5 ms·
I think this is a somewhat strange way to put together a conclusion. A lot of cybercrime comes from India. A handful of cities are overrepresented in when it co
by saagarjha 3y ago
I think this is a somewhat strange way to put together a conclusion. A lot of cybercrime comes from India. A handful of cities are overrepresented in when it comes to software engineering talent. So it seems natural that a lot of people, both good and bad, would be concentrated there? It would be like a report that says "25% of financial crime in the US comes from New York City": well, duh, that's because all the financial activity happens there.
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoThe article confounds cybercrime and the IT industry. People working out of offices in Indian cities are not criminals since they work for legitimate businesses; the concentration of scam operations in said cities is not related to the presence of the IT industry, nor would scammers allocate resources inefficiently by buying office space, which isn’t required to run a criminal enterprise and may be detrimental by way of drawing attention and scrutiny which would have been avoided otherwise. (Downvoters may want to address the problems with my comment; although I feel this is an issue which people feel strongly about, so a rational analysis is often foregone in the pursuit of vindication.)
- mattw2121 3y agoMy understanding of scammers in India has been formed by Youtube videos, where the host "scams the scammer", and from the Reply All podcast (https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/6nh3wk https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/6nh3wk). Saying that scammers do not buy office space doesn't seem correct. Are you saying they wouldn't buy (or lease/rent) office space? If so, the Youtube videos and Reply All directly contradict that.
- spacecadet 3y agoEven "mobs" operated as legit businesses. Agreed, to suggest some of the criminals would not attempt the same ruse is nieve.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoSome rich businessmen in India are implicated in these scams as well. That is, they operate legit businesses on the whole, but, say, have a floor in a high rise of theirs that’s a scammer call center.
- Hikikomori 3y agoFrom what I've seen of every phone scammer case they're in an office and look like a normal call centre.
- xiaodai 3y agowhy can't these talents just find normal jobs
- mkagenius 3y agoMost of these crimes hardly require talent. It's just social engineering the tech illiterates or even the unsuspecting literates. > Another finding in the report was that of all reported cyber crimes in India, almost half (47.25 percent) involved Unified Payments Interface (UPI) fraud. Debit, credit card and sim swap fraud came in a distant second place with 11.27 percent. Overall, financially motivated crime accounted for 77.41 percent of incidents. Talented criminals are rare. And those talents mostly go behind bars while the above criminals loom at large.
- joshxyz 3y agoand they pay is usually better than other companies easy to get in, low skill requirements, good pay
- ttyyzz 3y agoyou forgot one big thing in your list. the downside, which imo outweighs the benefits. being a criminal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cdchn 3y agoLess of a problem when corruption is rampant and you can pay off the police.
- H8crilA 3y agoAnd the upside can be enormous. There's a huge amount of very poor people in India. For example only a few years ago everyone finally got a toilet in their house. Stealing $500 from a slightly demented grandma that is afraid about her medical insurance "running out" can be a lot to them.
- ergl 3y ago> It would be like a report that says "25% of financial crime in the US comes from New York City" Boy do I have the project for you: https://thenewinquiry.com/white-collar-crime-risk-zones/ https://thenewinquiry.com/white-collar-crime-risk-zones/
- morbidious 3y agoI was not sure how you concluded that "A lot of cybercrime comes from India". But looking through the same lens as the example you provided, it makes sense that since 1.4 billion people stay in India, it is natural for the volume of cybercrime to be high.
- geodel 3y ago> It would be like a report that says "25% of financial crime in the US comes from New York City" Yes, and it would interesting to know for lot of people. I wouldn't mind T-shirts with NYC :: BFC front and on back BFC expanded to (Big Financial Crimes).
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoI think the definition of cyber crime is what is important here. I think there are huge buildings with call centers in India dedicated to cyber crime. Thousands of people. Nothing to do with tech skills. Here is Mark Rober basically bringing the war to their shores with incredible pranks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xsLJZyih3Ac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xsLJZyih3Ac
- _kwef 3y agoI think you have a misconception of where cybercrime truly is concentrated in India. I think its more in the villages, some of which actually organise "crash courses" for youth that wish to make a career out of this [1]. Personal anecdote but I've witnessed cybercrime being done in various towns in some of India's biggest states, and they attract youth that would otherwise have been working in their family farms, etc.
- southernplaces7 3y ago>youth that wish to make a career out of this [1]. and your link for 1?
- subtra3t 3y agoOops, sorry for not including the link. I could've sworn I'd included that in. Anyways here's your link: https://www.indiatoday.in/magazine/nation/story/20160808-cyber-crime-jamtara-jharkhand-829309-2016-07-27 https://www.indiatoday.in/magazine/nation/story/20160808-cyb... And before anyone says such towns only account for a small proportion of all cybercrimes, the Union Home Secretary Rajiv Gauba has himself acknowledged that this one town alone was responsible for more than half of all cybercrimes (where the fraudster was posing as a bank manager) [1] [1] - https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/current-affairs/010618/this-town-in-jharkhand-is-the-cybercrime-capital-of-india-jamtara.html https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/current-affairs/01061...