough money already.
- snehk 3y agoYes, let the mob decide. Frontier justice is clearly the way to go because the current system has flaws.
- Turing_Machine 3y ago> Courts and police are terrible at dealing with this stuff. Perhaps, but not as terrible as self-appointed "activist" lynch mobs.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoIt's a mark of where we are that "lynch mobs are a bad idea" has become open to debate. And not a good one.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoThanks for demonstrating my point.